Co-ops and Saccos; drivers for growth. PDF Print E-mail
Written by Peter Ndiangui   
Sunday, 11 March 2007

Kenya has the most profoundly developed cooperative movement in Africa , one with great potential to contribute to an economic revolution.

Many Kenyans are oblivious to the impact that cooperatives have had on our economy, but they are doubtlessly familiar with some of the following:

  • The Cooperative Bank
  • The Cooperative Insurance Company
  • Teachers Saccos
  • Matatu Saccos Associations
  • Equity Bank - Before a building society
  • Kenya Cooperative Creameries
  • Kenya Planters Cooperative Union

For all the praise in the world, Kenya's co-ops are not exactly having the time of their lives. What ails them and how can they be returned to influence?

As the Kenya Bus Service (KBS) was going under, Kenyan Saccos had over 130 billion shillings mobilized as savings. While roads in Kenya are in dire need of expansion and repairs funded by tax revenues and development aid,  Saccos sit on untold wealth that would almost literally pave the streets with gold. Other infrastructure projects that would turn around the country's economic fortunes like the communication fibre-optic cable remain incomplete even as savings in the form of 'Cooperative Infrastructure Bonds' could be used to serve the country's interests while earning a decent return for the Sacco members- a multiple blessing to the country as Sacco's wide memberships ensure a more democratic appreciation of national wealth gains.

All over the western world from primary financial markets to secondary financial markets, savings mobilization precedes other instruments of project financing including even debt. It is upon the expectation of future cash-flows that debt is leveraged or equity in a firm is staked by the stakeholders. To simplify this assertion; you lend somebody money with an expectation that they will afford to pay as per your covenant a minimum payment whether from their salaries, businesses revenues or from existing savings.

In this regard then, Saccos and cooperative members with known avenues of earning some cash and mobilizing it into savings would be at great advantage if such savings were loaned out or invested in projects that would offer superior rates of returns in a predictable fashion. In a country like ours, with an urgent need for an infrastructure revolution the government can turn these investments to the advantage of the many, offering to coop owners a better return on their investments than would otherwise be realized. For example, rather than have the Rift Valley Railways take a controlling stake in the Kenyan-Ugandan Railway, why not balance its stake with one from the Saccos?

To do this, however, legislation needs to be in place that would protect the cooperative members. Also some depth of education needs to be carried out along these lines. So far the cooperative college in Karen only offers education to Diploma level. Merging this institution or creating collaboration avenues with the universities would allow broader and deeper courses with degree awards at the end.. These would be geared towards producing efficient and savvy managers of cooperatives and Saccos. Indeed having several government funded finance/economics graduate candidates in masters or PhD level researchers study the application of Coop- Saccos resources in rapid economic development of our country could harness even greater potential than is presently conceived. Such homegrown solutions have been proved especially effective in other countries, for example the South Koreans strategy of funding the Chaebols and thus developing such global industrial giants such as Hyundai , Samsung and Daewoo.

In the West and especially the US, UK and Australia , venture capital firms, mutual funds and other institutional investors have been used by the pension holders funds institutions to allocate their mobilised savings from salaried employees to various investments through either debt instruments or taking up equity stakes in early stage ventures (usually the role played by venture capitalists in the US and other economies).

The power of secondary markets are harnessed through private buy-outs (where other corporations can buy in or have a joint-venture) ,whether on the New York Stock Exchange or in London's FTSE). Cooperatives and Saccos in our country represent such 'mobilised savings stop shops', but much of their resources are only utilized by members borrowing amongst themselves. There is nothing wrong with this as such,but this wealth could be further utilised if the portfolios were expanded into taking direct stakes in other SME's, Real-Estate development (which has been done to some extent) and provision of Debt instruments to government infrastructure projects.

