Home
Promoting hatred and violence, even now PDF Print E-mail
Written by Peter Ndiangui   
Tuesday, 22 January 2008

The ODM leader Raila Odinga is a famous man for his many talents. Foremost among these are his organising and rousing skills. It is true that few politicians in the history of Kenya have had as much ability to provoke their followers to action as has the ODM's captain. So it is that many Kenyans hoped in earnest that he would be able to quell the violent passion in his supporters, that he would be able to save Kenyan lives by asking that his people restrain themselves, take to the courts and settle disputes particularly those over land in a civilised and non-violent manner. He has pointedly refused to do that, famously insisting to the foreign media that he would not anaesthetize the Kenyan people as they were being raped, and then also shocking the international media by crudely comparing the post-election tragedy with mere post-match skirmishes between the supporters of rival football clubs.

But what is guaranteed to forever tie the opposition leader to the vicious outbreaks of violence against the GEMA ( Gikuyu, Meru, Embu) and the Kamba, is his announcement in Kisumu that, "We should have seven of the 10 parliamentary seats in Kisii, but Kibaki men stole the votes and we only got four. The Kisii are our people. We must not touch them." I understand that all well-meaning people are unlikely to believe that a national politician would so tacitly endorse violence against sections of the population, but here is the evidence from a newspaper that operates on a similar platform and which quite clearly endorses similar views

The ODM leader is in these fighting words endorsing violence against those who did not support his party, exonerating those who he has decided voted for him and as a result condemning the others, those non-Kenyans to whatever the wananchi class will decide is their fate. Whereas the Kisii should not be touched, the GEMA and the Akamba who have been the other main victims of this violence, may be touched. This, is the humble pronouncement of a national leader at a rally where he had a great opportunity to take on a reconciliatory stance, to play president and promote an end to the violence. Instead he took to the stage and taking advantage of the people's emotional state, urged the crowds to come out and fight in the streets.

I am not sure that the people of Kisii would be happy to have their lives saved by these kind words, and we should perhaps not be surprised by Raila's statement, he is after all the first national politician in Kenyan history to declare an entire fifth of the country's population 'adui'. He also bears the great distinction of being the first national politician (in Meru during the campaigns) to promise tears to those who would not vote for him. I do not know how those Luhya and Kisii families who lost their people in the Rift Valley will take to the ODM candidate's attempt to appropriate for his altar the lives of all those who died in the Rift Valley. I am not sure what they will make of his failure to lament the bows and arrows, he did not lament the burned church, or the doors marked with the ODM 41 slogan he has lived this past year. He has if he was ever uninvolved in the violence and the punishment of dissent, now come out boldly to endorse it.

So it is that we now meet the ODM's mischevious claim of ethnic cleansing against the government, which move it is promoting at the International Criminal Court.  Again the ODM side are told that the state is out to finish them, thus ensuring that they come out again now ready to fight, the already selected enemy, to the death. Paying absolutely no attention to the reports from the Rift Valley, and with a media and civil society missing in action, the ODM Secretary General declares that the State action in Kisumu (which incidentally many local business owners are calling delayed and not firm enough) was both premeditated and designed to kill as many as possible.  And Anyang' Nyong'o is not without inspiration, in his only comment on the Rift Valley attacks to date, the ODM leader Raila Odinga attempted to justify them first by constructing a narrative in which these attacks were a revenge mission, and then declaring that the perpetrators were unaware that those they chasing after had hidden themselves among women and children. So again, we find an endorement of the violence, except perhaps Kikuyu women ought perhaps to be grateful that they are deemed unworthy of the sword and the flame, destiny's which must now be the left, by the process of elimination to the males of the GEMA and Akamba people.

The Langata MP as I said is famous for his organisational aptitude, and his violent ways, but he is also famous for putting his foot into his mouth. In the same week that it finally dawned on even the most stubborn that the Rift Valley massacres were premeditated, planned and disciplined, his endorsement in Kisumu will make the case for his innocence so much harder to prove.

Peter Ndiangui
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (27)add
0
...
written by Kamale , January 23, 2008
Peter,

Your pain is understandable under the circumstances. I think Kenyans need to start thinking beyond the politicians and we must now start preaching a one Kenya amongst Kenyans since the politicians seem bent to have us kill one another. We need to reach out the other individual whom the politician does not want us to talk to.

