Kenya has the most profoundly developed cooperative movement in Africa , one with great potential to contribute to an economic revolution.
Many Kenyans are oblivious to the impact that cooperatives have had on
our economy, but they are doubtlessly familiar with some of the
following:
-
The Cooperative Bank
-
The Cooperative Insurance Company
-
Teachers Saccos
-
Matatu Saccos Associations
-
Equity Bank - Before a building society
-
Kenya Cooperative Creameries
-
Kenya Planters Cooperative Union
For all the praise in the world, Kenya's co-ops are not exactly
having the time of their lives. What ails them and how can they be
returned to influence?
As the Kenya Bus
Service (KBS) was going under, Kenyan Saccos had over 130 billion shillings
mobilized as savings. While roads in Kenya are in dire need of expansion and repairs funded by tax
revenues and development aid, Saccos sit on untold wealth that would
almost literally pave the streets with gold. Other infrastructure
projects that would turn around the country's economic fortunes like
the communication fibre-optic cable remain incomplete even as savings
in the form of 'Cooperative Infrastructure Bonds' could be used to
serve the country's interests while earning a decent return for the
Sacco members- a multiple blessing to the country as Sacco's wide
memberships ensure a more democratic appreciation of national wealth
gains.
All over the western world from primary financial markets to secondary
financial markets, savings mobilization precedes other instruments of
project financing including even debt. It is upon the expectation of
future cash-flows that debt is leveraged or equity in a firm is staked
by the stakeholders. To simplify this assertion; you lend somebody
money with an expectation that they will afford to pay as
per your covenant a minimum payment whether from their salaries,
businesses revenues or from existing savings.
In this regard then, Saccos and cooperative members with known avenues
of earning some cash and mobilizing it into savings would be at great
advantage if such savings were loaned out or invested in projects that
would offer superior rates of returns in a predictable fashion. In a
country like ours, with an urgent need for an infrastructure revolution
the government can turn these investments to the advantage of the many,
offering to coop owners a better return on their investments than would
otherwise be realized. For example, rather than have the Rift Valley
Railways take a controlling stake in the Kenyan-Ugandan Railway, why
not balance its stake with one from the Saccos?
To do this, however, legislation needs to be in place that would protect
the cooperative members. Also some depth of education needs to be
carried out along these lines. So far the cooperative college in Karen
only offers education to Diploma level. Merging this institution or
creating collaboration avenues with the universities would allow
broader and deeper courses with degree awards at the end.. These would
be geared towards producing efficient and savvy managers of
cooperatives and Saccos. Indeed having several government funded
finance/economics graduate candidates in masters or PhD level
researchers study the application of Coop- Saccos resources in rapid
economic development of our country could harness even greater
potential than is presently conceived. Such homegrown solutions have
been proved especially effective in other countries, for example the
South Koreans strategy of funding the Chaebols and thus developing such global industrial giants such as Hyundai , Samsung and Daewoo.
In the West and especially the US, UK and Australia , venture capital
firms, mutual funds and other institutional investors have been used by
the pension holders funds institutions to allocate their mobilised
savings from salaried employees to various investments through either
debt instruments or taking up equity stakes in early stage ventures
(usually the role played by venture capitalists in the US and other
economies).
The power of secondary markets are harnessed through
private buy-outs (where other corporations can buy in or have a
joint-venture) ,whether on the New York Stock Exchange or in London's
FTSE). Cooperatives and Saccos in our country represent such 'mobilised
savings stop shops', but much of their resources are only utilized by
members borrowing amongst themselves. There is nothing wrong with this
as such,but this wealth could be further utilised if the portfolios
were expanded into taking direct stakes in other SME's, Real-Estate
development (which has been done to some extent) and provision of Debt
instruments to government infrastructure projects.
This obviously requires expertise in investment management, a capacity
that needs to be developed. For example, the Kenya Coffee Planters Union (KPCU) has for years remained an
exporter of raw-coffee even as there was an opportunity to mobilise
members funds in creating a coffee processing entity and grow their
brand internationally much like Nescafe and Starbucks have. Remaining at
the raw-coffee dealer has only hurt its members when raw coffee prices
fell due to over-supply by Vietnam and the fact that though unique,
Kenya's Arabica coffee is not branded. Such strategies need to adopt a
capitalistic approach balanced with the social cause that KPCU serves.
In the same breadth KPCU through its regional or locally owned coffee
processing cooperatives would have diversified coffee farmers savings
by investing in other areas of the economy through the NSE or even
taking direct stakes in companies such as Mumias or even rural energy
provider entities -a venture that some KTDA facilities have gone into.
These energy plants would be powered by coffee husks which may
alternatively be used to develop organic fertilizer brands.
Such measures would have seen a continued quality of life
enhancement of its members who after the 1980' coffee crash suffered
huge losses and a drop in their quality of life. Farmers who previously
had started building semi-permanent to permanent houses could not now
even afford meals. Such adversity can be avoided in future if these
cooperatives diversify at the mobilised-savings resource allocation
level or in the industries they participate in by adopting more
superior and efficient investments management strategies. To get this
right, certain legislation is necessary as is a deepening knowledge of
how these strategies can be executed.
The onus is upon the ministers of
Finance , Planning and that of cooperatives to take up this challenge
and their bureaucrats to create a new economic order in rural Kenya.
|