Partisan politics and ethnicity; the twin curse of Kenyan politics PDF Print E-mail
Written by Kihiu Thairu   
Sunday, 24 February 2008

The past two months have seen our country slide into the kind of anarchy we somewhat foolishly assumed was not ours, we were above it, and two months after it all begun, we seem as distant from a resolution as ever. The loss of life and property, the unbridled eagerness to stoke hatred between Kenyan ethnicities that have co-existed in harmony for more than 45 years, shameless political rhetoric of the kind that damages long into the future, the extensive damage to the country's opportunities for growing its economy and its dignity among the nations of the world, the list of shames goes on and its consequences threaten to last a long time into the future. 

Faced with so compelling a nightmare, it is a mystery that it is taking so long for the political class to act decisively to bring the crisis to an end. As time passes, and animosity is built up, Kenya it seems is digging herself deeper into a mess, one from which extraction promises to be infinitely more difficult.  So low have we sunk that it is probable that even as you begin to read this article you are pondering, huyu muandishi ni wa kabila gan?,' so that you can prejudge the views presented here.  That is itself central to our present crisis, the fact that we give so much weight to what is mere historical happenstance, that over which we have no control, all the time neglecting the countless relationships and experiences we have enjoyed that should make us see ourselves as one people, perhaps with competing interests and histories, but essentially joined up in the effort of making a success of Kenya.

We were not always like this, but political freedom it seems has changed us. 1991 and the repeal of the notorious section 2A of the constitution brought much hope for progress and prosperity.  All around the country was great relief; here at last was the end of tyranny, we celebrated.

Those expectations were, however, short lived and the country continues to writhe in the agonies of the birth of pluralism. There are many factors that have fuelled our fall, the failure of elective politics to improve the state of our country; but two of them stand out most: the extremely partisan nature of our politics and the prominent position of ethnicity in national discourse.

Our partisan politics have frustrated any hopes Kenya's citizens had for the empowerment of the citizen, for better representation of the electorate's needs and for more responsible and inclusive governance. The scramble for power that ensued after the 1991 reforms has led merely to more ruthless competition among the political class while delivering very little in tangible benefits to the people. There seem to be few real goals to our politics other than a mad rush for power and the accrual of personal wealth. There are not many values the politicians can be said to be really passionate about and very little either that opinion in parliament coalesces about. One can almost predict with certainty that no matter how benign or foul a proposal is, there will be parties ranged on either side to viciously protect or oppose it.

Perhaps it was set-up from the beginning to be this way. As the fruits of power politics were dangled low, competition grew fierce among the political class, and with egos and financial realities standing in the way of ambition, recourse was made to ethnicity as the surest means of collecting support around a political banner. 

So powerful and entrenched have these two influences, extreme partisanship and ethnicity, become on our politics that all the major parties regardless of size and the resources they can marshal, are guilty of using them to define and impassion their constituencies.  And it is not just the political class. Ethnicity and partisan politics have become us. The printed media has in the months preceding the elections made many references to ‘tribal mathematics' especially in the context of the presidential elections. Pundits compute the likelihood of electoral success not on the strength of policies and ideas, but on the divination of ethnic probabilities. Media companies have taken sides in the political debate and pay very little attention to the issues. Even the most unexacting research is avoided and the most profound issues refracted through the prism of the political side the company has chosen to support, with scant regard for sacred fact.

Unlike what prevails in the more established/advanced democracies where political parties are historical organisations shaped around ideology and value systems, in Kenya, personalities, personal alliances, egos, the threat of violence and the ability to raise a large enough coalition of ethnic supremos is the preferred political stratagem for political success. Almost every last Kenyan political party finds itself built on exactly these influences, thriving on nothing but the most colourful, if inane,  promises.

So it is that for the majority of the politicians in Kenya today, the reality is that political parties are mere temporary vehicles, aimed at getting political power and the opulence that comes with it. There is nothing in political passion that represents a zeal for service or any real ideas. The elected leaders know it and most citizens surely know it. One only needs to review the party switching habits of many of the more seasoned elected officials, or examine the kind of coalitions they have formed.  Most politicians have shifted between parties, some, many times over, they have formed alliances with those they would have in the previous days considered their arch-foes and started defending positions they were cursing as heretical only a few days prior.                                                                                                                                                                        
And it is this fluidity that Kenyans would have expected to come to the fore at this election. Pictures of apparent foes high-fiving each other and throwing their heads back in laughter indicate the possibility of compromise and the potential for a leadership that can steer Kenya back into clearer waters. The future of Kenya depends on its citizens thinking and acting as one nation, taking pride in their heterogeneity, and maximizing on the strengths that this diversity brings. The political class and Kenyans at every level must also open their eyes to the damage wrought by partisan politics, the missed opportunities and the fact that the present state is beneficial to no one. Partisanship precludes an understanding that part of our oneness is a shared tragedy of loss and want, poverty and a lack of opportunity, envy and hatred. We must soon realise that only in coming together do we find solutions.