Frankly, the stories I hear of revenge gall me, and I keep thinking that the tit for tat we see will only hurt and eliminate the poor!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Let the truth be told
written by JV Ogot , January 23, 2008
One must be terribly ignorant to have to be brainwashed into fearing Raila Odinga. No, wait, one has to be incredibly foolish not to fear Raila Odinga.

It is easy for ODM people to try to force other people to back Raila by claiming that there is a campaign out there to bedevil him, but the truth as you have said must be told.

I am a Luo and I can tell you that there are few if any politicians in this country who have as much blood on their hands as Raila Odinga. You refuse to see it if you must, some of us my brother have actually lived it. Ignorance, I see is a human right.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
ARE LUO\'S RAILA EXPERTS
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
This is the most shocking arguement.

God save Kenya
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: The constitution and a re-
written by Wuod Aketch , January 23, 2008
Agreed , we can get the two at the end of these crises; a new constitution and re-run of the polls.

It is now getting to three weeks since we have been trying to hammer this into your thick skulls without much success. So you finally accept? What a waste of time for those 250k refugees. Had you accepted this earlier, those refugees would be back now in their homes harvesting their shambas.
We will not accept the rerun if it is in 2012!!!. A re-run now.


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
CATHOLIC CHURCH OR KAG
written by Truth Be Told , January 23, 2008
It does not matter

The only thing to fear is fear itself.

The people who set the church on fire must be punished the same way the policeman who killed the unarmed protester in Kisumu must be punished

Point to ponder:

This is not time to talk about re-runs of elections.At the risk of annoying many people what we need is to reform all the institutions which allowed the elections to be stolen and they were indeed stolen.

Firstly they will be stolen again and secondly their will so much violence what ever we are seeing now will seem like child play .

We need justice and healing
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , January 23, 2008
Kevin,

kibaki has been to Rify Valley, where hundreds of his supporters have been killed. He very clearly asked them to forgive their neighbours and not to revenge, but let the law handle the situation. There were no hints, ommissions or anything hiddeb in his speech to suggest that attacking a particular community was okay.

He did not line up coffins, potray emotional scenes, tolerate calls for arming, call for selective need to violence, insist that a struggle must continue, etc.

You claim that we read between Raila lines, but that is because Raila says and behaves as such. You cannot on one hand claim to call for peace, and in the same sentence attempt to make the burning of women and children in a church appear reasonable.

You cannot call a prayer meeting, display coffins, display a show of emotion thus fueling the crowds anger, call for selective end to violence, then claim you are for peace, without leaving a lot to read between the lines.

You claim that Kibaki has not done his part asking for peace.....do you think Kibaki going to Nyanza to call for peace will cause peace or more chaos?

For the 2 weeks that kisumu was burning before the kisumu "prayer" meeting, Raila did not once to there to call for peace. When he shows up, it is to whip up emotions.

Raila has made it pretty clear that he is happy with the chaos.......he will not anaestise the people while they are being raped by calling for calm.....remember those words.

That is why we don't believe him and read between the lines
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Peace
written by Michael , January 23, 2008
Raila knows exactly what he is doing. In a very calculated manner, he preys upon the ignorance of some people with the clear objective of promoting ethno-fascism. His behavior is utterly shameless.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , January 23, 2008
If Kibaki is such a saint or as honourable as you would like us to believe (instead of insisting that he has won and hanging onto power by force) he would have immediately after the chaos broke out asked for a recount and investigation of the irregularities. He didnt.

He would have delayed his swearing in to allow for the legal 3 days allowed for recount. Instead he was hurriedly sworn in a manner suggesting that he was running away from something.

When doubts persisited, poll observers questioned the tallying, he did not move to reassure Kenyans that the tallying was authentic, all we heard was go to court. Of course he knows what kind of pedestrian rulings Kenyan courts have given on elections in the past. The case against Moi could not even take off because he was not personally served. Where will ODM get Kibaki so that they can personally serve? Let's be honest Kibaki knows that the route to court is already rigged in the incumbent's favor.

An honourable man would have resigned when his continued stay in power led to the death of so many. Not Kibaki. Instead his response has been to issue shoot to kill orders. Police are even shooting from moving trains at Children in Kibera. Is it a wonder then that Kibera people uprooted the rail to prevent the death train from reaching them.

While you can make all sorts of arguements in an attempt to link Raila(and other ODM leaders) to the violence. The best, you can get is substantial evidence. To my knowldege, there is no evidence that Raila told people to kill anyone. If the government has evidence to the contrary why not just arrest Raila and take him to court. Use the evidence against him. The fact that the government is not using the court to seek redress tells you something. Doesnt it?

