Should Wangari Muta Maathai be the next president of Kenya? PDF Print E-mail
Written by Dave Nyambati   
Thursday, 08 February 2007

A few day ago we went to listen to Wangari Maathai speak at St. Cloud State University in St. Cloud, Minnesota.

I must admit before I went there I had preconceived notions of who Wangari Maathai was. I remember in the late 80s and early 90s seeing Maathai's picture in the paper and thinking who is this eccentric tree-hugger who would die to save a tree? Many politicians and news people, including President Moi, considered her insane and had no qualms about saying this openly, but as Elizabeth Browning said "Since when was genius found respectable?".

 

There may be a method to her madness after all. Maathai’s initial inclination was not towards politics, but toward community development. In the 1970s she became the first woman in East Africa to earn a Ph.D and then became Dean of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Nairobi.  She also started the Green Belt Movement (GBM) which was an NGO aimed at tackling environmental issues from a grassroots level. In the beginning she focused on educating women in rural areas on the benefits of environmental conservation – especially regarding the arable and pastoral communities these women came from. They would have regular meetings to discuss new and better ways to combat deforestation and soil erosion and carry out tree planting exercises. The GMB turned decisively pro-democracy when Moi's government banned unlicensed meetings of more than 9 people. They then started fighting for open governance, inclusive of human rights and the rule of law as well as the environmental conservation.

 

Maathai’s most high profile fights were against the Uhuru Park Skyscraper and the plan to giving portions of Karura Forest to private developers that pitted her squarely against the Moi government at great risk to her person. She was jailed several times and physically injured like the time she wound up in hospital when at Karura hired thugs pounced on her.

She got some vindication for her blood and sweat when she was nominated and won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2004. The Nobel Prize is the most prestigious of awards any intellectual can hope to receive today and I have always respected Maathai for getting one. I know the Nobel Committee is a very deliberative body and the nomination and selection process is long and rigorous, but I had not been completely convinced as to why a tree-planter deserved the Nobel Peace Prize. (Her acceptance speech here.) That is until I took a deeper look at Professor Maathai and her work.

Maathai’s political philosophy revolves around the idea of valuing life in all its forms above everything else on earth and rethinking the concept of security to include sustainable management of resources to protect and sustain this life. In her speech she urged that we have to challenge our consciousness on the need to appreciate all life saying there cannot be peace if there are violations of life. If we degrade the resources that sustain our lives then peace and welfare will be threatened. She said the scramble for recourses was characteristic of all small and large armed conflicts and that resources have to be shared equitably through a democratic system of governance to extend global peace.

 

In her view the primary function of government should be to manage common resources needed for life. These resources belong to every citizen including future generations.

This attitude and approach would go a long way towards solving some of Kenya’s most complex issues. It is easy to see how her philosophy could address issues from land reform and the environment to corruption and poverty. I’m not suggesting she would fix any of these problems single handedly, but changing the attitudes of our politicians has to be the first step towards the Kenya we want.

 

Her “strong-mindedness” and defiance towards the powers that be have left her isolated from the Kenyan political mainstream, which is a good thing considering the political climate in parliament where politicians are quick to point at the twigs in each other’s eyes. She has no real political allies because she is generally considered rogue and untetherable. Is this not what a lot of Kenyans have been looking for? A politician who is not part of the system, old or new, imagine that!

 

She sites the large amount of propaganda and disinformation generated by our politicians as a problem,but calls for personal responsibility saying everybody who is pointing fingers at the government should also realize that in some way they may also be part of the problem. This reminds me of a time when I was driving with a friend of mine outside Nairobi and got pulled over for speeding. My friend quickly offered the policeman 100 shilling which he took and let us go. My friend then went on a 30 minute tirade of how corrupt Kenyan police were, without missing a beat! What we choose to do as individuals is ultimately more important than what the central government does. Look at what Maathai almost single handedly did for the Kenyan environment (and even the world now), it started with a single personal choice to take a stand for what she believed.

 

I doubt many people could credibly challenge her commitment to Kenya. On winning the Nobel Prize, she was offered many speaking opportunities at foreign institutions which would have made her a lot of money, instead she chose to first focus on serving her constituents. She judges speaking offers equally be they from Nyalgunga Primary School or Harvard. She may have possibly given more blood for Kenya than any current elected official in Parliament. She deserve a second look.

 

“It took 10 years to convince the opposition to unite against the government, in the new elections we should try to see if we can do better than before.” Wangari Maathai





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (20)add
0
Tree Hu*ger to Politician?
written by Kamale , February 08, 2007
Wangari Maathai is perhaps more suited on community and social issues that the rigours of Kenyan politics.

