Clawing our way out PDF Print E-mail
Written by Open Thread   
Saturday, 09 February 2008

What are our betters negotiating about this weekend? Probably the colour of their ministerial Mercedes. What, though, do you think are the priorities? What would you like to see done in the immediate/medium/long term? 

I'll start with a random selection of my own (not, of course, to be mistaken for KI editorial recommendations):

In the immediate future: an impartial investigation into the election irregularities; reconstitution of the ECK; resettlement of all Internally Displaced Persons, so far as is possible, in their previous places of residence (or suitable compensation for trauma and loss of property or livelihood); an impartial investigation into the planning, funding and direction of the violence; a national reconciliation committee (or perhaps, as someone has suggested, a dedicated ministry); a capital gains tax of, say, 5%.

In the medium term: constitutional reform (and no, 'adopting the Bomas draft' and 'constitutional reform' are not synonyms); parliamentary reform (strengthening parliamentary oversight of the executive, redrawing constitutional boundaries); the reintroduction of a compulsory year of NYS; abolishing the provincial administration altogether for elected regional governments ; splitting the provinces into regions, none of which ought to have a large ethnic majority; a 10-year term-limit on all public servants; the phased introduction of a ceiling on land ownership...

 In the long term: abolition of all barriers to movement of capital and labour in East Africa. What say you?


Open Thread
About the author:
Please send the editors an email at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it on suggestions for topics on Open Thread.




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (23)add
0
...
written by Nyabs , February 09, 2008
For me the priorities I would want them to adress are:

1. Fundamental changes in the way we do our politics. As long as politics will remain a game of which tribal chiefs brings the largest number of voters to the table, we will never have issue based politics and tribal tensions will be raised every five years, with the same or even graver consequences in the future. For heaven's sake, even an El Molo has a right to be president of Kenya, but under current conditions, only the big tribes will ever make it to the presidency. We need to move from tribal coalitions that are a necessity of tribal based politics.

2. A framework for creating a nation and not a collection of tribes. As events of the last one month have clearly shown us, we are not a nation. Strategies, programs need to be put in motion to detribalize the minds of Kenyans, especially the young. Tanzania has effectively done it. We need to learn from them.

3.Legislation to criminalize hate speech and campaigning on ethnic platforms. If it so necessitates, the law should stipulate that all public meetings be conducted in English or Kiswahili. While at it, regulation or outright banning of FM stations that broadcast in other languages other than English and Kiswahili.

4. Legislation banning the training of youth in military craft under the guise of rites of passage. I know this will be a hard one, but we cannot continue to have parallel forces, on one hand the army and the police and the other one tribal armies.

5. Measures to speed up economic growth, that will open windows of opportunities for our unemployment young men and women. Measures to ensure that every Kenyan attains secondary school education and after that, has access to subsidized vocational training or university, depending on one's capabilities. Access to credit for the establishment of businesses or other economic ventures for young people

6. Creation of social safety net programs that will take care of the very poor, tied to them getting engaged in activities that will earn them income and eventually remove them from these social safety net programs.

7. Investigations and unmasking of those behind the mass killings and destruction of propery and their speedy arraignment before courts of law, even the Hague if necessary.

8. A review of our land policies. At this point in time it is impossible to rectify the errors of Kenyatta but some compensation to communities that were dispossessed by the chauvinistic land policies of Kenyatta may be in order. The repossessing and redistribution of land given by Moi should adress the Moi era generosity.

9. A redrawing of districts and provinces with the aim of ensuring that they are multi-ethnic. Banning of tribal associations at Universities. Moi effectively banned those operating out of Universities. I fail to understand why those in Universities still exist.

10. A reduction in the number of terms an MP can serve. Also, a review of whether the 5 year presidential term is realistic. Shouldn't we go to 7? A reduction in the powers of the presidency, election of provincial governnors with clear mandates and performance targets and contracts.