On the other hand Kibaki is directly responsible for his ministers who have issues shoot to kill orders. The responsibility is direct. No need to beat about the bush on who is responsible for police killings.

Clearly Raila's statement can be interpreted in many ways including what you state here. However , I believe, the Rift Valley violence has absolutely nothing to do with Raila or the election. The election rigging is just what ignited what already existed. To try blame Raila for this is really stretching it too far.

I dont know if the catholic priest's explanation is authentic. It just doesnt make sense. No one should burn church or any place of worship. Human life should be respected, no one should be killed for any reason. But it is illogical for Kikuyu combatants to run into church and risk the lives of none combatants taking refuge there. I dont buy the explantion.

On the issue of land, the problem in Rift Valley is outside the jurisdiction of court. What do you anticipate the case to be about? This issue can only be solved politically. The Kikuyu/Maasai/Kalenjin and Kisiis must seek a lasting solution to this problem through a negotiated agreement.

On Raila's statement about Kisii's: View this from the context of where he was. He was in Nyanza and had to ask the Luo to live peacefully with their neighbours, the Kisii. It was important that the Kisii issue was addressed while speaking to the Luo. Dont take it out of context.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Peace
written by Ole Ntimu , January 23, 2008
(Insults deleted. Ed.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Mogoka shtim , January 23, 2008
"Peter.
You wrote this article here because this is an anti Raila site"

Hmmm, tempted to call it a stretch but most of the articles prove otherwise.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
On Democracy
written by politicalscientist , January 24, 2008
I'm writing an essay on Kenya at the moment and in the process of reading up on this I found this quote and I thought it really poignant and particularly relevant. Love to hear our thoughts.

"smilies/grin.gifemocracy is a process that institutionalises fair, general rules that risk a loss of power. If a government , after an initial breakthrough resorts to force or fraud and does not play by the new democratic rules...then at the popular level, the power holders will seem illegitimate and a violent anti-democratic opposition can seem legitimate" (Edward Freidman, Democratisation:Generalising the East Asian Experience, 1994, p 22)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Pointers of Raila perpetrated
written by pndiangui , January 24, 2008
Have we addressed the pre-election hatred statements like 'Adui' that Raila very well used to spur the anti-Gikuyu sentiments in Rift Valley and other parts of the country?

We very know Raila's character of playing victim against his very much preditermined victims. We have seen him make claims of corruption while very knows he breaths and lives the same. We have seen him claim of merceneries while it is clear the Texeira's of this world are in the business of merceneries just as the Ammenians.

My concern is not that Kibaki is saint - very far from it , infact the chaos in the country have as much to do with his laxity and poor leadership as they are about ODMers.
My concern is the messeiah's holier than though claims ,preying on the ignorance of many Kenyans whilst behaving out of the very same things he speaks against.

Before these elections as I took a stand politically , I wrote an article here that almost summarised Raila's rhetorism; http://www.kenyaimagine.com/in...ew&id=803
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Daniel.Waweru , January 24, 2008
"While you can make all sorts of arguements in an attempt to link Raila(and other ODM leaders) to the violence. The best, you can get is substantial [circumstantial?] evidence. To my knowldege, there is no evidence that Raila told people to kill anyone."

Examples like this illustrate the depths of jaundice to which people - some on both sides - have descended. FACT: What Raila has not done is be a statesman, putting Kenyans first and incessantly calling for peace.

OPINION: Raila is an actor on a stage. Raila is not an ethno-fascist. He incites them for his own personal gain.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Human Rights Watch Report
written by Tim Norwood , January 24, 2008
(Eldoret, January 24, 2008 ) – Human Rights Watch investigations indicate that, after Kenya’s disputed elections, opposition party officials and local elders planned and organized ethnic-based violence in the Rift Valley, Human Rights Watch said today. The attacks, targeting mostly Kikuyu and Kisii people in and around the town of Eldoret, could continue unless the government and opposition act to stop the violence, Human Rights Watch said.


Link here
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by aeichener , January 24, 2008
Possible this would well be.
But are we willing to accept the cost?
Do we as a nation value innocent lives high enough, to pay a collective price for their protection?

