Kalonzo Checkmate? PDF Print E-mail
Written by Kamale T   
Monday, 06 August 2007

On hearing that Kalonzo Musyoka was, ‘defecting to LPK but remaining in ODM-K, my first reaction was that it was a clever move, allowing him to manoeuvre within the movement free from the constrictions of LDP.

Kalonzo also required a position for his Presidential Campaign from which he could be seen as a party leader, which stance was impossible in the Liberal Democractic Party where he constantly played second fiddle to Raila- nevermind the the days last year when he led in national opinion polls. The Labour Party of Kenya was the junior partner in ODM-K, and if he could somehow rope in Uhuru's KANU, then he could lead a 60% share in ODM-K a sizeable chunk considering the present domination of the Raila juggernaut over Orange House.

As we shall see, Kalonzo may have also made a serious political mistake with this decision!

The immediate result of this move was the re-alignment of Kalonzo Musyoka with Daniel Maanzo, the now famous paper chairman of ODM especially since there was a growing problem over the issue of party officials. As long as Maanzo was the registered party chairperson, he was a man necessary to have in your corner should you decide to play dirty in your politics. Several people have actually questioned how the Raila's advisors did not foresee this confusion.

the two minute peace
photo EA Standard 

The media was awash on Friday with news of the resignation and then the quick retraction of Abraham Chepkonga who is registered as the Secretary-General of ODM-K . This was quickly followed by the announcement by both Mutula Kilonzo and Julia Ojiambo, the political vice-chairpersons of ODM ( along with the Henry Kosgey- Anyang' Nyong'o group) that they were actually not elected and hence should not be registered as party officials. This renunciation of power by the two vice-chairs tells you just how earnest the fight for the ownership of the registered officials is.

The importance of these officials is premised on the fact that the ODM constitution deposited with the Registrar of Societies indicates that the party chairman and secretary general will sign the nomination papers of the party nominees come the elections. This makes the Maanzo- Chepkonga group of officials very powerful, especially should ODM-K be unable to conduct elections before the General Elections are announced.

It is therefore safe to say today that Kalonzo has won a battle of party official ownership. Unfortunately, you cannot say that he has won the party for himself. ODM-K over the last 18 months has built itself a unique brand that many Kenyans try to identify with. But ODM the organisation is like a tattered trouser with patches holding it together where if one fell off the rest of the trouser would follow suit. A Kenyan friend of mine visiting from Afghanistan where he is working with the UN described ODM as moto ya makaratasi which simply means it is a paper fire that dies quickly. Eighteen months is a long time, but ODM-K is seriously ailing!

no longer at ease

Back on to the politics of scheming. Kalonzo's other reason for his action was that he realised that Raila was going to push him out of the ODM-K race by any means possible. With that and the realisation that a Kalonzo candidature outside of ODM is a waste of time, he decided that it would be him that forced Raila out of the party! The machinations started quite sometime back where Kalonzo always ensured that he took the differing position from what Raila wanted. He flip-flopped on the consensus and delegates' nomination system and this happened every time Raila conceded to either of the methods. Now Raila Odinga was to be faced with a dilemma of either fighting Kalonzo internally through the nomination process and in the process force Kalonzo out of the party or in the alternative he could have swallowed humble pie and moved to another party where he would be the candidate. From this new party position he would still beat Kalonzo but thus enervated challenging the incumbent would end in certain failure. This phantom of another electoral defeat for the Lang'ata MP was reinforced by the fact that he did not at any cost want to add another party to his CV!

The problem with ODM-K was its original formation structure. Political leaders came into ODM-K representing their communities as their voting blocks with which they would negotiate for power positions come the elections. This structure created a dependency on the leaders to deliver their communities' votes to the ODM machine, but it also opened the possibility of creating expectations in the communities that their ‘own' would become president. So as the politicians went round the country, it was important to preach unity to keep these communities under lock and key. Now the time of reckoning has come and the next few weeks will even see more re-alignments with their common rival- the incumbent- ending up the beneficiaryof their internecine struggle.

 
 things fall apart

So can this move salvage Kalonzo's presidential hopes? Before I answer this, let us bring in the so-called Iron Lady called Charity Ngilu. Kalonzo and Ngilu have over the years fought to retain supremacy in Kamba politics. Following the actions of Kalonzo, the Raila camp has been working hard to woo Ngilu into their camp and her recent activities are a pointer at what she is looking for. Relevance. Political relevance! If she joined Raila, then it would be for the purpose of shoring up the Kamba vote in ODM, and stealing the thunder from Kalonzo. But I do not think that Ngilu would do this to Kalonzo for the simple reason that Akamba votes are split between Kalonzo and Kibaki with Ngilu being the lone ranger here! The reason the government allows Ngilu to be incarcerated is simply that she has no political value even if she was jailed and Kibaki would not want to sack her as this would only make a matyr of her.

