Home
ODM? Enter the dragon PDF Print E-mail
Written by Jhaigne Wanyama   
Saturday, 13 October 2007

The war on corruption is an urgent war, one which every good Kenyan would like to see bravely fought. Election day approaches and we must now consider just how important this struggle is as we decide on our votes.

The onset of the campaigns and the barrage of promises will attempt to direct and redirect Kenyans' attentions away from the truth, at the politicians' whim. Currently, the ODM party leads this crusade, promising to deal with the corrupt Kibaki government and its thieving officials. But the attentive voter must watch carefully and see whether the 'hammer' does drop on the real culprits, and guard that in seeking to settle scores with one side, we do not bless the crimes of the other.

It is imperative now that we flip the coin and find out more about the people we would charge with saving Kenya from the jaws of corruption and the bad governance of the Moi and Kibaki governments.

deya.jpg
The Archbishop and I

Starting with the ODM, the reform party and the poll leaders of the minute, it is clear that not all is as is sold to us.

Not too long ago, when the ODM-K was still intact, William Ruto, Musalia Mudavadi, Uhuru Kenyatta, Kalonzo Musyoka and Raila Odinga were supposed to attend a bond-building meeting in London. In the end, only Raila attended the meeting, accompanied by South Mugirango MP Omingo Magara. Ruto and Mudavadi stayed away, excusing themselves with the ruse that they had not applied for travel visas. Kalonzo on his part alleged that the meeting had been called to declare Raila Tosha. Interestingly and not incidentally, that meeting was found to have been organised by Gilbert Deya, who is wanted in Kenya on charges of child-trafficking.

Following the uproar over the UK trip, journalists carried out a little sleuthing, and it was soon clear that there was more to Ruto's absence from the get-together than first met the eye. It turned out that the UK visa was denied on account of his court-case for the grab-and-sale of forest land at premium prices to the Kenya Pipeline Company. UK travel regulations it was reported, preclude the entry into the country of persons in court on allegations of corruption. One finds it is difficult also to forget where the name of William Ruto first impinged on the public consciousness. Do you remember the roles of Ruto and Cyrus Jirongo in the 1990-1992 plunder of the economy? Is this camaraderie what drew Jirongo to his fellows in ODM?

William Ruto is however, only the number three in the ODM pecking order. What about the projected next Vice President Musalia Mudavadi? He has restricted his movement to within the borders of Kenya, perhaps on account of the continued shadow of his involvement in the Goldenberg scandal. It is only Raila Odinga the ODM chief who is able to travel abroad on fundraising missions for the party, as his fellow Pentagon chiefs have travel restrictions that prevent their travel, especially to the EU and the USA. Even as our future Vice President protests his innocence, it is instructive that his boss, the ODM candidate has not retracted a statement he made before the elections in 2002. In it he invited Mudavadi to come clean on the Goldenberg saying:

"Musalia and (President) Moi know the whole truth about Goldenberg and they should come out clean. Mudavadi was the Finance Minister in 1993. He first paid out the Sh5.8 billion in export compensation and then the Sh13.5 billion. I know what I am talking about. I stand for the truth and the VP and the President should come out and prove me wrong."

dickberg.jpg
Dick Berg; picture Daily Nation

That Raila's 2002 pre-election statement was a retraction of one he had made earlier putting former Vice President George Saitoti on the spot for the Goldenberg scandal, compels us to take this second proclamation very seriously. It was he then said, a studied opinion and not one based on hearsay. If, as some maintain, Raila 's leadership will itself protect the ODM from temptation to corruption, then we must pre-suppose that Raila's judgement is reliable. Subsequently, his selection of a man that he himself had previously stated was responsible for the greatest theft in our history to the position of running mate, begs that we question his sincerity and his graft-fighting credentials.

And those powers of discernment, are hardly luxuries especially as the ODM lists are filled with politicians of less than innocent inclinations. Party chairman Henry Kosgey was part of the team that
brought in Dick Berg to execute the 1997 "4th All African Games" looting. Berg was the marketing consultant appointed to oversee the 4th All-Africa Games in 1987. He fled the country with 200 million shillings even before the games had begun. And those games are but a small part of Kosgey's portfolio. The Tinderet MP has also been accused of complicity in many other economic crimes, including most prominently the total enervation and subsequent collapse of the Kenya National Assurance Company.

