Home
Political tribalism, moral ethnicity PDF Print E-mail
Written by Daniel Waweru   
Tuesday, 22 January 2008

Unlike, apparently, rather a lot of the people I like and respect, I think that the boycotts strategy announced by the ODM is a disastrous move, one that can only lead to greater pain. Let me explain. John Lonsdale somewhere distinguishes between political tribalism and moral ethnicity. (Never mind that I've always thought it a slightly tenuous distinction - everybody thinks the same of most distinctions they didn't first think of themselves.) Political tribalism is the constitution of an ethnicity by competition for state power and largesse against other, similarly constituted, ethnicities.  Moral ethnicity on the other hand is a set of assumptions about public virtue for people like us. Political tribalism is inevitably adversarial; moral ethnicity inward-looking.

 Lonsdale has suggested (in his masterly Wealth, Poverty and Civic Virtue in Kikuyu Political Thought) that political tribalism is driven by elite interests. One substantial piece of evidence in his favour: despite the fierce ethnic mobilisation that has coincided with electioneering in the past, Kenyans, it seems, have generally been able to restore normal interethnic relationships once all the sturm and drang has passed. Elite competition having taken its course, ethnic identities relax into shapes which allow everyday life to continue. Not so - or, at least, not so much - this time.

odm.jpg
 ODM supporters at a rally, DeMosh@ Flickr

I'd like to suggest a reason why this is. Moral ethnicity in Kenya has been corrupted by political tribalism. If moral ethnicity determines standards that one has to meet to be a member in good standing of a given ethnicity, some of those standards are now borrowed from the repertoire of political tribalism. So, for example, Luo friends of mine were called bad Luos (and worse) for not voting for or supporting the ODM, and Kikuyu friends were called traitors (and worse) for not voting or backing the PNU- and allied parties (or, as in my case, abstaining).

It has become necessary now, that we face the fact that our ethnic identities are presently constituted mainly by the political activity they permit. This really shouldn't come as a surprise - not a lot is left of most lived Kenyan ethnic identities after language and politics are removed. (Maybe Muslims are a partial exception. This election has seen the birth of a Muslim 'tribe '; recapitulating the venerable history of that process in Kenya: competing elites strike deals with state power to deliver support by creating a unified, exclusive community out of a plurality of them. If, like me, you buy this story, then Muslims are the only tribe in Kenya defined by religion.)

Objection: political tribalism hasn't really corrupted moral ethnicity; the present mess is the aftermath (and continuation) of what has been a semi-permanent political campaign (since 2005); so what we're seeing now is the tail end of a particularly severe bout of ethnic mobilisation by our rulers; we can expect a return to the relatively benign inter-ethnic status quo ante once things calm down.

Reply: I don't think so, mainly on account of the magnitude and viciousness of recent violence. As I've said elsewhere, both these are new to independent Kenya (Yes, I do know about the Wagalla massacre and the 1982 coup attempt, and the myriad outbreaks of ethnic conflict in the Rift Valley and at the Coast,thanks).

kibakimandela.jpg
 President Kibaki with Nelson Mandela

When the tribe is under attack, virtue consists in defending it. That judgement is relatively independent of political context. The results are easy to spot: there's a genuinely new form of ethnic hatred afoot - the sort of cold, implacable, unashamed kind that, I'm embarrassed to admit, I once thought only Rwandans were capable of.

The transformation thus is as follows, in the past, (well, for many of us) even overt attention to ethnic difference was shameful because it was inconsistent with both our internal and external moral codes. Now, however, we unashamedly express ourselves hatefully because our corrupt internal moral codes allow - sometimes even demand - it

What does all this have to do with boycotts? Antiguamente, Kenyans were able to resume normal interethnic relationships in virtue of sheer proximity. It is hard to believe all the bad things politicians say about the other (and even harder to allow them to determine your sense of belonging) when you're buying mboga from them, or getting or giving them a loan, or having a beer with them, or trying to get them to sleep with you.

Work has been the crucial site for these sorts of interethnic negotiations: I was amazed, a few days after the violence began, how unrancorous talk - even political talk - at some private firms was, even while horrific images were pumped out on TV. It is precisely these interactions that in the past have enabled us to stuff the ethnicity genie back into the political bottle. The introduction of the adversarial stuff into workplace interactions ought, so far as is possible, to be avoided. Applause for the alleged sacking of non-GEMA employees at Brookside should not become a test of genuine Kikuyuness.