This obviously requires expertise in investment management, a capacity that needs to be developed. For example, the Kenya Coffee Planters Union (KPCU) has for years remained an exporter of raw-coffee even as there was an opportunity to mobilise members funds in creating a coffee processing entity and grow their brand internationally much like Nescafe and Starbucks have. Remaining at the raw-coffee dealer has only hurt its members when raw coffee prices fell due to over-supply by Vietnam and the fact that though unique, Kenya's Arabica coffee is not branded. Such strategies need to adopt a capitalistic approach balanced with the social cause that KPCU serves. In the same breadth KPCU through its regional or locally owned coffee processing cooperatives would have diversified coffee farmers savings by investing in other areas of the economy through the NSE or even taking direct stakes in companies such as Mumias or even rural energy provider entities -a venture that some KTDA facilities have gone into. These energy plants would be powered by coffee husks which may alternatively be used to develop organic fertilizer brands.

Such measures would have seen a continued quality of life enhancement of its members who after the 1980' coffee crash suffered huge losses and a drop in their quality of life. Farmers who previously had started building semi-permanent to permanent houses could not now even afford meals. Such adversity can be avoided in future if these cooperatives diversify at the mobilised-savings resource allocation level or in the industries they participate in by adopting more superior and efficient investments management strategies. To get this right, certain legislation is necessary as is a deepening knowledge of how these strategies can be executed.

The onus is upon the ministers of Finance , Planning and that of cooperatives to take up this challenge and their bureaucrats to create a new economic order in rural Kenya.


Peter Ndiangui
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (11)add
0
...
written by Newafroguy , March 12, 2007
Absolutely!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
The vehicles are elsewhere!
written by Kamale , March 12, 2007
I think you have a wrong notion on the grounds upon which our SACCOS flourish in Kenya.

SACCOS in Kenya are the only answer to the high interest rates that banks charge. Consequently they are a vehicle for savings with the aim of borrowing as the principal motivation of membership. Towards this end, many Kenyans have over the years benefitted with being empowered to take up development activities that improve their lot. These are achievements that would not have been possible if the co-operative movement was not active in Kenya. You can imagine borrowing at 12% whilst the banks were charging 29% and the effect it had in diverting savings from the mainstream banking sector to the co-operative movement.

You have suggested that with the movement sitting on 130 billion, this money can be used to improve the infrastructure through co-operative infrastructure bonds. Unfortunately, this runs counter to the aims of most co-operatives which are as I said above are premised on a save and borrow scheme.

The mobilisation you talk about will be achieved through the flourishing of investment clubs which it is estimated could be controlling close to 12 billion shillings if you remove the older clubs such as Heri and Transcentury! I am aware of one such organisation that hopes to rope in 1000 members with an aim of raising 100 million shillings before the end of this year and I gather they have raised close to 40% of their target.

It is these investment clubs that will fill that gap that co-operatives cannot. These clubs are being used by people that want to grow their wealth as opposed to savings for borrowing.

These investment clubs have been investing heavily in the NSE and in other ventures that generate money for their members. Being a member of one, I cannot wait for the Bitange initiatives on the way especially with the gazettement of the Kenya Information and Communications Technology Board as a parastatal last month by Kibaki.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Tim Norwood , March 12, 2007
The writer is on to something. It really is an issue of greater returns. This article is not as radical as it seems. Coops and Saccos have been investing in real estate for a long time ( remember the Mwalimu Sacco next to the Co-Op bank in Nairobi's 1998 bomb blast?)

Surely, a leap from this into infrastructure development at higher rates is not too large a jump.

Kamale,
What will people be borrowing from the Saccos for? Investment or consumption, and if it is for investment, why not pool the resources into a sort of investment club ( still the Sacco) and tackle larger projects.

