Portfolio balance; 21 questions PDF Print E-mail
Written by Open Thread   
Monday, 07 April 2008

Many Kenyans did not watch the football this weekend, they were at home waiting on the announcement of the Cabinet results, looking for relief after three months of almost fictional horror. But it was real enough, and as elements of the political class keep reminding us, a sequel is on the cards should their angry spirits not be mollified. The major reason for their grief, are captured in words that have now come into the shrine of our political lexicon for all time, Portfolio Balance. The trouble is, what seems important to some, seems less important to others.

Which ministries do you think are crucial to the running of the state and under whose control do they fall? Is the very idea of a Grand Coalition under such circumstances not anathema to national progress, after all the vigorous arguments betray a desire in the politicians not to serve all Kenyans but to serve specific narrow passions of their own.

Was the Salim Lone list fair? There seem to be an equal number of people on both sides (aside from those whose direct interests were at risk), who felt that the agreement was too lenient on the other side.  Supporters of the ODM swore against their champion Raila for being 'outsmarted by an octogenarian'. He should never have let the PNU have finance, and by all accounts giving away the Justice and Constitutional Affairs office was criminal, simply criminal considering the prominence of the reform agenda for the ODM.

On the other side were great numbers cursing the President, 'someone should have gone in with him, how dare he give away Foreign Affairs, or most egregious of all, how dare he give away Local Government'? 

What seems clear is that the levels of distrust are so great, that either side is looking at this distributive process as something of an arms race, looking to build up its armoury so as to withstand and retailate should it be attacked. Which side comes off better in the Lone list? Is the argument valid, that a certain party 'should' have a certain post? Are there any teeth in the threats issued now regularly from the ODM? Are the rumours of threats from Uhuru Kenyatta valid, and if so should the President not call his bluff? Is the KANU boss able to deliver on his threats?

Given the prominent role of the civil service, the centrality of Vision 2030 and the lesson hopefully well-learned that the experts are best allowed to do their jobs unhindered, does it really matter who gets what post? Are not the most radical decisions made by the Cabinet? Any hope  that the politicians will be driving any progress , or will they spend their days bickering and making merry ?

 

Final question for this entry, does anyone understand the sudden rise to prominence of Prof George Saitoti and Dalmas Otieno at these talks? These two after all are hardly ancient best friends of their principals?

 

 


Open Thread
About the author:
Please send the editors an email at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it on suggestions for topics on Open Thread.




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (9)add
0
ODM List
written by Johnny B. Goode , April 07, 2008
I think the ODM list was fair enough. The government kept key ministries including Finance, Internal security and defense. It's clear that if you keep finance, then you have to cough up quite a bit.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Portfolio
written by jj , April 07, 2008
I repeat Open Tread question and ask "which ministries are crucial to state running"rest this sharing of ministries leave all of as in a ditch full of water and Koffi Annan looking down the ditch can only see his reflection.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by manta ray , April 07, 2008
Uhuru should give up the Local Govt portfolio to the ODM and take up that of Nairobi Metropolitan development. If ODM mishandles the poisoned chalice that is the LG portfolio, they will have only themselves to blame in 2012 considering that they also control most town and city councils. The corruption in those councils will never end.
Many astute politicians have used the prominence of Big City leadership to rise to National leadership, from Rudi Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg in New York, Ken Livingstone in London and Yuri Luzhkov in Moscow. Uhuru should see this as an opportunity rather than a demotion. Such is the myopia of Kenya's politicians. Running a big city Govt is like running a small state!
Instead of fighting a slippery portfolio like Local Govt, he should be negotiating and demanding that the new Ministry have absolute executive Authority in Nairobi and be out of bounds to the local Govt Minister. Furthermore, he should demand a hefty budget to run it, and this should be easy as the Finance Ministry would be under PNU.
Secondly, he can demand that the city council is done away with and a brand new form of govt is introduced through the new Ministry.
He can therefore build a National profile that sets the standards for other local Govt authorities, and needless to say, will show what he can do if given responsibility.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by wangila , April 07, 2008
uhuru kenyatta should ultimately quit the local government in favour of ODM. after all, ODM controls over 3/4 of councils around the country. that position legitimately belongs to ODM.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re:
written by Johnny B. Goode , April 07, 2008
Uhuru should give up the Local Govt portfolio to the ODM and take up that of Nairobi Metropolitan development. If ODM mishandles the poisoned chalice that is the LG portfolio, they will have only themselves to blame in 2012 considering that they also control most town and city councils. The corruption in those councils will never end.
Many astute politicians have used the prominence of Big City leadership to rise to National leadership, from Rudi Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg in New York, Ken Livingstone in London and Yuri Luzhkov in Moscow. Uhuru should see this as an opportunity rather than a demotion. Such is the myopia of Kenya's politicians. Running a big city Govt is like running a small state!
Instead of fighting a slippery portfolio like Local Govt, he should be negotiating and demanding that the new Ministry have absolute executive Authority in Nairobi and be out of bounds to the local Govt Minister. Furthermore, he should demand a hefty budget to run it, and this should be easy as the Finance Ministry would be under PNU.
Secondly, he can demand that the city council is done away with and a brand new form of govt is introduced through the new Ministry.
He can therefore build a National profile that sets the standards for other local Govt authorities, and needless to say, will show what he can do if given responsibility.