11. Banning from public office any leader convicted of corruption and incitement.

12. And finally, for them to prove to us that they are different from the lot that was largely voted out: taxes on the earnings of MPs.


And immediate resettlement of those displaced, on their land, with adequate security and grants to enable the reconstruct their destroyed properties
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Land Tax
written by a guest , February 09, 2008
Land tax based on land productivity, land utilization and quantity of land owned by the individual, starting for exanmple at all owners with more than 5 acres of land: The more land an individual owns, the higher the tax rate; The more productive the land, the higher the tax rate; The better utilized the land, the lower the tax rate. This way, we heavily tax rich fellows who own large tracts of land that are not utilized.

Kenyan's will also be able to get a better return on this valuable resource, which needs to be better managed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
cold water on optimists
written by ndorobo , February 09, 2008
Here is 2Face. In English he is talking of peace. In Kiswahili, he is igniting the "warriors".

http://ukpress.google.com/arti...3unsf9jPZQ

But speaking in Swahili, East Africa's common tongue, in his power base in western Kenya on Saturday, Odinga returned to the themes that have rallied supporters - and, many say, incited them to violence - since the December 27 election.

Kibaki, who the opposition accuses of stealing the vote, "must step down or there must be a re-election - in this I will not be compromised," Odinga told thousands of people who gathered in an open field for the funeral of David Kimutai Too. Police say Too was killed in a crime of passion, but the opposition insists he was assassinated.

"You cannot steal my cow, and I catch you red-handed, and then expect me to share the milk because the cow is mine," he said as the crowd cheered wildly.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
justice and equity
written by Alfred , February 09, 2008
Long term: Equity and Justice: I think the main thing is to ensure that all people are treated equally by the government. If Kenya is to be stable, it should get to a point where it should not matter who is in office. I don't think Kenyans have a problem living amongst other people. Its when they feel that they have been discriminated against by their government that they revolt and struggle to have one of their own be president and shove aside other tribes. If people didnt feel that Kikuyus were being favoured by the govt I dont think they would be fighting them. So me thinks what needs to be done is get as many people out of poverty as possible, administer justice and ensure equity. The prerequisites for these to happen include but not limited to comprehensive constitutional reforms. Land reforms? I don't know about that.

The Rift Valley expulsions pre-date Kibaki's government though, don't they? Please read the Kiliku and Akiwumi reports, or thumb through John Oucho's Undercurrents of Ethnic Conflicts in Kenya. Eds.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , February 09, 2008
I'm not sure what to make of the ODM tone in this article. Are these the initial signs that ODM may refuse to accept the results of the negotiations, or is it just politiking to maintain pressure and popularity.

Link here
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Land reform
written by Daniel.Waweru , February 09, 2008
Anonymous' suggestion sounds good. In particular, I'd like to see the introduction of a tax on the value of unimproved land, something like this. This shouldn't be hard to do since Kenya, unlike some other African countries, has brought pretty much all of its land within the scope of the formal legal order.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: cold water on optimists
written by Nyabs , February 09, 2008
Here is 2Face. In English he is talking of peace. In Kiswahili, he is igniting the "warriors".

http://ukpress.google.com/arti...3unsf9jPZQ

But speaking in Swahili, East Africa's common tongue, in his power base in western Kenya on Saturday, Odinga returned to the themes that have rallied supporters - and, many say, incited them to violence - since the December 27 election.

Kibaki, who the opposition accuses of stealing the vote, "must step down or there must be a re-election - in this I will not be compromised," Odinga told thousands of people who gathered in an open field for the funeral of David Kimutai Too. Police say Too was killed in a crime of passion, but the opposition insists he was assassinated.

"You cannot steal my cow, and I catch you red-handed, and then expect me to share the milk because the cow is mine," he said as the crowd cheered wildly.


The king of doublespeak at his best. What was the point of having the talks? Wasn't one of the undertakings not to say or do anything that would derail the talks?