 The economic boycotts are already ethnicised - plans to boycott Equity couched in terms of bringing down the Kikuyu bank, or plans to boycott Spectre described in terms of doing harm to Luo interests aren't far to seek on the Kenyan web. The boycotts, and their ethnicisation, began quite early on; ODM is only formalising and extending a process already informally in progress.

It is a disastrous step. We need actually to spend time in each other's company to rebuild the trust necessary for reconciliation - segregating ourselves at work or play is guaranteed  to fatally stunt that process. Spending time with those and only those one agrees with leads to the whole group becoming radicalised; and, in these times, that can only mean an increase in rage and hate. So, if you know anyone who's planning to sack employees from the other side, or refuses to rent a house to someone from the other side, or is intending to boycott a bank because it's owned by the other side...ask them to please to stop, in the name of Kenya.


Daniel Waweru
About the author:

Daniel Waweru likes Thomases Mboya and Gray, and Johns Kenyatta and Lonsdale.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (23)add
0
...
written by Vikii , January 22, 2008
I am waiting for that time when Kenyan politics will be de-ethnicized. When I hear people say; 'Luhyas are likely to vote for...., Kalejin's interests are best taken care of if they vote for......., luos will obviously vote for..., Kikuyus will undoubtedly vote for... and the kambas as expected will vote for so and so', I ask myself, "how does the average Kikuyu fellow in the village benefit by having Kibaki in Statehouse?"

Unless and until people accept the fact that a President can only help you if his government adopts sound policies---those that support the expansion of the economy, that improve security for the people, that expand the democratic space, that ensure affordable quality education and healthcare etc, then we will remain caught up in this circus forever. When a politician goes back to the village and tells his folks, 'we are going to statehouse...it is our turn..', by doing so, he has enlightened his community on who (which tribe) is the stumbling block to "their" ascesion to power. That is the genesis of the problem and trying to look for excuses else where is a waste of time.

The moment Raila Odinga made the "Adui" remark at KICC (after months of euphemising the same thing), his supporters took up the baton against these "dominant enemies called the Kikuyus". When Nyachae told his people that a Luo, by virtue of being uncut, is unfit to lead anybody, there are those who believed it and will do everything to block such a 'catastrophe'. "Given a Luo and a Luhya, I would go for a Luo because with all their weaknesses, they have clout" This was said by a man we all love called Kenneth Matiba to spite Shikuku. We love him for what he has done for the country, but the truth of the matter is that when such popular politicians grab those damn microphones and spit those words, our suspcions are aroused. In other words, the bug stops with our political leaders.

I have said it in other fora and I will say it here; We have to groom a modern set of leaders. It is a pity that we kenyans derive pleasure from being led by people clearly lacking any fresh ideas. They have colonial hangovers and they use their positions to poison our thinking. What is so wrong with having Dr. Mukhisa Kituyi, Dr. Willy Mutunga, Dr. PLO Lumumba, Mr. Maina Kiai, Rev Mutava Musyimi and Mr. Raphael Tuju as the team to lead us into the future? These are fellows who as far as I am concerned do not understand the language of the 'tribe'. They have proved beyond any doubt that they will never allow themselves to be held hostage by their tribes and that is what we should be looking for in leaders. The current President, for example, is by and large a good man, but one who cannot shed off his cartel of overbearing friends (And it is true most of them are his tribesmen). If Mwai Kibaki was an independent person today, Kenya would be miles ahead. Credit to him for what he has managed to achieve, but he could do better without the input of the Karumes, Murungarus and Michukis of this world.

We have a long way to go, brothers. Muungano wa mageuzi was a good idea and we need another muungano now more than ever before.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Violence is humane
written by Wuod Aketch , January 22, 2008
I am waiting for that time when Kenyan politics will be de-ethnicized. When I hear people say; 'Luhyas are likely to vote for...., Kalejin's interests are best taken care of if they vote for......., luos will obviously vote for..., Kikuyus will undoubtedly vote for... and the kambas as expected will vote for so and so', I ask myself, "how does the average Kikuyu fellow in the village benefit by having Kibaki in Statehouse?"


