Equitable banking PDF Print E-mail
Written by Peter Ndiangui   
Thursday, 26 April 2007

In the last year, Equity Bank has grown from a small, hardly heard of establishment to a large bank that is in many ways leading the market and causing something of a revolution in the banking sector. Tribute must be paid to the vision and resilience of the Muranga farmers who came together to moot the community building society idea and to the leadership of Peter Munga and his successors. This vision that targets the small depositors is now leading rival banks like Barclays and Standard Chartered to rethink their evaluation of the lower end of the market.

munga.jpg Equity's persistent efforts have proved that there is black ink at the bottom of the rung. In the event, the customer has benefited as even proud Barclays has been compelled to slash its banking costs and accede to the forces of banking democratization, a path previously shunned and left as scraps for the likes of Equity.

 It is doubtable however that Barclays and Stanchart's cultures will be agreeable to the implementation of the business models that have seen the smaller banks succeed at this level.

The big banks undoubtedly have the financial resources to execute every strategy they may conjure to out-muscle their smaller competitors but they lack the human capital necessary for micro-finance banking. Previously these banks held sway in convenience service delivery technologies such as ATMs but with the emergence of Pesa-Point this advantage was lost. Now even members of SACCOs have access to ATM facilities and this at prices lower than they would be burdened with at the mainstream banks. This advantage was also set back by the alliance of the small banks in a consortium that led to the creation of their own payment exchange infrastructure

 In terms of values, not as a 'moral ideal ' but in terms of organizational mores; Barclays and Standard value their big 'prestige' corporate customers so much that the optimization of their services is specifically targeted at this clientele. Their organizational cultures are prejudiced towards those who seek exclusive banking services unavailable to the ordinary mwananchi.

 As for processes; the cost-structures in the service models of the largest banks are oriented to the premium banking consumers with a floor of 10,000/- in their accounts plus deposits. Compared to the service delivery cost-model delivering the same service to a consumer who barely affords to maintain the 200/- deposit, it becomes clear that the Barclays model cannot be quickly tweaked. Customer service at the largest banks is innately poor with regard to the non-banked.

The revolution however is not restricted to this struggle between the traditional banks and those with micro-credit histories. Other players coming up in the country threaten the existence of even the versatile and innovative micro-finance firms like Equity. These organizations offer services beyond debt instruments. Examples include South Africa's Business Partners International and GroFin East Africa. These South-African enterprises that are targeting SME's that need capital as well as management expertise for grow. At the centre of their value-proposition is that in most Kenyans SMEs, capital access has been the not been the only impediment to success. Management expertise is a chronic problem where SMEs resulting in SMEs not reaching their growth potential. These firms offer to take equity positions in small firms while providing management expertise. This two in one package will compel the industry's main players to come up with similar products especially as these small businesses are much valued across the sector.

equity.jpg The battle lines are not just with the traditional banks or the South Africans but extend to within the world of the micro-credits itself. Family Finance has just last week had Central Bank approval to operate as a bank. These former micro-lenders come into the market with solid years of experience dealing with micro-borrowers and depositors. They also have solid earnings and corporate governance practices that were honed during the difficult period of their growth.

The battle for banking Kenyans, both individual consumers and businesses will be fought on the basis of some key value-propositions that banks will have to satisfy. The customer demands,

a. Help me save my money with minimal cost even when I need it

b. Help me grow and manage my money at the best price

c. Help me acquire an asset at the best price

d. Help me grow my business - as an entrepreneur

e. Help me fund my expansion- for the established business seeking growth, perhaps even a listing.

It is in this field that market-share in the banking sector will be decided. Even if they do not come out as market leaders, these institutions have done a sterling job for the Kenyan consumer and deserve credit for their continued efforts to democratize banking.