The question then, is why the ODM presidential candidate would surround himself with men of such questionable repute, especially if as advertised, he was, determined to clean Kenya up. Is it perhaps because like them he too is reeking of scandal? News reports from two years ago show just how fast Raila ran to court to block legal action against him on account of the land that he had received just 5 days after the NDP joined KANU. The Odinga family paid 4 million shillings for 240 acres of prime industrial land in Kisumu. That is a measly sh16, 000 per acre. What was peculiar about the case was not that the charges were brought up against the charismatic ODM candidate, but the vigour with which he warned Justice Minister Martha Karua against investigating him or his family.

musalia_mudavadi.jpg
Mr Goldenberg?

Does the rule of law not demand that everyone is investigated and consequently absolved or convicted by the courts when there are allegations against them? Would the ODM chief not be happy to have a court of law clear him and stop people having these doubts about him. There were, it is true, other politicians recommended for investigation in the Ndung'u report including the PNU's George Saitoti and Njenga Karume, and ODM's William Ntimama. But so vociferous were the protestations from the ODM presidential candidate that KNHRC boss Maina Kiai was moved to implore the Lang'ata MP to let the law prevail and have the courts prove his innocence. And the Molasses plant deal was not as minor as has sometimes been depicted. So far reaching were the effects of the scam that one of the biggest Kenyan banks, the Kenya Commercial Bank, lost up to 1 billion shillings.

I expect that it will be said that there are politicans on the NARC side with greater shame hanging over them. Foremost among this is likely to be the former President Moi. But even these the Langata MP is partly responsible for reintroduction to the public sphere. Following the election, the former President was a pariah, ostracised in all quarters of goverment. Until that is, the intervention of Raila Odinga. Or in his own words to a large rally in the Rift Valley:

"I came to Moi's aid when the Government wanted to take away his houses and sue him over Goldenberg during my days as the Minister for Roads. Moi should be grateful. I organized his first meeting with Kibaki at State House. He should thank me by not attacking ODM unfairly"

The ODM candidate also claimed that soon after taking office, President Kibaki's government had wanted to sue Moi over the Goldenberg scandal and even throw him out of his Kabarnet Gardens residence but that he objected.

with_president_moi.jpg
the old man and I

"I was censured at the Cabinet meeting for fiercely defending Moi but as then Minister for Public Works, I said Moi still deserved to retain his Kabarnet Gardens home," he said.

So Raila did not only object, but he fiercely resisted attempts to hold the former President to account for the excesses of his regime. His proposals that he will seek to restitute to the public the gains of corruption are thus unlikely to be at all sincere.

So we see that there is not a difference between ODM and PNU in their approach to corruption. ODM must adopt for themselves a new campaign platform since they have not the moral authority to talk about recovering the loot from the former regime when they have not handed themselves handed back to us what they stole.

It is truly tragic to our prospects for fairer government that Kenyan politicians would have us believe that their wrongs can be forgotten simply because they are not currently serving in government. President Kibaki has been accused of associating with Moi for political gain. But is this not the same reason for which the hero of the moment Musalia Mudavadi lost his Sabatia seat, sticking to President Moi at election time? It is truly strange to hear him now accuse Moi of running down the country while he sat high up in his government and watched over Goldenberg as Finance Minister. Similarly, in the aftermath of the 1997 election, as the opposition alleged widespread rigging, the Raila Odinga-led NDP saw fit to lend succour to Moi's government and strengthen its grip on Kenya's politics.

It is important that as we go to the election, we remember that there are many in ODM with very tainted pasts, which pasts include both collusion in the Moi government's worst crimes and the most egregious abuse of public office for personal gain. These pasts cannot be wished away simply because "Kenyans want change". If change means that likes of William Ruto, Musalia Mudavadi, Henry Kosgey, William Ntimama, Raila Odinga and many other MPs are allowed to con Kenyans into letting them have another turn at public wealth, who always reinvent themselves every time there is an opportunity, then Kenya does not need change just for the sake of it. Kenya needs meaningful change. An ODM government would be a case of exit the dragon, enter the dragon.