The road leading to his boma is tarmacked and he has free running water (I assure you this is true, in Kikuyu areas that I know near Nairobi, people do not pay for running water)!!! They also pay less taxes compared to other poorer regions in the country

Being of different ethnies and being aware of our ethnicity is necessary for the cultural diversity of this country.
What will Kenya be without the githeri or the ngege that Kamau and onyango, respectively, can offer you when you are are their hosts . I enjoy the cold nights around the fire enjoying the milk from the calabash in ole tipapa's manyatta.
I cannot imagine a Kenya where everybody is having a unique language, music, food ...
A coca cola or MacDonald Kenya is not my vision of this country. We only need to cultivate our differences in a civilized and peaceful manner and we will be the richest nation on earth.
So let us not be naive, the human being is violent by nature. Fighting and killing each other is not that bad because after the storm the sunny weather.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Vikii , January 23, 2008
Wuod Aketch, I am very disappointed with you. I expected you to provide informed leadership to the fellows in Luo Nyanza, but I am afraid if there is any difference between you and the majority of them, that difference is negligible, at least that is what you just proved to me. If you honestly think hooliganism and primitive violence still have room in the 21st century, then we can do with some prayers.

I will tell you the truth Wuod; My family comes from Kitui which is definitely not one of the most developed districts in the country. But I can assure you right now Kitui's lack of development is attributable to KENYA not having had good leaders since independence.It has nothing to do with the President of Kenya not being Kalonzo or some other Kamba. You seem to believe if Raila odinga becomes President, then the "road to your boma will be tarmacked". Well that one will never happen and you can take that to the bank. Central province people pay less tax? What exactly do you mean? Which tax are you talking about here? Is it PAYE, VAT, extortions by Mungiki and Taliban or what is it? You continue to support the view some of us have that violence is being perpetuated by people who were not planning to pay rent and bus fares in 2008 but whose plans were thwarted by Kibaki's victory. It is a dangerous mentality that one Mr. Aketch.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
A new breed of leaders
written by pndiangui , January 23, 2008
As said above I coudn't agree more those politicians can lead us to the de-tribalized Kenya and even others we don't know.
Mwai Kibaki or Raila Odinga cannot be part of the solution that is to de-ethnicise this nation.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Surprise? I love Africa
written by KiMeli , January 23, 2008
'get dissapointed in someone, not with someone'
Anyhow, have you [Viiki] ever heard-by chance or rumour- that one Johnstone Kamau Muigai Kenyatta Jomo asked one Bildad Kagia 'What he had done for himself' after Independence, becoz the former disagreed with the greed exhibited by his 'excellency' .

How do you Viki 'suppose Kenyatta got all that land in Taita Taveta? Inherited from his parents?

I BEG TO UNDERSTAND...how did Eldoret Airport establishment fund (whose economic function remains to be decided) surpass Kisumu Airport during Moi era, yet Kisumu, disregarding its Luo populace was a better economic gamble?

I have always thought Moi was very kind to his people he thought their goats needed good rest on pavement after meals to enhance milk production. What do you think?

What I think is that while this happens, it stinks to the highest heavens, and that political maturity shall only be achieved when this kind of reasoning and acting is halted. In Uganda, the Baganda are having a siesta as the Acholi are marginalized and killed by Kony in the North, while Yoweri seeks to help end Kenya's mess!

We are progressing. Today an opposition member in Kenya is not afraid losing business for merely saying nay. But with this mess...lets see before I get all glittered.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
The answer to these
written by This year , January 23, 2008
I was touched by this man's mail and am not ashamed to post them here as they
MAKE SENSE.....
quote

I have been soul searching which way forward as a Luo community.
The just concluded election as a community we organized and supported
Raila as we have always done. But I knew things won˘t go well when Raila used
The tribal card as his main campaign tool where he turned other
tribes against Kikuyu in order to defeat Kibaki. I found that irresponsible
because at any time it could bring bloodshed.

I am from Ugenya constituency and most constituents wanted
Stephen Okoth because Orengo once elected stays in Nairobi never comes back. So we
wanted somebody who will be with us as a community. The Raila
Machine rigged Orengo in and that was the end of the people˘s choice.
Raila did not talk about rigging then why is he speaking about it now. When
Orengo went against Raila he was rigged out but when he supported Raila
he was rigged in. So I have come to realize that Raila is not about
justice or democracy or common man he is about power.