Kalonzo was a very good presidential candidate that would have appealed to many Kenyans had he stayed in a United ODM, but this is now water under the bridge. Kalonzo cannot muster enough national appeal to win the race, so it will be a futile exercise and he cannot count on the luck of Kibaki in the coming years. Kenyans are not as anti-Kibaki as they were against Moi and anything he represented in 2002, so a magical Kalonzo tosha may not materialise. He also cannot join the Kibaki group as he has demonised the lot many times over, and he would therefore be unwelcome. Instead his fate will be like that of other presidential wannabes like Koigi Wamwere and Wangari Maathai.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (7)add
0
...
written by Pat , August 07, 2007
Kalonzo is finished. He bit off way more than he could ever chew and suceeded in effectively alienating himself from the other candidates. Kalonzo's defection has cleared one obstacle from Agwambo's road to statehouse.

Pat
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kalonzo finished?
written by Dave Nyambati , August 07, 2007
This is a very interesting analysis and quite a good read. However, Kamale has failed to take into account one thing, this is politics where sworn enemies often become bedfellows overnight.

Take a look at the now defunct Moi era LDP-KANU alliance. This shows one very important trait of Raila's, the ends justifies the means in his quest for the presidency. Don't be too surprised if the Raila group offers some major concession package to woo Kalonzo back into the fold. Both these men realize that without the other, Kibaki will be impossible to beat.

I would not bury ODM-K just yet, that there is still some indecision in Narc buys ODM-K a little more time to get their act together.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Moi University
written by vivid , August 07, 2007
Did you all see the photo of Kalonzo standing next to the former President at their little scouts love fest? The reason our little democracy boda boda is not quite running correctly is because if you look closely at almost every piece you'll see the tiny scrawls "Moi was here". See, for some reason God gave us Moi and he didn't just give him any kind of wisdom but the very deep, one of a kind, chop-the-kid-in-half solomon type wisdom of ancient yore. Saying "Kalonzo Checkmate" may even be giving the poor fella too much credit. For all we know he's just one of those pawns that hope to make Queen one day but will most likely get snapped up in some minor pawn exchange or even just get blocked by another pawn (even one of its own kind!).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 08, 2007
There's a big lesson in all of this that only the blind will ignore. It is impossible to work with Raila Odinga if your head has half an ounce of sense, or two dollops of dignity. That is where the problem is.

Coming up next year, rows with Ngilu, rows with Sally Kosgei, candidates forced down wananchi's throats, Ida as an intefering first lady ( Lucy eat your shorts ) and so on. For those of us in the anything but Odinga camp, Kalonzo will act as a foil between the dictatorial demagogue and State House.

Vivid,
The one thing this whole episode has shown us about Kalonzo is that he is his own man. We may think of him as foolish, naive and so on, but for a Kenyan without a tribal base to speak of he has certainly shown a great deal of courage. Look at how Musalia and Ruto have folded under the pressure of the juggernaut.
Oh wait, they will actually take that as a complement.

Kamale,
I do not suppose that NARC-K would have any use for Kalonzo ( not because he has criticised them heavily) but because he has shown his independence. This means he cannot be made VP, this is the same reason ,I wager, that Mukhisa was nudged to the railings. What will they do about the constituencies, they may very well win the Presidential Election- because many of us would never vote for Raila- but they will surely lose the parliamentary election ( NARC-K being nothing more than DP with a few flowers on).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by vivid , August 09, 2007
@Stephen: I'll agree with you that so far Kalonzo does not give off any scary vibes.

I wish the candidates would just focus on the issues facing wananchi and drop all these political theatrics that have become too much. I really, really can't believe these turks are squabbling so much over power and so close to elections. It just dosen't look good for any of them and is horrible for the country. Someone should tell them to "Kimya!" and just get on with it. It may even be safer for the peace of the country if the current President continues for another term while Kenyans take another 5 years to really get to know the characters of these ODM-K guys. Better still, it may give time for some new long term planning patriot who takes the time to build up his or her party from scratch based on fair, sound principles, and a solid platform that addresses our deepest concerns. Such a man or woman is surely out there. Kanu would have been well placed to take advantage of this mess if it wasn't for the fact that their leader has shown himself to be indecisive, easily manipulated, and simply not fit to lead the nation. In fact, Kalonzo should have just gone back to baba, replaced Kenyatta as Kanu head and started packing his bags for the state house move.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , August 10, 2007
Vivid,
To me as a voter, unity means nothing. Unless Satan himself was in office, I do not see any reason why unity in the opposition would be a good thing. I also do not see how it is not good for the country, are these vestiges of the neurosis we suffered when kicking Moi to the curb? That any alternative was better?

The trouble with building a new party, one that could win an election is that you need billions to achieve that. even more you need tribal clout. Not too many can afford that.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by vivid , August 10, 2007
Think outside the box. Below our tribal identity lies something deeper. Western companies have created strong brands by re-analyzing demographics and reaching for those deeper identity elements. But, for the practical situation we face now maybe Kalonzo should just let the Raila group have ODM-K and he goes over to head a new ODM-Kanu. Kenyatta would do well as a vice president since as an individual he, too, does not give off any scary vibes.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Monday, 06 August 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company