Jhaigne Wanyama
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (8)add
0
hold no elections!
written by Seline , October 13, 2007
emmo:
Jane in french is Jeanne

back to the issue. We all scream from the rooftops the way kenya and kenyans want change. We have three maybe four presidential candidates Kalonzo, Raila, Kibaki and Muiru. I will not talk about kalonzo- no discriminatory intent-opinion polls show he's headed nowhere. That leaves Kibaki and Raila as the two main contenders. The sad truth is both have been named in corruption cases, either directly or indirectly. And they both surround themselves with people of questionable character. But elections are here and since we claim to be a democracy, we must go to the polls and elect a new president. But the questions is, what exactly do we want? When one mentions Kibaki,we (not all) scream out our disatisfaction with the guy, mainly because of corruption and tribal issues. And when (one) mentions Raila, the same sentiments are expressed. So what should we do? We all know that the battle is between Kibaki and Raila, and as i mentioned earlier both have been involved in some way or the other in corruption scandals. So since we are so disastified with both contenders, should we still vote? At the end of the day, someone has to be elected to lead the country.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Abdullah Rashid , October 13, 2007
Wanyama, you need to know that an analysis done with a predetermined mind like yours which raves and rants about
ODM can't be objective and critical. That said, if ODM members are corrupt, then that's exactly why Kibaki and his octogenarian armada need to go.

As a PNU supporter, you are launching (and always launched)a scathing attack on the ODM brigade in the name of corruption analysis. The question is: who is suppossed to bring the corrupt to book? If Ruto is corrupt (for example), why don't you bring him to book? Don't you think failure to do so (and it was) means the people who were entrusted with that job wanted to steal more and thus Ruto became an angel?
This is why Kenyans will send these poorish and bogus octogenarians that you support in the name of PNU, (Pora Na Uende) to their homes willy-nilly.

Furthermore, when you are raving about the Molasses Plant as if that was a grand corruption, and Raila indeed bought it appropriately, there are many cases of grand corruption that need to be tackled, which your PNU failed to address. In this case, your lame argument that ODM brigade is corrupt much as PNU elements and thus no need to change PNU is not only a barren argument but one bereft of any truth.

The source of corruption is tribalism, and ODM assured Kenyans that tribalism will end. In this case, Kenyans will settle for ODM since PNU represents tribal warlords and colonial chiefs who have ran down the nation. Granted, they have their own weaknesses and shortcomings, but to argue that they are equal to PNU in shame is to ignore every human consideration and expose one's intellectual penury, if not utter hate. Furthermore, Mudavadi was cleared by the Bosire Commission, so what is that you need to be cleared again? Take Saitoti and the rest to court and leave Mudavadi out of this cheap game.

Otherwise wait for the ODM train to clean the mess, though as a doubting Thomas, you will shake your head; only that no one needs your approval because Kenyans have embarked on a new journey and the Grand March to a New Dawn is unstoppable.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
anti-euphoria
written by emmo opoti , October 13, 2007
Seline,
I am very much one of those torn Kenyans. It is difficult to ignore the fact that Kibaki is himself one of the richest Kenyans, and a lot of that wealth seems to have been gained when in public office. The very Ndung'u report that is mentioned by Jhaigne (I was only joking) also mentions Kibaki. Remember also the trouble with the Naro Moru ranch of his?

I have always hoped that educated Kenyans, and especially the middle classes could be objective, and notice that both sides are unlikely to improve the lot of Kenyans. I find nothing more repulsive than those who cannot see the error of their masters. Those who insist that everyone must see it their way, and why are you not supporting my candidate. Nothing stands in the way of our development so much as the blind trust we place in our politicians.