Seems to me this is something like the workings of a pension fund, pension funds, for example the California one that got burned at Enron, being of course among the largest investors in the NYSE.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Customizing our models
written by pndiangui , March 12, 2007
Kamale
Let me ask you a simple question ; were you happy when Equity bank was a building society or are you happy the way it has moved a notch up to be a bank? When was it more efficient in its service delivery? Much as it is a an innovation dillema continous improvement in a 'sustained' way is critical to improvement of service delivery in every entity. All am saying is that the Coops and saccos can be our customized 'mutual funds' in the rural areas.
As Tim says ; Why do the coops members borrow? The borrow to invest. Dont they? If they borrow to literally consume, then thats another thing altogether of which , the portfolio of the debt under consumption should be balanced with that under investments. It is the portfolio under investment that am proposing can be pulled together to give them a higher return on investment and at the same time contribute significantly in the deepening of financial markets in the country and the rapid development of infrastracture in our country.
As Tim Norwood has put it some of the investments am proposing are not radicle , some like real-estate have been done before including such visible ones like Mwalimu, Nyeri Teachers Sacco etc etc. Cooperative societies have their own investments ranging from KCC plants , KPCU coffee milling plants etc.
What am saying is that these investments have been effected by taking up some members contributions from say 'product delivery'. It is these contributions that I am saying can be increased abit and those funds channeled in a diversified manner together into other projects that can offer a higher ROI paid in quaterly or monthly periods according to their yields. And where they are channelled can be either into debt instruments that pay them an intrest rates such as special infrastructure bonds , Equity instruments that may range from primary equity market which might involve taking up equity in SME's or even in the coorperatives' own 'in-house bred' start-ups like I said KPCU engaging in organic fertilizer production or becoming the 'Nescafe' of Africa...the Market Dorman Coffee been enjoying. On the other hand the members contributions can be channeled up'North' into secondary markets that we all seem to know better; from NSE to Uganda stocks to Dar stocks markets etc or even in the more sophisticated secondary markets such as becoming majority stake-holders in buy-outs of other private or public firms. An example would be KPCU taking up Equity in Dormans Coffee or becoming the East African joint-Owner of StarBucks Franchise..such. (I remember cooperatives had tried to take up a stake in the 3rd mobile operator I dont know what went down). Lastly real-estate investment projects, which as much as that they have been done before, they havent been done as vigorous.....Infact if thought deeper these coops and sacco institutions can even spin-off rural Mortgage providers leveraging on farmers produce cash-flow to improve their quality of life.
These are complex products and services and cannot be effected overnight but they can have a serious impact on our economic growth. They would also improve the efficiency of coops and saccos even down to the chosen service providers in the value chain.
The problem with some of us here , think that 'farmers were born farmers and should always be farmers'.Its the mindset that rural kenyans cant be sophisticated investors and only 'us the urbane or 'educated'' , the 'investment' club members' who are sophisticated investors who will do these sorts of investments. Thats the cause of the wealth disparity in our country.
Like equity has done , taking the banking products to unbanked and then moving up to take on the yester-years 'sophisticated' banks like Barclays or stanchart, that's what I am proposing the Saccos and Coops can be empowered to do.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , March 13, 2007
Perhaps the issue is one of democracy. There are those like the current administration and Moi's who believe that the little man should stay poor, that more and more public compnaies should be give out to the already wealthy.

I am sure this is not the design, but that is how it ends up. The thing about Ndiangui's idea is that it widens this net. Suddenly even young professionals and lowly matatu touts can take a share in national growth; true ownership even if vicarioulsy through the Sacco.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Kamale , March 13, 2007
Peter,

The point I was making (appears I did a poor job!!) was to explain the genesis of your traditional Sacco like you have mentioned - Mwalimu Saccos being involved in real estate. As I said the Kenyan Sacco model is a save and borrow scheme. When the members borrow, the question is where they are taking their money. To most apart from being able to buy a small plot and then build a house, very few, if any, of the members borrow to get into speculative investment in money instruments.