Fair enough if the deal is sweetened with a deputy PM post.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by pushka , April 07, 2008
I think Kibaki and Raila should just throw caution to the wind and declare a cabinet of 20 ministries. Everyone gets 10 each.

If there are some that are in disagreement, then pass those to Kenya charity sweepstakes for a live draw. Let the chips fall where they may.

If there is a fall out as a result, at least the two politicians will have the goodwill of the nation behind them.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Boss
written by Omama , April 07, 2008
Finance, roads, transport and communication, education, Internal security, agriculture, education, Labor. Those are important to common man.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by izze , April 11, 2008
Dalmas Otieno :- (Watch this space)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
CABINET-Proffesional considera
written by Joseph , April 15, 2008
In making the grand coalition govt,President Kibaki and Rt.Hon. Raila Odinga failed Kenyans in one major respect: Failure to recognize professional achievement and related, expected output.

Take medical services ministry for instance---Hon.Anyang' Nyongo and Hon. Mutangatana have no relevant knowledge
in the area of medicine.What will they do ? Flying flags and eating.Cant they eat at their homes ? Raila / Kibaki ?

We may suggest that Prof Sam Ongeri takes medical services as Anyang' Nyongo' takes education or planning and vision 2030. This makes good sense.The assumption that it is for permanent secretaries to have relevant knowledge while ministers just doze around is fallacious .It has killed Kenya for the last four decades.

Another proposal: Dr. the Hon. Oburu odinga is Ph.d trained economist from Moscow university but how sharp is he to work with Kimunya ? Kimunya needed Omingo magara to screw the finance docket.One wonders whether Dr. Oburu Odinga is in good form today ?.The man will smile to death in that office.We Need young leaders to take critical, challenging jobs.If Dr.Oburu smiles to death what happens next ? Magara please take up that job.Oburu please join Ntimama at the national heritage office and smile, yaap together.

Hon Ruto is an ideal material for the local govt portfolio.He is aggressive and sharp.But let him screw agriculture lets have more maize, milk and honey. Hon Mudavadi, can work .But he must now start wearing a serious face.This gentle man thing isnt neccessary in the local govt docket.Mudavadi will work if he starts wearing a serious face and put relevant policy magic in local govt.

Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta has not shown leadership any where.He has moved so fast that his performance cannot be assesed.But for purposes of my central kenya uncles having own,tribal kingpin, let him be there only to face it rough again in 2012.

Orengo must show how law and related justice will address land issues especially in R.Valley.This must be done fairly.Historical injustices involving post-indepndence land grabbing must be told .And those who own vast land for nothing MUST surrender it to the landless.ORENGO, Please be fearless.FEAR NOT YOUR OWN BOSS RAILA.If Raila is compromised on this, he will not be head of state 2012.

Raila are you up for test, should you condone corruption, riches without work, police harrassment being meted out on peaceful demonstrators Kenyans will judge you harshly in 2012.This must be well communicated to you in advance.Kenyans want change.We seek law on housing so that reckless landlords raising rents day and night can be fixed.The lanlords have caused many Kenyans untold poverty.We need better roads, electricity accross all provinces, we need increased allocations to the CDF.We need a new constitution before end of this year.This is Raila's challenge because the constitution empowers him "to supervise and co-ordinate functions and affairs of govt including those of ministries".


For Hon. Saitoti, he must start giving Ojode the power to deal with Mungiki.We cannot risk our security.If leaders from Mt.Kenya want this sect, the let's go Majimbo.Ojode must be given lee-way to reveal to Kenyans what is it all about this Mungiki mystry that Mt.Kenya leaders are funning.Because we expect the to have relevant intelligency connections that can help clear this mess.They will never run away from it.PNU needed the ministry of internal security and defence and these must come to bear on all forms of security threats internal or external.


Finally, we demand to know the roles and clear functions of both the president and Prime minister.Who heads or does what and what is the extent of responsibility.We demand parliamentary supremacy from executive misdemeanours.


We want youthful M.Ps WHO FAILED TO SECURE appointments to the cabinet to take serious role in screwing cabinet.We hope Hon.Imanyara and hon. Ababu, pius, Mutuba-Namwamba among others will play this role.

KENYA MUST CHANGE-RAILA WE HOPE THAT "Power will not start entering into your nerves" as the late Vice-president remarked.

RAILA and ODM you're up for test.Your worth in 2012 depends on how you work for Kenyans today
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Monday, 07 April 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company