I think it is time as a Luo community we start supporting another
Family we have been supporting the Odinga family for over 50 years but
we have nothing to show for it. Every government comes along they rub it the
wrong way and we had to stay in the opposition all this time. When
Kenyatta offered Odinga the Vice Presidency he continued to
attack the government and even went ahead and started his own party when he
was just a heart beat away from the presidency and I think that was very
Stupid.

Kenyatta appointed Moi and Moi was an example of what Odinga
would have done, he remained loyal to Kenyatta and he finally got his
reward. After Moi became president he invited Odinga to join his government.
Odinga started bragging that Moi could not lead without him. Moi heard
it and dropped him like a hot potato.

When Raila said tosha to Kibaki all he needed was to continue to
be loyal to Kibaki and probably when Wamalwa passed away he would have
been made a VP but just like his father he started attacking the government from
inside and he was eventually kicked out. Now Kibaki would not
want to hear of him in the government because he is a headache.

What has been polarizing even among us as a community without
knowing is that the Odinga family has been portraying a communist image, a
man of the people or the people˘s president but the family is as
capitalistic as any one can get. The fact remain the family is one of the richest in
Kenya through the gas business, entrepreneurship which they have failed
to lead us into. I was surprised when Raila informed us that we can grow
Coffee in Nyanza. I asked myself after 40 years since every other
community who could grow coffee has grown it is the time Raila is talking about
it?

Fellow Wajaluo it is time to give another family a chance, the
Odinga family might have charisma but they don˘t have the wisdom to lead
us as a community where we want to go. Look at Oburu he sleeps for 5
years and then get elected almost unopposed as if he owns Bondo
constituency just because his name end with Odinga. Now compare that with all the work
Tuju did for Rarieda but because his name does not end with
Odinga he was thrown out or rigged out.

We have also to think again on how we conduct ourselves as a
community, since independence the Kikuyus have change their royalty from
Kenyatta, Matiba and then Kibaki. We are the only people who have been
stuck with one family. If we have been held by a spell we need to get rid of
it, we cannot keep backing the same family for a whole century. When
Matiba was rigged by Moi in 1992 did the Kikuyu people riot and loot and burn
Murang˘a? No. In 1997 when Moi rigged Kibaki did the Kikuyu in
Nyeri riot loot and burn businesses? No. We have to think again and abandon
This type of leadership which radicalize the youth with nothing to
offer. We are suffering now in Kisumu because most of the stores are either
Looted or burned now who is going to suffer the Kikuyu the Kisii or Luo?
Jaluo.

The Kisii too have done away with Nyachae they have changed their
loyalty. The Kalenjin have changed their loyalty from Moi they have
refused to stick with his sons so we need to wake up.

It is time to support a progressive leader who people can
disagree with without being stoned who can lead Luo people in doing business,
in doing farming and in wise politics. By wise politics I mean a person
Who knows when to oppose and when to cooperate. Opposing all the time is
stupid and retrogressive.

The author is Stephen Ochichi
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Will Mutava Musyimi Please Sta
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
Hey Mutava Musyime used to be reasonable what happened
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Hey Guys- Please lets not be L
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
(Unnecessary personalised antagonism shortened in favour of the substantial critique. Ed.)

I have been to Kieni in Nyeri and Suba in Nyanza. I have seen poverty in those areas. I have been to Kwale and there is poverty.

I do not think these people are lazy.I just believe that the Kenyan society needs to be reformed. Starting with the constitution.

Stop advancing tribalism.

I hope I can get people to agree with me.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Anew breed of leaders
written by InSidious , January 23, 2008
As said above I coudnt agree more those fellas can lead us to the de-tribalized Kenya and even others we dont know.
Mwai Kibaki or Raila Odinga cannot be part of the solution that is to de-ethnise this nation.


Interesting note: Let's assume a compromise is struck that dictates the following; Raila & Kibaki will not hold Public Office. Do you see Kalonzo being voted in or Ruto for that matter? Who would be your compromise candidate, Noah Katana Ngala, Uhuru, Mudavadi, Muite maybe? Fact is Kenyan's are currently in an emotional cyclone of opposing forces and tough decisions must be made in the next few days. Compromises must be made however more significantly, both sides MUST give peace a chance and prevail upon their supporters to STOP acting like savages.