And when the government responds in kind, ODM is quick to accuse it of hardening its stand.

Under this circumstances, we havea long way to go, unfortunately, very unfortunately.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Way Foward for Kenyans
written by kobangoshe , February 10, 2008
Kenyans will have crossed the line to a self running nation the day it will depoliticize life and halt their dependence on state provided goodies. To this end, a robust private sector that will bring high paying jobs and produce quality goods and services that are competitive in the world market place is the only way we can grow out this kind of political crisis. Government will never be able to create jobs, and therefore it can not be expected to provide employment opportunities to the jobless youth and young adults. Government's job will be to set the right environment and legal structures that will enable both domestic and foreign investers grow in numbers and not just in the big cities but across the country. Infrastructure and security will be paramount priorities of government, and in partnership with the private sector it can work this strategy out in less than 10 years through 2-3 phases. If we get there, it will not matter much who the president is or where he comes from or what his ethnic link is. All that will matter is that institutions remain strong and firm to a point that the president of politicians can not shake them.

Land is definitely a critical resource, but I will hasten to add that land will cease to be as important as it seem now when have many other options of livelihood. Not everyone can make a farmer or rancher. Professionals like doctors, lawyers, accountants, police, engineers, teachers and professors, nurses, bankers, adminstrators etc, have no business owning land for agric and therefore specialization and practices must be brought to bear. Only farmers should own land and no one individual should have more than 50 acreas of land. Farming companies would be allowed to lease land from government for extensive high yield prodictive farming, call it commercial farming. This would have to be the core business of such land owners. Hence tax would be attributed accordingly and rebates allowed where the farms employ labour and skilled personnel. No idle land should be maintained, and in such caes the government will be free to take the land back and assign it to people/farms that are ready and willing to use it to produce farm products.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Mr. Vikii , February 10, 2008
The most immediate undertaking by these fellows we call leaders should be the resettlement and reasonable compensation of those displaced. We are talking about almost half a million people here, a very significant proportion of the national population. If these people do not go back to their farms and continue with their economic activities, we should be prepared to kiss national happiness, cohesion and any meaningful economic advancement goodbye.

To avoid recurrence of last month's unrest, we should embark on the reform of the constitution. Like someone said, this doesn't mean the adoption of the Bomas draft. It means a fresh collation of kenyans' views preceded by a massive civic education. This civic education should focuss on the issue of the imperial presidency against the need to share executive power with Parliament, local authorities and provincial governments(I do not want to use the word devolution which means different things to different people.), the reform of the Judiciary right from the appointment of Judicial officers to the maximum period it should take to hear cases and pass judgements. This review of the constitution should of course include discussions on the best way to craft a new independent and representative electoral commision, one that has powers to not only abitrate on electoral disputes but do it within within the shortest time possible. It should not exclude, as someone said, the review of boundaries of electoral districts.

Some have talked of putting a cap on the amount (or is it size?) of land an individual should own. Well, to me that is not only a ridiculous proposal, it beats the essence of a capitalist economy. What we should be talking about is reposession of all land that was irregularly aqcuired or unjustfiably dished out by Presidents, mayors or land commissioners whose only guiding factors were sheer populism and cryonism AND appropriation and division of this land to the citizens of Kenya guided by and based on need. Someone who owns 10000 hectres of land in Turkana and someone who owns 1000 hectres of land in Kiambaa, who should relinguish his land? Who owns more than who in terms of value? It is simply unworkable. We should instead be proposing buying of land by government(even if it means at prices higher than the market ones) and re-allocation of the land to the landless. That, is in my opinion the direction our land reform should take.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
First things First
written by Andrew , February 10, 2008
All very well written, but; unable to do without solving the current political crisis first. We are not out of the woods, not by a long shot. Kibaki did not show up for the post agreement photo shot after meeting Raila and Annan choosing instead to leave back to state house in a huff. (Serves him right). Wonder what image that gives the talks.