I would say the solution is to ensure that everyone goes into the election with their eyes open. Even as you vote Raila or Kibaki, you must not pretend that you are voting in a reformist party, or a party that has the interests of Kenyans at hand. I really believe that all the talk of Second Liberation, Third Liberation and so is extremely puerile.
Do you realise that the parties have not bothered at all with making detailed plans? They know that they have loyal, blind and ultimately self-harming backers, so why bother working hard? Why bother formulating policy? They do not even think about what they are saying because they can unsay it all over again the next day.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Sounds of a Stuck Gramophone!!
written by Don , October 13, 2007
Rashid,
I couldn't help but notice that this is "another" Wanyama writing very much like the "other" Wanyama who produced the "(in)famed" users' guide. Let the PNU go down the corruption road and they'll be astonished at how it boomerangs on them and Kibaki's boat sinks even faster. I pity their desperation.

[Comment edited by Moderator]
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , October 13, 2007
Well said Jhaigne. I have not heard that name before. Is it French for Jane? There's an old Japanese proverb that goes '
Vision without action is daydream. Action without vision is nightmare.

This is exactly what Kenyans were faced with in 2002, a change that was nothing but entirely cosmetic. 2007 promises to be the same thing whichever party wins.

[Comment edited by Moderator]
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
DN: Fear mongering not a win s
written by mimimzalendo , October 13, 2007
EDITORIALS

Stop trying to scare us
Publication Date: 10/14/2007
Election seasons in Kenya are tense periods, and people sometimes get frightened and uncertain. This mood of fear and uncertainty is created by the irresponsible and often blatantly incorrect utterances of politicians.

Our history is littered with the artwork of scaremongers, hate mongers and chauvinists who, by their words, create unnecessary tension and at times violence just to gain transient political mileage.

Kenyans will no doubt remember the infamous “Shadow Cabinet” tabled in Parliament by then assistant minister in the Office of the President John Keen. It was a time of turmoil during which Kenyans agitated for more open political space and because of which many dissidents and opposition politicians were held in detention without trial. An election was also two years away.

Mr Keen’s ‘‘Shadow Cabinet,’’ in which all dissidents were alleged to have been given big jobs, was a ploy to create uncertainty by pretending that they were preparing to remove the government of Mr Daniel Moi.

In 2003 during an interview with the Nation, Mr Keen described the list he had tabled in Parliament as “rubbish”. It was a fictitious document created to provide a political excuse to detain the opponents of Mr Moi, he said.

Others have specialised in tribal intimidation. Mr William ole Ntimama went down in history in February 1991 when he warned one community to “lie low like envelopes or suffer the consequences”, ordering its members to shut up when others speak or risk being “cut down to size like the Ibo of Nigeria”.

More recently during the launch of the Party of National Unity, politician after politician spoke of Mr Raila Odinga, the Orange presidential candidate as a “dangerous man” who cannot be trusted with power. They neglected to explain, however, when the man with whom they sat in the same Cabinet only two years ago and who has been a political ally of many years, became “dangerous”.

Mr Odinga himself recently spoke of an alleged government ploy to cause violence using the police so as to get an excuse to delay the election. He offered no evidence to support those allegations.

The effect of all this talk of dangerous people and armed plots is to create a mood of artificial instability and to frighten the people. It serves no useful purpose and is irresponsible.

Leaders must recognise that they too have a stake in the stability and peace of the nation. Those who lose the election want to be able to carry on with their other activities in a good atmosphere. Those who win the election want to govern a peaceful country.

Let politicians debate in an open political atmosphere, but let them stop trying to frighten Kenyans.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by tumaina , October 14, 2007
Well written, whats the way forward for Kenyans? what we are doing is Kicking one corrupt chief and replacing him with an even more corrupt tribal chieftain, the problem i thing lies squarely on us the kenyan elites, we own the information but deny our brothers in the villages the same priviledge, lets stop all this nonsense and save Kenya.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Future is bright
written by mkenyadamu , October 15, 2007
Tumaina
Problem is no one else is offering an alternative, so we are left in the dilemma of chosing the less scary monster.On a serous note though, i think that development in all it faucets is a process not an event, so it will take time, at least we are headed somewhere, obviously Kibaki was far much bettter than Moi if the next president is better than him then in future there is hope for our children or their cildren.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Saturday, 13 October 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company