|
The Case AGAINST Military Draft in Kenya |
|
|
|
|
Written by Kimani S. Njoroge
|
|
Friday, 22 June 2007 |
Dave Nyambati’s call for a military draft in Kenya is both socially unacceptable and economically unsustainable.
Such a policy will breed a generation that believes serikali ndio baba na mama yao, i.e., they are entitled to state-provided food, clothing, jobs, college degrees, and even happy marriages. On the other hand, politicians and bureaucrats will start seeing the youth as nothing but government property, which has no say whatsoever. Any attempt to rise will be met with threats of employment and forced arrest. The vibrant youth will then respond with what they know best: violence. What began like a well intentioned move will become a monster that will haunt our society for generations to come. Is that what we want?
Financing the program will not be cheap. The taxpayer that Dave’s policy is seeking to help will start paying more taxes, which will finance the expanded military’s hardware, food, medical bills, pension, paid leaves, and all other goodies that come with a government career.
I have come to a conclusion that our security sector does not need more personnel or funds to perform its duty. What we need is total transparency on how taxpayers billions are being utilized. This follows a short study on military spending in East Africa. See the following piece that I published during the Anglo Leasing hearings (Daily Nation March 1, 2006):
Kenya's military budget baffling
. . . Kenya is the biggest military spender in East Africa? Our military allocations have consistently dwarfed those of our sister states, Uganda and Tanzania. Moreover, we have been spending more per military personnel than Ethiopia did during its war with Eritrea, Sudan with SPLA, and Uganda with the LRA.
Interestingly, Kenya's army of 24,000 personnel was, as of 1999, the smallest force in Eastern Africa. This is according to the World Military Expenditures and Arms Transfers, a 2003 study by the United States Department of State. Ethiopia's army of 300,000 soldiers was the largest, followed by Sudan's 105,000. Uganda and Tanzania had 50,000 and 35,000 military personnel respectively.
One would expect our army to have the smallest budget. But NOPE!! In 1999 alone, Kenya spent $8,000 (KSh560, 000) for every soldier, excluding salaries. This was more than four times Ethiopian allocation (KSh120, 000), almost three times that of Uganda (KSh200, 000), two and a half times that of Tanzania (KSh244, 000), and double that of Sudan (KSh280, 000).
That comparison affirms that Kenya has surely been spending as if she was at war. But the peace she has experienced over the years makes one wonder how her Department of Defense (DoD) ended up spending Sh150 billion between 1989 and 1999 . . .
(Click here for the entire article)
Now calculate the cost of enlisting 300, 000 high school graduates into the military year after year. Is that affordable? Some of countries that Dave mentions are lucky because Uncle Sam finances their military budgets: it’s not a secret that Egypt receives US$ 1.3 billion (80% of its annual defense budget) from the US. Israel receives about US$ 3 billion from the US alone.
|
Kimani S. Njoroge |
| About the author: |
| |
Trackback(0)
 |
|
Last Updated ( Monday, 23 June 2008 )
|
TrackBack URI for this entry
Subscribe to this comment's feed
Show/Hide comments
. Where did armoured get this guy i love him. Major you forgot to account for the 2s7 Pions, BM 21 Grads e.t.c. Look man we've been living in Kenya since birth and we know the Kenya Armed Forces never acknowledges any arms purchases publicly. If you(army) were so transparent you could have started with the WZ 5516 6*6's from NORINCO. Who r we kidding? T-72'S are expensieve to maintain and with the kenya army always lookin for a cost effective solution i doubt if they would have settled on them plus the lack the kind of armour needed to protect the crews from this new era anti-tank weapons. I appreciate your loyalty to the forces (God it has made me feel safe already) but please don't lie to people who have the capacityto employ critical thinking. Anyway if you are right, i guess we'll se 'em(T-72) in a presidential parade around Madaraka or Jamhuri Day, then i'll come back here and aplogise to you! 
Show/Hide comment form
I think one needs to speak to officers of the DOD and you will be amazed at what they military does contrary to the perception of a group of pot bellied soldiers living off duty free alcohol and free food and just doing nothing all day after the morning parade!!!
Perhaps the Kenya military has the largest training budget for its offices than any other government department. Apart from the multiple training institutes it runs in the country, at any one time there are close to 200 officers abroad on one form or military training or other. Locally, most of the officers are taking postgraduate degrees in military science, engineering, avionics and international diplomacy. On the CSR side of things, I understand that the engineering battalion built a total of 405 wells in North Eastern province as well as providing emergency relief services.
Unfortunately, for quite some time, despite the huge budget not a lot of equipment renewal took place as the money was just pilfered. The huge budget this year is intended to re-equip the military with a fresh lot of used fighter jets from Jordan as well as other hardware from China - notice the new fleet of 1 storey-high lorries? I understand the joke in the Army today is how the short chinese soldiers are able to use the lorries which have broken the bones of quite a number of Kenyan soldiers jumping off the moving lorries during exercises!!!
Back to Kimani's post - I have already registered my disagreement with David, so nothing more to add on that!