You idea of mutual funds to get into money instruments is where I think the mushrooming investment clubs can fit in. These investors unlike the Sacco investors want a more interesting investment where they can take informed risks which your ordinaty Mwalimu Sacco cannot take as its leadership may not be sufficiently schooled into getting into the schemes you have suggested.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Lets go deeper
written by pndiangui , March 14, 2007
Instead of focussing of what I didnt say or I said lets get even get into some indepth work here.
Trying to see some of the legistrations that can be introduced inordr to to pre-empt a more prudent frame-work for the participation of these cooperatives and Saccos in larger deals that pursue better returns to the members benefits and to the greater good of the Kenyan public.
We dont have to demutualise all of these co-ops or Saccos but some might need to walk this route.In Australia Building societies and Credit Unions of the Self-Help era (like we have the self-help groups in our country today from where many Saccos have come from) have since 1992 when there was establishement of a new and prudent framework guided by Australian Finacial Institutions Commmision operated and expanded to even start rivalling the mainstream banks in their invetments products. This has happened at the most benefit of the members and Australian public who were able to own homes and expand ownership of other ventures through these mutually owned enitites. Some have demutualised and listed and this has delivered imnse welath to the members.
It might be good to review some of these issues to help us engage in a more productive debate issues for example in Australia .
A good point to note is that the Machakos Teachers Sacco has issued a statment that it intends to start issuing its members with Retirement savings products. This is significant and requires even more prudent framework for regulation but it also paves a way for the SACCOS to start looking for other sophisticated and sustainable investment vehicles.The once who will demutualise for example and become banks or Mortgage specialist providers will take up those members with them , increasing the banked in our country and increasing 'owners' of our country's mainstream economy. At the same time its good to note that Pesa-Point an outsourced ATM services provider in Kenya has found this area of Saccos as a rich growth area for its service, increasing the capability of these insitutions to provide some 'banking' services. Now we are saying ; can they move up into 'behaving' like investment banks not just like ATM Cards issuers ?
I think they can.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Its not a good to have
written by pndiangui , March 14, 2007
Kamale
Its not only just 'an intresting investment' , but its more productive and better win for the sacco member and for the country.
And it makes sense to lift up the sacco member and close the gap. Those investments are not only meant for the 'sophisticated' but if the Sacco member had an option to engage in them due to empowerment through re-training of the managers and instituting proper regulations , like I have said , they would be better off than just building those unproductive houses that dont provide for sufficient cashflow to them in as their life-time savings.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Some evidence
written by pndiangui , March 18, 2007
The cooperative bank performance underpins a mutually owned entity by coorperatives that is delivering top notch products in the country. Its
current perfomance
confirms that superior spin-offs can be done by the Saccos or coops , jointly amongst themselves or with other partners to deliver significant value.
Can these Nyeri matatu owners take up or take on KBS or even Michuki's 'city hoppa'? Why not with such sophistication. Will that be the beginning of a fair wealth distribution? I think so.

2.
The Nyeri Matatu Sacco , (2nk) has continued to chalk up profits for members as it takes up bigger opportunities and divesifies in its services range. A look at its current 1 billion project 1 billion project for vehicle upgrading and the involvement of some serious partnerships such as the General motors in pushing this project shows a growing sophisitcation in this sacco's investments management.
It has deepened its parcel delivery service to such a level as the DHL's of this world are feeling it as is postel. In the event of spinning off this business , that of insurance and the petroleum products dealership , corporitize them and list part of the ownership them in public markets would again take it a notch higher and position it for expansion in the COMESA and E.A markets. This is the kind of sophistication am touting and one that will deliver sacco members better results and quality of life.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Dairy coops thinking further
written by pndiangui , March 23, 2007
More information suggests that rural coops are also starting to see the new possibilities.
Some Six Coops in Nyeri have come together to form a Ltd entity that will process milk.
This might be the show of things to come.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
sacco
written by rahab , June 06, 2007
please let me know what sacco is best for me. Am employed but i dont earn much, female, 29 years
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Monday, 12 March 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company