As a politician, she has added little to bring any sanity to the confused kenyan political scene, and not even her refusal to take up a junior ministerial position helped her. Many asked if Wangari should have been made the minister for trees following her nobel prize, and I held the view that she actually would have served the environment better outside of politics and government.

Wangari is needed by the world more than Kenyans need her politically. She can change the world - but not as president of Kenya!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Is tree-hu*ger not a slur?
written by a guest , February 08, 2007
I am not sure Wangari Maathai was ever political material, her opposition to the Moi government was purely on the grounds of its encroachment on green land, not about democracy and such.

Clearly, the principled position she has taken, even if limited in its effect sets a precedent for future Kenyan politicians. She is obvioulsy limited by the fact that she enjoys no true alliances in Parliament or in the Kenyan civil service, but I believe that she would have already made a big difference if she had any political nous at all.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
top 2 articles on environment
written by Tim Norwood , February 08, 2007
Coincidence or is this the top issue of our time?

I do not agree that the Nobel Prizes are particularly prestigious, especially given the fact that it involves a lot of political and tactical influences. Wangari Maathai certainly enjoys a much bigger national profile than she ever did, and the effect of the GreenBelt Movement, especially outside Central Kenya is quite limited. More power to her though, Climate Change and environmental politics may leave the top page of kenyaimagine? but they will be key issues in the destiny of mankind forever more.

Kamale,
Are we saying then that good people do not belong in politcs?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
disturbed
written by Dave Nyambati , February 08, 2007
That's the same sentiment I had held, before taking a closer look. Why do you say she is not suited for Kenyan politics.

She was elected as the first president of the Economic, Social and Cultural Council which is an advisory body to the AU on development in Africa (and has been runing it since 2005) - so it can't be that she lacks the skill to be the chief executive.

She is not part of the past or current corrupt politics like the current aspirants - so it can't be that she is tainted!

Her number one interest is in the preservation of life and how to improve it while conserving resources. How is this not what we need.

No one can question her love for her country and her dedication to it.

Her refusal to take the oath for the assistant minister position did not help her (was it supposed to?) but it was a stand on principle. She did not want to be part of the Kibaki government which she recognized as faulted.

True she did not set out to be in politics but in this case necessity was the mother of re-invention.

Where does she fall short...I can't see it. Can someone please help me out?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Brilliant !
written by aeichener , February 08, 2007
I wish that articles of this quality, this depth and this good English would appear in Kenyan papers. Well, never mind. We now set the standards for others to follow... :D Thanks, Dave!

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
I like Wangari Maathai but..
written by Chameleon , February 08, 2007
I doubt if she can handle Kenya's tribal, violent and hate based politics without compromising her middle of the road way of doing things. I really doubt if she can make any hard decisions.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Middle of the politics
written by Nekessa , February 08, 2007
But Chameleon, this is what we need.. we need someone who is not part of the dirty political game that is Kenya.

@ Anon-- Even though, Maathai began her journey as an environmentalist/biologist (she was carrying out tests on water, when she noticed massive soil erosion), she has continued to maintain that a sustained environment results in upholding equity as it calls for equal distribution of resources thus democracy. So she does fight for democracy.
Read Mshale's African Woman Extraordinare

Other Nobel Laureate, Muhammad Yunnus, might also join politics in Bangladesh .
"if the people and civil society want." Terming the present situation 'new' one, Yunus said this is the high time "to start politics from a new angle," The Daily Star newspaper said.

The 'new' situation he referred to is the cancellation of the contentious general elections last month and the presence of a caretaker government that has applied curbs on political activity, but is also conducting a drive against corruption.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
politricks
written by Amir Ibrahim , February 08, 2007

Wangari Maathai certainly enjoys a much bigger national profile than she ever did, and the effect of the GreenBelt Movement, especially outside Central Kenya is quite limited.


It is this and not any goodness that afflicts Professor Maathai's political chances. Her impact on our national consciousness has not been great enough for her to have any influence on Kenya, whether in government or outside it.

This is not just because she was hardly involved in politics, but also because there is much more than goodness or intellect that voters around the world seek from Chief Executives -compare the smilar if less pronounced significance of Chinua Achebe or Desmond Tutu or even Jimmy Carter.