This is the trend across the world. For instance the European Union has been growing towards greater integration even as we speak greater deeper cooperation and mutual assistance is delivering for its citizens. Every other country where sectarianism has been promoted is characterized by strife. It is imperative, especially in this period of great anguish, that Kenya take a leaf from its Southern neighbour.

Mwalimu Julius Nyerere surely got it right with Undugu. If nothing else, what he achieved with this in terms of strengthening nationalism has surely set Tanzania well for continued integration and prosperity. Kenya will be left wallowing in the mud if current leaders are allowed to continue fomenting divisive politics by building tribal fiefdoms. We are all of us in a leaking boat and no one can afford to be restrained about the urgent need to be bailing and fixing those leaks. Divided we will surely sink.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (4)add
0
...
written by Johnny B.Goode , February 25, 2008
What people forget is that our is an extremely young nation. What we are going through are the birth pains as we forge forward. Our European counterparts have thousands of documented history behind them. Due to the way our ancestors passed on information, we can hardly trace our roots beyond 1900. The colonial area is the broom that swept our past and created a huge chasm between what was and what is. Any democratic state will however learn not to put their faith in politicians but on strong independent institutions. An independent judiciary is paramount. The police seems to be a basket case. That will be a hard nut to crack. How do you run a security apparatus where Kalenjin cops won't protect Kikuyu civilians and Kikuyu cops won't protect Luo civilians.In such a circumstance you can hardly enforce the right to own property in any part of the country. Speaking of the EU. It's funny how they won't let Turkey join.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Shiroh , February 25, 2008
I do hope at the end of all these madness Kenya learns the truth
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
afrobarometer
written by Amir Ibrahim , February 25, 2008
I suppose this extends to the conversation on another thread about the AfroBarometer survey. Our unceasing partisanship and ukabila make us oppose even those measures that are most likely to improve our lives. No one from Western Kenya acknowledges all the hard-work and money that was put in by the Kibaki government there across the sectors, he is a Kikuyu and hence a taker, not a giver. Kibaki is portrayed as a willing partner of the American state in its war on terror, despite his adamant refusal to sign the world courts treaty or to host Africom in Kenya. The media especially has completely abdicated their responsibility, when you read an article from Kipkorir, Tanui, Onyango, Odipo, Okungu, Oloo whoever else, you can tell that there is no attempt at objectivity, even rationality, throw the truth to the wind and back your man. How many Kenyans know that there was a slash in half of malaria figures? How many know that the price paid to a farmer for maize, tea, milk and coffee jumped up by 100% plus? Not many, the opposition and the media campaigned for freedom from tyranny. And again as has been said repeatedly, the truly shocking abdication of responsibility by the likes of Maina Kiai, Muthoni Wanyeki and Mwalimu Mati, people for whom the ODM can do no wrong, and the government nothing right. I even heard Maina Kiai claim that there had been since 2005 an unending crackdown on media freedom!! As represented by what? The fact that all the media had free-rein to do as they pleased? Shocking but true. The story of Kenya.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by manta ray , February 25, 2008
Amir Ibrahim, you have called it correctly.
Maybe we need to enact a system of governance that does away with politicians and ESPECIALLY MPs altogether, and only have elections for a President. We can do without a parliament.We should find another system to take its place.
Why is it CDF works where politicians cannot impose their will? You have multi-ethnic CDF committees in the rural areas that work very harmoniously without overt tribalism being displayed and we can all see the results, until the politico shows up.
Museveni was partly right. Political parties are simply vehicles for self aggrandizement by the owners, with gullible and ignorant youths as their biggest constituency.
Kenya also needs massive civic education as a matter of urgency. Most people do not understand politics and its relation to governance so they can never tell the difference between a thug and a politician. We all know there is none.
In addition, tribalism and ethnic chauvinism, even if its not overt, needs to made a serious crime, minimum sentence 20 years to hanging as punishment.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Monday, 25 February 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company