See my view here
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , January 24, 2008
Ndirangu and Waweru: Your views are one sided. There is no doubt that in the run up to the election, the ODM side whipped up emotion that bordered on creating anti Kikuyu feelings. What you choose to ignore is that PNU side is equally guilty in whipping up emotion against the Luo. This explains why each time Kikuyu retaliate, they do so against the Luo. In their minds the Luo are the enimies.
Your article is unbalanced and aimed at painting Odinga as the only culprit. This is distortion. Mount Kenya leaders are as guilty as Odinga and Ruto can be judged to be. What could be the aim of such imbalanced article other than to incite. You cant correct a flawed article through comment referring to an earlier article.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re:
written by Watetu , January 24, 2008

An honourable man would have resigned when his continued stay in power led to the death of so many.....If the government has evidence to the contrary why not just arrest Raila and take him to court. Use the evidence against him. The fact that the government is not using the court to seek redress tells you something. Doesnt it?


Your comments seem well intentioned but are thoroughly misguided. Kibaki stepping down for Raila in the wake of post election violence would have sent out the message if you're unhappy with election results, all you have to do is sacrifice enough Kenyans and hey presto your ambition is fulfilled.

As for arresting Raila, whether or not the Government has enough evidence against him, his arrest at present would only exacerbate the violence in Kenya.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
another tribalist called New D
written by New Day , January 28, 2008
Ndiangui,

I do not know if KenyaImagine pays you to write these articles (...)
(...)
(No, were are not. Though his good articles would certainly deserve remuneration, as much as vile and uncouth tribalists as you would deserve to be banned. Eds.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Only Government could control
written by New Day , January 28, 2008
(Tribalism deleted and empty propaganda erased. Eds.)
It is a president's duty to use state resources for the benefits of the people. Raila has none of these (...) It is Kibaki who can deploy forces to control citizens. By alleging that Raila is inciting people to destroy property and kill, then you must first explain where he is getting the authority to do that (...)
Back to the issue: WHat role does a government play in any national situation? A government that buries its head in the sand (or is busy printing full pages of tribal bickering in the newspapers) loses control when people start killing each other. It is quick to deploy police to shoot people in its enemy territory but is suddenly lacklustre when areas where it knows that people from the president's community reside, suddenly it only watches.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
za Kitale?
written by Stephen Wanyama , January 28, 2008
(Responses to an ogre shortened. Ed.)
NewDay, (...)
Already you have decided that Ndiangui is a tribalist, on what account exactly is lost on the many. Raila made what anyone with any decency will acknowledge was a grand faux pas in Kisumu, in fact he is the only politician anywhere in this mess who has come out to actually endorse violence, if indirectly. I mean we suspect Ruto, we suspect Kones, we can suspect anyone, but in the Kisumu speech Ndiangui writes about, Raila is the only one who has actually come out to actively separate the sheep from the goats, endorsing the 'touching' of some communities on account of their voting.

Now it is very easy to say everyone is blameworthy, but on this count alone, Raila is more blameworthy than most. Remember this is coming in a period of unrest, so he is augmenting his 41-1 strategy, affirming it (I am sure from your comments that you need no persuasion).

As to whether Kibaki can crackdown on the Rift Valley folks, we have seen quite clearly that being in government does curse you more than a bit. If Kibaki came out to quell the RVP marauders, then he would surely make it uninhabitable by Kikuyus for a long time yet.

The real problem, one which all the bigots are refusing to see, including the international media, is the fact that the ODM ran a campaign of hatred and ethnic cleansing. The 41 against 1 and Majimbo are the causes of this violence. As we speak Teso and Sabaot are fighting, Luhyas are being kicked out of the Rift Valley, Sally Kosgei is having to plead with Nandi people in Aldai not to attack Luhyas. Can you NewDay not open your eyes and see?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
The constitution and a re-run
written by pndiangui , January 28, 2008
Agreed , we can get the two at the end of these crises; a new constitution and re-run of the polls.

However let me remind you of Raila's comments in the BBC interview;
here is the statement Raila made in BBC:

A very powerful point indeed and we ourselves have issued a statement condemning the incident that took place in a church in Eldoret, but what are the fact? The catholic father who is in charge has given the explanation in that these people who were attacking members of other communities were being chased and when they were being chased. they went to take refuge in a church and the pursuers then pursued them into the church. They did not know that in the church there were children which were being kept as refugees. So in the process of course they set the church on fire. I am not saying the action was defensible at all......

Link here

In the first place does Raila know this was an assemblies church of God and not a catholic church ?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by D , January 28, 2008
Ah. The blame game. People in this forum are suffering from the same disease that has plagued our leaders. It must be infectious. A lot of time and energy goes into blaming others. While you do so, a house full of women and children in Naivasha was burnt down.