(Correction inserted as per request of author. Ed.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , January 23, 2008
Kenya politics came close to being de-ethnicised in 2002. Raila said Kibaki Tosha, Kibaki was not a Luo at that time. He and others campaigned for Kibaki tirelessly in his absence and he later won the elections triumpantly. What did he do after he got in statehouse? He surrounded himself with the 7Ms (I believe these are the very bad people Kivuitu was talking about - who should never have come into this world) who were all from his community and forgot about the likes of Raila and the rest who had helped bring him to power.

(Tribalist allegations deleted. Ed.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by This year , January 23, 2008
Truth Be Told - Will Mutava Musyimi Please Sta | Author | 2008-01-23 09:07:45
Hey Mutava Musyime used to be reasonable what happened?

HE JOINED PNU AND CAN NOT TAKE ANOTHER STAND PLEASE. KEEPING QUIET IS THE CORRECT THING AS THIS WAY HE WILL NOT CONTRADICT HIMSELF.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
De-ethnicising politics
written by mkosakabila , January 23, 2008
One way of doing this would be to improve living standards and welfare overall. For as long as 'tribe' remains an ideology for the (re)allocation of resources and a poor woman/man sees tribe as the primary means by which their livelihood is assured, then they'll go for that, with great payoffs for unscrupulous politicians who will manipulate and milk the cleavage. Kenyan politicians are such.....sleaze.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
stop, look
written by Timothy Wainaina , January 23, 2008
Two things.
Firstly, Raila did not control the KANU rebels in 2002, remember that some among them were his enemies having only recently been subjected to his tyrannical rule in KANU. I wager that Kamotho and Saitoti for example and very likely many others would have gone with Kibaki rather than stay with Raila who after all was a mere provincial interloper into KANU.

Secondly, it seems to me that Kenyans are much too willing to blame Kibaki for the fall-out in the NARC coalition. Now it is a given that all coalitions have their troubles, but is it not also clear that Raila can never sit in the same party with anyone strong enough to have his independent following, consider the following
Wamalwa and FORD-K
Moi and KANU
Kibaki and NARC
Kalonzo and ODM-K

It seems pretty clear to me, also considering the threatening way that Ruto was looking at MPs speaker ballots that there is a thuggishness in Raila/Ruto axis that many people find more than a little off-putting. Wouldn't you agree? I know that I would find it very difficult to work with them, did Musalia not himself tell us that there was a tyrant in the ODM? Had he been less supine, maybe the election would have gone a different way.
I suppose anonymous is not willing to put a name to his tribalistic face, given the prominence of the ODM's 41 strategy, eh?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
More on de-ethnicising politic
written by mkosakabila , January 23, 2008
Hard to believe that Kenyan politics was close to being de-ethnicised in 2002. I'd say supporting Kibaki was still part of the ethnic calculation--split the Kikuyu votes with Kibaki tosha! Consider the counterfactual--what would have happend if Raila had gone it alone at that time? Why Kibaki tosha anyway?
But I digress, we need to deal with today and tomorrow. Whatever happened to GDP--growth and development party that one Ribeiro had set up as we neared the election, or Maathai's green party, or even....KANU, which until 2007 election was the only political party that could be called that. How about Atwoli and his trade union?
My point is that we really need to think differently and construct parties that are consisetnt with our aspirations, experiences and heritage--not a single politician's lust for power. Our current crop of politicians is not up to the task. Just look at us now!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by aeichener , January 23, 2008
(This one is for Cirdan)

I fully agree with Mkosakabila. Unfortunately, the politics of patronage - to a certain extent an understandable reaction of the villager plunged into a complex, increasingly urbanized society - have been long-standing since colonial times.

The problem is that beyond a network of merely personalized or blood-related recommendation or patronage (both of which may on the ground simply translate to the well-known "this candidate is from my village and I know his/her family well" criterion), the increasily tribalized Kenyan society has exchanged these understandable threads of mutual knowledge, affirmation and dependency against tribal biases.

Notoriously, the notion of "tribal identity" is to some extent a colonial construct (how small or large the "construct" part is deemed to be, depends upon the spectator's own epistemological position or bias... let it suffice to state that for example the famous Njuri Ncheke of the Ameru, this age-old council shouded in venerability and romanticised deep African Volksgeist mystery [ahem...] owe their survival and today existence not to the ancient, sacred traditions and love of heritage of the Ameru people, but to the spirited, idealistic, altruistic and far-sighted efforts of two anthropologically interested British district officers in the 1920s-1930s; teste the brilliant field research of Jeffrey Fadiman in Meru social history).