Raila is now speaking through both sides of his mouth (Serves him right). Ordinary Kenyans are confused (Do they deserve this?)

Without the political issues being amicably resolved, Kenya will not be Kenya again. This is a real fear. Reintroducing NYS will ensure those thugs out there have quasi military training..I wonder if you really want that!!!

Let the talks be held, let a deal be reached, THEN let us start dreaming big again. For now like any wise investor the handle is on caution.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Today and Tomorrow
written by Mpa , February 10, 2008
I believe the most immediate thing is to have our country back. We now know where we stand (is it where we have fallen?)
The good thing is that we also realise that we need the country known as Kenya. To heal the wounds a Truth and Justice Commission with a wide mandate of righting the wrongs done recently and also going back to independence is a must.
Secondly i agree that we need to know what is the place of politics in our lives. We should exorcise politics from our education, from the civil service and business.
We should also not forget where our current crop of "leaders" took us to, we should never ever let ourselves depend on individuals from our salvation. We need to work on institutions that we can lean to during times like the present. The Juducairy, parliament, ECK, police and the Army.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Capping landholdings
written by Daniel.Waweru , February 10, 2008
Some have talked of putting a cap on the amount (or is it size?) of land an individual should own. Well, to me that is not only a ridiculous proposal, it beats the essence of a capitalist economy.


Why not? Land is a finite resource, so it can rationally be rationed. There's nothing anti-capitalist about limiting individual ownership of finite productive resources (especially essential ones such as land); if there is, so much the worse for capitalism.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Capping landholdings
written by benadede , February 10, 2008


Why not? Land is a finite resource, so it can rationally be rationed. There's nothing anti-capitalist about limiting individual ownership of finite productive resources (especially essential ones such as land); if there is, so much the worse for capitalism.


And since land is a finite resource I think it is also high time to let Kenyans know that not everyone is entitled to land. This idea that almost two generations after independence we still have squateers has to be dealt with once and for all. Deserving cases should be expedited in one massive resettlement and we close that chapter once and for all. One of the problems we have had over the years is the idea of title deeds being handed to "squatters" every election period to influence voters.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Empower Youth through sport
written by benadede , February 10, 2008
One of my suggestions is that the sport ministry should be used to empower our idle youth. From what i have been seeing on TV, there is no shortage of energetic youth who do not know how to make use of their talents.
Personally, I am just disappointed that I do not have money to invest in a WWE sort of wrestling challenge. I would quickly recruit the likes of the railway uproot gangs!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
No sports, this is GoK !
written by aeichener , February 11, 2008
Benadede, there is much more to your - very valid - suggestions than just the quip or joke in my headline above.

Unfortunately it will never happen, because this is Kenya, not a civilized country... Let me relate to you my almost comical experiences with the Ministry of Gender, Culture, Sports, and Social Services in a later posting :-(.

In many places in Kenyan public (dis)service, employees are sleeping under their office desks. In this ministry however, the permanent secretary (Mrs. Rachel Dzombo) has obviously dug out a fully-fetched aardvark burrow under her desk, and like any good aardvark, never ventures out at daytime.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Empower Youth through spor
written by pndiangui , February 11, 2008
One of my suggestions is that the sport ministry should be used to empower our idle youth. From what i have been seeing on TV, there is no shortage of energetic youth who do not know how to make use of their talents.
Personally, I am just disappointed that I do not have money to invest in a WWE sort of wrestling challenge. I would quickly recruit the likes of the railway uproot gangs!


Couldn't agree more !

Now, Kabashonge I think we are jumping the gun. The movement from an agrarian mindset needs several forces at work. First I think we still haven't attained the real agrarian mindset of basic farming skills. We still have a number of hunter/gatherer altitude towards land as a resource. We can leap-frog this mentality into the 21st century thinking but the critical elements of how a society thinketh , when it comes to saving, consumerism, hard work , service, governance is where I see more emphasis should be focussed on. This is a hard nut to crack, but therein lies the next generation of Kenyans that might recognize that Land is not the only resource. For now we have to work with what we have to create the desired.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
addressing corruption
written by observer , February 11, 2008
We may also have to create a truth commission of the issue of corruption.