If we were to go down the India route however, where a nuclear scientist is head of state but not government, she would be of great use to the country and our development.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
She cannot be president
written by Haron , February 09, 2007
There is no way that I will support her as president.Kenyans are very rude and corrupt and there is no way a women can handle them.Kenyans need Osama or saddam like president.I was in Kenya from December and I can tell you that diplomacy cannot work in Kenya for now.They are extremely rude even to red lights.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by kenyaonly , February 09, 2007
Amir Ibrahim i disagree with you on the point that Wangare Mathai was actively involves in politics when Kenya was hot she was among the first people to publicly declare they were in FORD movement. So she has actively been involved in politics to an extent of Police bulldozing the doors of her house so that they can arrest her back in the 90's...But is she ready for presidency? NO will she ever be ready? NO as Haron has said Kenya needs someone more aggressive, but not raila type, someone who can take criticism and still keep their head up.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Wangari has what it takes
written by pndiangui , February 09, 2007
I couldnt see why Wangari doesnt have what it would take to turn Kenya around.
The critical thing which I think leadership in Kenya is lacking is one that inspires Trust, is honest and humble but still can take tough decisions which might even make him/her unpopular with the masses but deep down and in the long-term it will benefit the masses. This what I think Wangari represents.
I have seen her put her thoughts into actions like never before , sometimes even becoming unpopular in her own constituency.
Amir if she hasnt had any impacts in our National consciousness its because we are an ignorant rot. Thats why she has had a global impact but not a national impact. She's one of those locally unsung heros.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
not true
written by Dave Nyambati , February 09, 2007
Chameleon – Wangari is not a middle of the road politician. She does not compromise on the things that she believes. If she did, she may have settled for a smaller building at Uhuru Park or a smaller section of Karura being given to private developers – but she stood her ground and paid dearly too, but ultimately achieved her goal. She will stand up to other politicians uncompromisingly for the things that she believes.

Most of the arguments against her here are of the consensus that she is not tough enough to handle the presidency and that Kenyan politics is too brutal for her. Really? What exactly is it that she cannot handle? What about Ngilu, or is Ngilu judged the same, and is it because they are women? She is an MP and head of her own party – she openly stood up against Moi solo back when people disappeared just for whispering anything anti-government. Her husband, a former MP divorced her saying she is too strong minded for a woman – he could not control her. She is tougher than a lot of the MPs in parliament right now. I do not see how anyone can say she is not tough enough!

The only real obstacle she faces is the Kenyan people.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Kamale , February 09, 2007
After reading her book, I became more and more convinced that her attraction to politics was to make a statement against Moi rather than progress her environmental causes. For instance her attempt as a presidential candidate and the explanation she gave had me seriously questioning her political wisdom.

David,

Was her standing up for Karura or Uhuru Park a political or environmental statement? A very thin line you might say, but I am convinced that she was striking a blow of the environment rather than be another Moi oppositionist!

As I said earlier, the world needs Wangari more than Kenya needs her.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Doris Sadera , February 09, 2007
She is a very educated woman who has done a lot for Kenya, but she would not make a good president. First of all, Kenya is years away from taking a female presidential candidate seriously - let alone one with her reputation. Why waste time on someone who is unelectable?

If anything, I think Ngilu would make a much better candidate, and she has a good reputation too! At least people would consider her more seriously!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , February 09, 2007
Ngilu has shown that she cares about Kenyans, Wangari, that she cares about trees.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Maathai
written by Chameleon , February 09, 2007
Maybe Wangari maathai can be a good president but her well intentioned plans can be useless if she does not have a good team supporting her in parliament, police, judiciary or even the media.

We all remember some time back when our own parliament blocked well intentioned ideas just because they were proposed by the Kibaki goverment.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Honey , February 10, 2007
I concur Mr. Wanyama. Ngilu is better placed in dealing with Kenyans. Wangari is a scholar, not a leader.
I expected her pet -'green belt'- to bloom and inflame all regions of Kenya, but it remains unknown outside Central. She is not using that podium (Nobel) so well, is she?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
All the way
written by dalani , February 14, 2007
The title says it all. She should also hook up with Liberia's female president and other rulers around Kenya and preside the African Union. Not only that, she should with the AU's help, institutionlize the GBM into a para government agency and form a comprehensive African wide environmental policy.

She should form the African Space Program designed specifically for tackling the Saharan desert front with concerted terraforming brigades to push back the desert and create new economicaly viable land.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
but whats a leader?
written by pndiangui , February 14, 2007
Honey you say Wangari is not a leader.
What is a leader.
The conceptioning and leading GBM to me is far more showing leadership than the Ngilu 'tosha' brought by Anyang Nyong in the hey days of SDP as a strategy to woe women voters.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Ngilu
written by Honey , February 16, 2007
Please, update me on GBM, ni nini?

I find Ngilu's down to earth persona appealing, and resonating with the common man. She is not exposed as Wangari, but has taken her path and stood well as amother, leader, wife and good woman.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 08 February 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company