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
PARLIAMENTARY VS PRESIDENTIAL
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
Truth peace and Justice should lead us to Canaan.

The politics of tribal hatred emanate from the imperial presidency and the winner take all politics of Kenya.

Michuki believes they won and thus everything is for the winner

Given that the Kenya constituition is a hybrid of the Presidential and Parliamentary system then shouldnt we then say ODM having the majority of seats should seat on the government side.

Let us solve our constitutional puzzle and save our beloved country
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Raila = De-ethnization
written by Wuod Aketch , January 23, 2008
Will get to be a new word in the dictionary!
Raila, as someone has said here, de-ethnized politics in Kenya in 2002. I agree with this.

Even after being refused food service by some hotel owner, a relative of president Kibaki in some town in central province last year, Raila marched on. Who were the tribalists that time? Remember that like many of us, Raila, has a relative by marriage in this community.

Raila is the most de-ethnized politician we have on the political chess board. The whole country knows this. That is why the Kenyan people from Mombasa to Busia and from Namanga to Moyale listen to him. Raila has been the MP for Langata for a number of years unlike Mwai Kibaki who fled from Nairobi.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
The event was totally condemne
written by pndiangui , January 23, 2008
I remember the event having been totally condemned by many politicians from central Kenya. Even the former MP for Mathira invited Raila again to campaign in his constituency. Let's also remember Raila campaigned in OTHAYA without suffering any sort of humiliation. I wonder if Kibaki would have done the same in Bondo.

Moving on , I think at this critical time of our country , with the current hardships, it is the right time to enact the major reforms to our constitution. We can get two things out of this crises; A re-run of the presidential poll and a new constitution. The politics of winner-takes it all has got us to this. I think constructive regionalism and a parliamentary system with reduced power of the president will do well to quell the ethnicity of a 'favoured tribe'. However these reforms must happen with a lot of integrity, not the Majiomboism of chasing others from certain regions that we have witnessed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
ARE PNU MEMBERS DEVILS
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
Hello

It is his democratic right.We must stop thinking that that our political enemies are devils and we are angels

God save Kenya

Ps Did Mutava become bad because he joined PNU
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
We all have failed
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
At this critical juncture in our history we should be honest with ourselves.

1 We must at least admit that we had flawed elections.To think otherwise would be to cheat ourselves.There was no winner Kenya lost.

2 The election comission was a farce.To go for another election with this election comission is to fail future generations

2 That this ethnic hatred and self jusification must stop.

3 The displaced people must be resettled
and a permanent solutions be found to this problem.

4 The powers of the presidency must be reduced and the arms of government(Judiciary & Parliament) stregthened.

5 0ur votes must count for something

6 Lasly and most important reach out to fellow Kenyans regadless of tribe and or religion/

Let us shame our so called leaderd
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , January 23, 2008
It seems to me that there never really was any real glue holding us together as Kenyans, the yearning for Majimbo and the constant cry of marginalisation (much of its imagined) is clear evidence that we do not at all belong together. This was already clear from the early days of the independence struggle when fears of Kikuyu dominance by numbers and wealth, and Luo dominance by numbers and craft, took over the spirits of those from what were then styled the smaller tribes, leading to the most urgent call for Majimbo.

You'll recall these interesting statements from among those who would be called our founding fpoliticians, one each from the pro-and anti-Majimbo teams then. The first is from the great Jaramogi of whom I am an unabashed disciple and the second from Kenya's second president Daniel Arap Moi. In 1993, I think it was, the Jaramogi captured the spirit of exclusion and desperation among the Luo elite when he praised the very Moi who had been the firm hand behind many of his travails, conceding that the younger politician was like a giraffe who could see far into the future. Perhaps he was speaking about Moi's August 1958 prediction that Kenya would remain caught up in the spirit of tribalism for the next fifty years at least, a warning which he repeated even as we clamoured like the Israelites of old for our kings. Today we are at the tail-end of that prediction and Moi it seems remains vindicated.

