While some of us
grieve lost ones, and while thousands of Kenyans grapple with the reality of
losing all their earthly possessions, it's time to reflect on how the
violence escalated to these, previously unimaginable levels.
In my view the violenc and its drivers can be divided into several
categories.
The spontaneous
expression of outrage at the perceived flawed election
This was what was
witnessed in Kibera and Kisumu. Traditionally, this rather loud and
exuberant expression of either political opinion or disappointment has
historically had few if any cases of violence meted out on individuals. The
disappointment was expected especially considering that this was a close
election. Exit polls conducted by independent parties showed that Kibaki
had won by 47% of the vote to Raila Odinga's 42%, but pre-election polling had for a long time prepped the ODM for a victory. The expectation was that as reality and sanity set in, these
expressions of exultant exuberance would have peacefully dissipated.
This has
provided the hallmark of how Kenya has achieved political progress and
change by civil means. This non-violent expression of political opinion
is encouraged. The transition to multi-partysm led by most famously
Kenneth Matiba and Charles Rubia is based on just this.
The dousing
of the spontaneous expression by inflammatory statement.
I do not recall
any calls for calm by the so-called people's president when his supposedly
aggrieved supporters had the upper hand in the violence that raged.
Matter of fact, all I heard was him calling Kenya's legal president
a thief. There were further calls for "mass action".
In an already
volatile situation, the call for mass action in a situation that is
already spiraling out of control is tantamount to inciting the perpetrators
of the violence. In repeated press briefings, there were claims
by ODM that they had won most of the provinces. The reality is that
President Kibaki won 4 of the 8 provinces and was not the president of one tribe as the ODM has sought to promote. Half of the provinces is
not most. This was a convenient oversight that was continuously relayed
to the Kenyan people. The Kenyan and international media has not made
a protracted effort to rectify this false perception. The continuous
and false claims that ODM had won most of the provinces did little to
assuage their peeved supporters. When the country needed
leadership, neither Ruto from Eldoret nor Raila from Kibera appealed
to their constituents to maintain the peace. It is really most preposterous to ask that President Kibaki make this effort, quite clearly his presence in these areas would only be inflammatory.
The planned and well coordinated attacks in the Rift Valley
This international
media has characterized the violence in the Rift Valley as ethnic violence.
There is the implication that neighbor is rising against neighbor. This
is not the truth. The truth is that there are organized criminal gangs
that are unleashing this violence. These criminal gangs are not even
native to the areas when they are unleashing the violence. The reality
is that gangs of people do not assemble on a single night and cause
mayhem over an entire region as a sporadic act of expressing anger and
outrage. There is more to this violence than meets the eye, and it needs
to be thoroughly explored. Even Bishop Cornelius
Korir agrees.
"Bishop Cornelius Korir spoke in
western Eldoret, scene of the fiery massacre of Kikuyu. Eldoret and
surrounding areas have seen an exodus of Kikuyus since. The violence
across the country has killed some 500 people.
"The way the attacks
were managed seems to me very organized," Korir said as the U.S.
envoy, Jendayi Frazer, toured the region Tuesday. "No, it did not
seem spontaneous to me ... It seems it was well planned."
Over a quarter of
a million people have been displaced - each has a story of property
razed, or a personal testimony of a threat of violence, there have
been numerous witnesses that have claimed that the violence was promised
even before the elections (so much for spontaneity!). Pause and comprehend
that number, - 250,000 displaced! Not over a month, but in two or three days. The MO of the perpetrators of this mayhem, ranging from Kuresio,
to Ngenia Farm in Molo, to Eldoret was the same. Burn! Loot! Maim!
Even then we must not overlook those who have risen above the hatred. Most of the residents have stories of their neighbors (some of them
from the supposedly terrorizing tribe) helping them to hide or providing
assistance in one form or the other.
But who then are the perpetrators of this
violence? Where does their hatred, over and above the normal arise from? Why such ruthless efficiency? Where do they get the resources
to travel in such large groups and cover such long distances? Who are
this people? Who is sponsoring them? How come they are only to be found
in ODM strongholds? Why have the ODM leaders not strongly condemned
these acts of violence? Or prevailed upon their supporters with sincerity
to stop the violence?
These are not freedom
crusaders; they are local terrorists. Calling this low life criminal
gangs anything but that is an insult to our freedom fighters, an insult to
all those that have fought for democracy, an insult to the heroes who
spear-headed the crusade for multi-partysm. The violence in the Rift
Valley was not about an election loss. It was about majimbo - enforcing
a political system by hook or crook, demanding zones of ethnic exclusivity much in the same way as the ethnic cleansing of the 1990s did. The violence would have broken out irrespective
of the outcome of the elections
I also believe the
final death count from the Rift valley will be higher than the official
death count as it stands today - as evidenced here. From various media sources,
the victims of the violence say that there are still bodies not yet
collected and are out there - in the razed wheat fields, in the rolling
lush green tea bushes in Kericho, in the burnt houses in Burnt Forest and in small outposts where killing a family of Kikuyus is not exactly going to make the news.
To serve and protect
The claim that there are multiple deaths by bullet
wounds does not implicate the police only. As has been clearly documented in
the one case where some refugees were attacked in a police station, these
criminal gangs have guns. Not every bullet-riddled body is a result of police
bullets. We should not blame the police for serving and protecting. That they
killed marauding armed criminals who had shown a propensity to kill is called
serving and protecting.
The retaliation
by Mungiki of attacks on their kin.
This criminal outfit
took this as the perfect opportunity to re-group. And they contributed
to the problem by raising the tribal tensions and causing wanton death
and destruction while directing their wrath on the wrong culprits. The
expected reprisal killings from Mungiki are an attempt to make this
criminal sect relevant. Mungiki must be made to step aside - let justice prevail so
that the ensuing criminal prosecution does not get muddied and side
tracked.
The real culprits
are still roaming free in the killing fields of Kuresoi, Burnt Forest,
Ngenia Farm, Eldoret, Kericho and more areas in the North Rift. These
criminal gangs that barricaded roads and pulled Kikuyus from matatus
exiting the North Rift should be pursued, prosecuted and tried for pre-meditated
killings.
The accidental deaths
of innocent people caught in the melee by the police are, in America speak,
collateral damage. Their deaths are truly unfortunate, as they were truly innocent victims caught in the line of police fire. Some were
maybe genuine demonstrators, some were looters who in a situation that
was quickly deteriorating, were met with the full force of the law.
It would be wrong as some commentators are doing, to labell all the violence, post-election violence, or tribal clashes. All across the country, it has shwon itself to be very varied in both its inspiration and its execution.
|
What is your point? How on earth do you expect anybody to listen to your grievances when you can be so callous? Does losing an election justify murder? Does it? You can moan and groan about the election results till the cows come home but i assure you, if it is found out Ruto & co, ODM luminary, icon, saint and thug in chief, organised and orchestrated the murderous ethnic cleansing, they will certainly go to jail for very long prison terms, i.e if they escape the hangman's noose first. This kind of impunity has beeen going on since 1992 but this time, trust me, they have overplayed their hand and they will pay.