The government has taken out ads in the newspaper blaming everyone and their mother for the violence. The money and energy spent on taking out that ad in the Nation could have been used toward helping the displaced. While they do so, a woman gets hacked to death in Nakuru.

The opposition has held press conference after press conference saying they have been cheated. While they do so, children are evicted from some area school in Nyanza by mobs shouting "No Raila, No School."

Blaming only takes you so far. Blaming never ensures justice. It does not ensure security. Are the mobs in Nakuru watching KTN or reading the internet? No. Even if they were, they would not listen. And this is the problem. This is no longer about PNU or ODM. Or Emilio or Angwambo. No amount of media campaigns and empty talk by politicians who cannot lead will stop the violence.

I wonder who will be man enough to step up to the plate and stope blaming and start making sacrifices. Is the power of the presidency so sweet that we will allow parts of the country to plummet?
The fight for democracy can never done through undemocratic channels. It is getting expensive with 800 people dead and about 500,000 displaced. Or are these just numbers? Are these people dispensable? CHILDREN HAVE DIED. Why? They have done nothing but somehow have been forced to pay. At what point do Kenyans begin to stand up for other Kenyans and not just for those from their own community or party affiliation? Do we need more people to die? Is 800 not enough? How about 5,000!!???? Is that what it will take for people to stop blaming each other and start looking into the eyes of the innocents that have been chased, raped and evicted? Or mabe 10,000 dead is a better number to stop this BLATANT RACISM in Kenya. I wish someone would give me the number that will not only push our leaders to act but for Kenyans to stop this!

God bless Kenya.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Truth Be Told , January 28, 2008
(Edited)
Since our leaders have failed to lead us we should lead them.

Kindly know that our leaders use ethnic mobilisation because it is cheaper than articulating policies.

To stop us from looking at them critically they antagonize different tribes to stop us from looking at their looting.

It is easier to brainwash the Kikuyu in Mathare into hating the Luo rather than to ask him to question the immense wealth of the Kenyatta family.

Conversly it is easier for the Luo to be brainwashed into Kikuyu Phobia than for the Luo of Kibera to be helped to break out of the yoke of poverty.

Let us change this constitution.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kibaki - main problem
written by Wuod Aketch , January 28, 2008
Well said Dr Vincent Magombe - the main problem is Mwai Kibaki.

See news here:

Kenya - 28 Jan - United Kingdom BBC News : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XluLYcwTXHI
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: re:
written by Cindy , January 28, 2008
Watetu,

The same applies to Kibaki. His staying in power even with strong indicators that the elections were rigged, with the EU observers believing the same. First World governments have refused to endorse the presidency.
...(Silly blame game deleted, Ed.)...
During Moi's regime, rigging was rife but intelligently carried out. But what we witnessed last month was daylight robbery.

Cindy
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Kibaki - main problem
written by aeichener , January 28, 2008
Well said Dr Vincent Magombe - the main problem is Mwai Kibaki.

See news here:

Kenya - 28 Jan - United Kingdom BBC News : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XluLYcwTXHI

This Vincent Magombe, though being an Ugandan, is appearing so Kenyan: A paid tribalist posing as a "political analyst".

There are people slaughtering with pangas (like the young men shown in the BBC clip, now Kikuyus, after it had been Kalenjin and Jaluo before), and there are people slaughtering with words (like Magombe), but both are criminals.

Shoot both, and restore order. And after that, embark on the long and arduous road to peace.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: re: Kibaki - main problem
written by Wuod Aketch , January 28, 2008
Well said Dr Vincent Magombe - the main problem is Mwai Kibaki.

See news here:

Kenya - 28 Jan - United Kingdom BBC News : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XluLYcwTXHI


This Vincent Magombe, though being an Ugandan, is appearing so Kenyan: A paid tribalist posing as a "political analyst".

There are people slaughtering with pangas (like the young men shown in the BBC clip, now Kikuyus, after it had been Kalenjin and Jaluo before), and there are people slaughtering with words (like Magombe), but both are criminals.

Shoot both, and restore order. And after that, embark on the long and arduous road to peace.

Alexander


(...) Entirely gratuitous credentialism deleted. Also, entirely gratuitous use of French deleted. Don't show off. And especially not when you're posting content-free insults. Eds.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 23 January 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company