Incidentally is it not interesting not that the Aembu and the Bukusu seem to have over time moved over to the side advocating a unitary Kenya, while the Luo are now pro-Majimbo having in the 1960s been so vehemently opposed?
RVP Jingoism seems however to have remained pretty constant, with the madoadoa talk of today echoing sentimes of Moi's from as long ago as 1961 decrying the presence of Kikuyu squatters there.
Waweru,
I cannot quite bring myself to say moral ethnicity, it always comes as ethnic morality, although I suppose that would be something different, but the spirit of the riots seems to me to be a fusion of this ethnic morality (we decree what is right, Cf. the shame in targeting particular populations and the brazenness with which other life is hunted) and political tribalism into a powerful jingoistic thread that demands dominance and the annihilation of the other. This ethnic morality needs no catalyst for its transformation into political tribalism, being as it is an isotope of its perhaps marginally less stable sibling.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Quibble, quibble
written by Daniel.Waweru , January 24, 2008
You're much too pessimistic on the unity of Kenya. There was a glue, more importantly, an ideological glue, that held it together: African nationalism (rather, the desire for African control of state power). The immediate appeal, and obvious justice, of African nationalism united all the independence-generation leaders, even Moi. Support for majimbo, or recognition of uneven economic development, wasn't inconsistent with that aim.

(Moi's 1958 proclamation was just as self-serving as his 1990 one (that multipartyism meant violence): it wasn't so much a prediction of what would happen, as an announcement of what he would do. But even he was a nationalist in his own way; I've never forgotten hearing him address a Machakos KANU rally in Kamba.

Nietzsche says somewhere that there was only one true Christian, and that he died on the Cross. I'm a worshipper at the shrine of Mboya; I sometimes feel that he was the only true Kenyan. So I don't take kindly to either the Jaramogi's (and his wafuasi's) plotting against him in life, or their grossly opportunisitic exploitation of his death. In life, the contempt for Mboya took the crudest forms, such as insisting that he wasn't a true Luo because he was Suba, and because he had grown up partly in Kikuyuland. The Jaramogi and his wafuasi wasted no time incorporating him into the Luo Pantheon once he was dead. But I digress.)

I'll quibble slightly with your thoughts about ethnicity.

Moral ethnicity is about public virtue for a group of people: how should we (the people of this place, who have this history, etc) act in the sight of others? So Odera Akang'o's exceptionally vigorous enforcement of high standards of education and hygiene is moral ethnicity at work: those willing to put up with the rigour of his rule eventually found a secure place amongst the Jo-Gem. Jacqueline Klopp's Can Moral Ethnicity Trump Political Tribalism has a more recent example: Kirwa made common cause with the poorest of the Kalenjin, Kikuyu, Kisii and Luhya voters in his Cherangany constituency to resist land-grabbing by Biwott and Moi. Hopefully, then, moral ethnicity is elastic enough to allow others to become one us.

Political tribalism is different. It's competitive, and therefore adversarial, from the start: the tribe is mobilised as a means of bargaining for, or taking, state power. Inevitably, thought and action is turned to identifying, demonising, and sometimes destroying the enemy. Hence William ole Ntimama's career.

Kikuyu peasant farmers carried their traditional morality, which very highly prized productive agricultural labour, into the RV; there they met others (Kalenjin, Kisii, Luhya) who didn't speak their own language but who had a similar conception of the honourable (male) life. (See also p. 468 of Lonsdale's piece). Reciprocal recognition, and a tentative accommodation, followed, even with periodic outbreaks of political tribalism. Until recently. Proof, maybe, that political tribalism and moral ethnicity are independent, and that benign moral ethnicity cannot long survive corruption by its sinister counterpart.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
We need one another
written by wandembei , February 05, 2008
Dear editor,
Kenyans may be made to look at themselves as ethnic sycophants but I have interacted with many members of different ethnic backgrounds and when anybody would ask me about my tribe I would insist, I "am Kenyan". Now we hope that those goons who think they can rule this country by tribe will think twice about what they are doing before they raise their weapons to kill their fellow Kenyans. We may be down but I believe we're not out. Soon we will be on our feet, soon we will be producing food and exporting it and returning where we once stood. The international community must take care what they say now and ensure that their interest in Kenya is the people's interest or else they may find they are putting fire in a house while sitting on its roof.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 23 January 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company