The the primary driver of our politics is the ablity to get money from the treasury by unlawful and unjust means really needs addressing.

I would like to see a system where every tender for both national and local government for over 10K is published on a web site. It should not be enough to just publish them but also list all bids and who the bid is awarded to. This would give the media and both government and independent watch groups the ability to monitor and go after corruption in the country.

I believe that this level of transparency would stop significantly opportunities for corruption. I think this would force the purveyors of corruption to spend their efforts in creating viable companies that can meet these tenders like other tenders in the private sector.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
short term solution to the vio
written by observer , February 11, 2008
I just read this article http://www.nationmedia.com/Eas...102086.htm and I think it is very well thought though and insightful on addressing the short term goals to ending the violence. There is a lot here and my warrant a separate thread of discussion.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
honesty in peace and justice
written by the melancholy , February 11, 2008
As we discuss about equality and righting of historical injustices let us not forget the following :
1.unequal repersentation in constituencies formerly opposition strongholds currently in govt eg Embakasi over 200k+ voters and other Nairobi areas with such numbers .Remember the disputes by ODM on number of voters eg Molo ,Nithi,Juja.This was calculated to deny by the previous Kanu govt these areas to have proportional representation.
2.The recruitment to the armed forces is without doubt skewed to the tribes which had been Kanu strongholds.There should be equitable representation by deliberate policies to ensure the number of our armed forces bear a link to the population of different tribes.
this should be extended to all other areas of our society.
one of our big failure of our society is to pinpoint only what is palatable to our ears and ignoring underlying issues .The media and the civil society has not been helpful either and is a wiiling partner in this conspiracy .By the way have we now come to our senses and realised that all that hot air about Anglo Leasing , Mamlukis was just gibberish and that the real danger lay in your next door neighboiur who would pick a machete or panga to slash you upon little provocation by politicians .may God help kenyans \
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
ODM\'s media success
written by mainat , February 11, 2008
Here is ojinga's long-term strategy http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/85b9...d2ac.html.
PNU will unless they can bring fwd some articulate and probably softer PR person than Martha, continue lagging behind in the international PR war. Their luck has been that some of the major media outlets have actually started listening to the IDPS now in RV. They do need to hammer their lies as loudly as Ojinga does.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
what abt IDPs?
written by mainat , February 11, 2008
One issue on which I feel no attention is being paid to in the on-going talks, is whole impunity shown by communities in throwing out outsiders. I think that if IDPs can't go back to their homes (some have been in RV for example since the days of Harry Thuku), the compensation costs for resettling them elsewhere must come from the CDF accounts of the constituencies where they've had to flee from.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: what abt IDPs?
written by Daniel.Waweru , February 11, 2008
One issue on which I feel no attention is being paid to in the on-going talks, is whole impunity shown by communities in throwing out outsiders. I think that if IDPs can't go back to their homes (some have been in RV for example since the days of Harry Thuku), the compensation costs for resettling them elsewhere must come from the CDF accounts of the constituencies where they've had to flee from.


Agree entirely that the IDP agenda might have been made more central to the negotiations. But it's clear that ODM, on the one hand, regard it as a piece of anti-government leverage, and that PNU has managed the issue incompetently. For example, closing down some camps was a very poor move: some of the IDPs went back to their homes, and set off the retaliatory ethnic cleansing (e.g. in Central); it was also a poor move because it leaves them unsafe, and makes it harder to collect evidence.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Kimemia , February 12, 2008
Not that Slavoj Zizek was speaking in direct reference to the Kenya issue but the comment he makes in this clip do strike a resonance with the land claims in Rift Valley

Cut the Gordian knot
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 24 June 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company