 


Peter Ndiangui
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (9)add
0
...
written by aeichener , April 26, 2007
Kenyan banking so far is on a year 1900 level, as far as individual (consumer) customer disservice is concerned. I find it just disgusting.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Marangu , April 26, 2007
Nice piece of work Bw Ndiangui. While it's true the Kenyan Banking system lags behind as Alex observes, I have to agree with your analysis that lately a democratic transformation has occured and continues to occur. Sadly, even today people continue to choose Standard and Barclays over local banks purely based on prestige that comes at a cost they can ill afford. I find that the likes of Equity still have to put double the effort in customer care to gain some respectability, something not at all in the agenda of big banks. Kenyans need to prop up the likes of Equity and any other bank that relates to their realities.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by John Ongeri , April 26, 2007
Bw Peter Ndiangui does us a great service in highlighting the on going success of Equity and other small banks. This is very heartening and we should wish them every success. It is true that these small and upcoming banks must work twice as hard as the big giants at innovation, presentation and customer service if they are to win a share of the growing banking sector.

IMHO the big banks behave like complacent fat cats with their creed: Banking for the select. Why else have they raided the accounts of my poor wife and thousands of other small investors who had paid nothing into their accounts. Our meagre savings which was redundancy pay dropped to negative figures and today we owe these shylocks money.

A further problem that small banks face in their ongoing customer recruitment drive is investor confidence. People's attitudes my be changing but many remember the great banking disasters of the 80s and 90s which centred on the indigenous banks
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , April 26, 2007
Equity are really serious about reaching every last coin. This can only be a good thing, the recent announcements by Barclays that they will open an additional number of ATMs is in response to this expansion.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , April 27, 2007
Peter has written about SACCOs before. The article may be found here.

Does anyone know how Kenyan banks deal with non-traditional businesses, or with young people with no assets to put up for loans?
Joe,
The double negative in your comment has me in a terrible bind, care to clarify?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Marangu , April 27, 2007
Agree fully with Mr Ongeri's comments, and while we can blame the big banks for the nice ride they have had for so long, lets not forget this has happened under the stewardship of successive governments and to date, none of the Finance Ministers or anyone in power has seen it fit to put a stop to this melee.
So while Ndiangui's analysis indicates that banks like Equity will restore some equilibrium and hopefully some equitable access on a needs basis to banking, the government has a key role to play in promulgating necessary legislation.
So while we think of the coming elections, lets think of people who can address the current market failure in many sectors of our economy.... banking included.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Great insights
written by pndiangui , May 02, 2007
Thankyou for your insightful comments kenya imagine readers.
To further get a better thrust of this area we need to look abit deeper on the theories of disruptive innovation and mirror what we see today as hard data to them. To my analysis , this confirms a classical disuptive innovation by the micro-finance institutions in Kenya in the banking industry.
Some of the greatest impacts being the expansion of the banking industry from the previous ways that we knew it.

At this point I also would like to point out that Instead of the chinese copying Americans now they want to copy Kenya's own Equity Bank business model and as Mwangi (CEO of Equity Bank) put it , it is now becoming evident our own innovations can aslo begin shaping global economies
"The success of our model is a clear demonstration that Kenya is ready to own and drive her own economic agenda through innovation and implementation of home grown solutions to local development challenges,” he said.
Looking for example at Barcalys Kenya's website , you cant hep to discover the boring, static and un-attended site. For example they only have their 2003 annual report on the site!! , they are still talking about their 2005 graduate recruitment exercise of having closed.
This shows an ignorant bank out of touch with the reality of the efficiency of web-banking much as the parent Barclays has been forced into adopting it.
Equity has seen its diaspora population rise and had to innovate to offer them a cheap way to access their money and transfer it to their relatives; Thus taking a lead with an online banking solution in the country. Much as Equity might have developed this soluiton to its diapora segment (which is no mean segment in terms of the size of the deposits) , the students, the youthful Kenyans will now experience of an efficient way to bank while the accelerated pace of ATM roll-out will together be easing the previously experienced long ques while putting it at the same footing in terms of ATM experience as the main-stream banks like Barcalys or standard that could have ealier claimed that this was their main competitive advantage.
Thus in essence targeting the mass market and the diaspora has in itself forced Equity to move with speed to increase efficiency to solve the problems of a large mass of low-margin clients, but solving these problems have resulted into some serious core competencies within this young bank. The diversity of its clients also puts equity at a step forward more than Barcalys and any other mainstream bank.
Infact I am looking foward to their new strategy of becoming the bank of choice in the larger African region; A true African Multinational that has its roots with the Kenyan farmers.
Who said Kenyans cant become the African tiger if they are innovating, focussed in challenging the services/products of 'big boys' from the 'West' as currently structured?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Equittable Bank
written by Edwin Gachinga Warima , June 18, 2007
Mr.Kihara Munga's vision 30 years ago to start a bank for the small farmer, ... what he has built into Equity Bank, is nothing short of award winning!
Equity Bank is known as the place to go to, if you want a quick 50,000-250,000 loan. Loan applications have been known to get approved and funds released in 24 hours, which is music to the kawaida Kenyan businessman. Compare this service to the bureaucracy to be expected at KCB,NBK,Barclays etc.
Hope this great bank sticks around for a long time.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
....and now the politicians hi
written by Kamale , July 24, 2007
Many people will have read in the media the recent negative media coverage that Equity Bank has been receiving especially with allegations of poor governance.

I am an avid newspaper reader, and sometimes I ask myself why I do this considering that I continually have a diminishing respect for our journalists, especially the quality of what they ask as to read. But like a cigarette, I find myself handing 70 bob to my newspaper vendor for my daily dose of the Nation and Standard. Recently I have found myself confused into buying the Business Daily, especially when I have to go for a mid morning meeting and expect to be kept waiting. I sometimes think it is a serious paper and I have found a bit of recycled material from the East African, which I buy on Sundays.

The Standard started off with what I initially thought was a well written story on the governance issues at Equity Bank. The fact that one of the directors had raised with the chairman certain issues she felt were of concern to her. I also read that following this she left the board of the bank. But I also read that the bank insituted an internal audit of the bank's governance problems and this was carried out by a firm of external auditors. The auditors did not find what the director had alleged but still managed to find other issues that needed attention by the board. The Central Bank also undertook an inspection of the bank and in the cacaphony of the noise in parliament issued a statement clearing the bank of any misdeeds.

One of the issues that have been persistently reported on is the matter of ownership. When Equity issued their statement that they intended to acquire 20% of HFCK, they made certain disclosures about their shareholding and one name came up, that of Jimnah Mbaru. There would have been no need to name Jimnah as his holding is through incorporated companies where he has an interest.

As we are all aware, Jimnah was previously connected with the failed Jimba Credit in the 80s when several locally owned financial institutions took a tumble. When their institutions were taken over by the government through Consolidated Bank, all the previous owners/shareholders of the failed banks were barred from owning or managing a financial institution for 10 years. There is no legal backing for this requirement apart from it being an undertaking that each of these people made for their institutions to be taken over by Consolidated.

It is therefore intriguing that a serious paper like the Business Daily will come us with this http://www.bdafrica.com/index....temid=5821. A good business journalist/editor will certainly know the distinction between a company and its owner. The fact that Jimnah has two companies each owning 5% of the shares of Equity simply means that in LAW, there are two distinct shareholders of the bank that are within the banking law for their respective holdings! Secondly, a simple check on the rule barring previous owners was actually dated, but the 10 years issurely so long ago for this journalist to remember!

There have been several postings in Kenya Imagine that have pointed out at the quality of our journalism, and equally the dangers associated with the kind of reporting that we constantly see. The media in their reporting could create a rush on a bank like Equity with dire consequences on the lives of thousands of Kenyans.

Mine is not to exonerate the bank if it is doing dirty deals, but the media owe Kenyans a duty of responsibility in their reporting!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 26 April 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2008 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  the Six Degrees Media Company