Ideally, we should be halfway towards redemption. Raila was
largely seen, even by his enemies, as a reform-committed, energetic,
straight-shooting, sincere politician. As a result, most people decided that he
was what he said he was - the bridge between our nasty past and a just and
prosperous Kenya.
So we took him at face value and mounted him, posthaste, upon a high pedestal.
But our elevation was cut short, so he got halfway up the
pedestal, there to hang inelegantly in the spirit of 'nusu mkate'. And he
seems vertiginious all the time, as though our expectations of him are
extremely and unreasonably onerous. He is falling back more and more on the
'nusu mkate' argument than he is on his avowed commitment to ' transformation'
and so forth.
What has happened?
Two things have happened.
One, he is getting inured to the alternative reality of
power and privilege as instruments of exclusion and limited good.
Two, he is discovering that being of limited good, and being
exclusive, it is an obvious imperative of power and privilege to cut off the
people to whom one made unrealistic commitments whilst outside. Unrealistic in
the sense that such commitments are opposed to the alternative reality, see
above.
So has Raila betrayed us?
It would be easy to say that, but it might not be right,
ultimately. Betrayal implies a reneging on a legitimate commitment. It is
legitimate if both the promissor and the promisee are entitled to make and
extract the commitments in question.
We would be entitled to claim that Raila had
betrayed us is if we could demonstrate that we were collectively suited to the
commitments. And we cannot do so if we do not possess the rigorous vigilance,
fidelity to due process and commitment to democratic give and take that are necessary to
hold leaders accountable for their commitments. If Raila has betrayed the
cause, and that is arguable, very few of us have the capacity to hold him to
his word. That barely lets him off the hook and leaves us wholly disenchanted.
I have come to the conclusion that we are not rigorous in
holding Government and leadership - such as there is - responsible and
accountable. We do not ask for more, for better, for an improvement, for a step
forward. We become irritable to threats upon the status quo. We seek a form of
change that does not require our moral responsibility. We want to
wholly delegate to the said leaders, instead of micromanaging their sorry
behinds as democracy requires.
That is why Kenya
is officially a dumping ground. Of dangerous and obsolete ordnance left over
from the Cold War, of defective products from all over the world, of shaky
'professionals' and' 'expatriates' whose only claim to distinction is their
complexion, of ideas and ideologies that have fallen on 'the wrong side of
history' as cuz Barry would say, of sad, unwashed leadership, of...
I hate it when Raila's family is mentioned in connection
with scandals. Perhaps it can be argued that in a free country, every Kenyan is
entitled to choose which scandal to wallow in. It demonstrates, however, how quickly we accustom ourselves to failure, how easily we tolerate lapses, regression and
mediocrity, and how accepting we are of betrayal and disillusionment as both
logical and axiomatic. There is every reason to believe that the mention of
Raila's name, and of his associates' and relations' is mischievous and
mistaken. That is beside the point. The point is that because we do
not hold our public servant to any standard of conduct and ethics we actually
expect the ruling families to behave badly.
We expect our leaders to be highly
conspicuous in their consumption. That is why a newspaper recently went ga-ga
reporting how simply scandalous it was that Prof Kivutha Kibwana enjoyed
chicken and chips at an airport cafe! We expect our leaders to steal. We expect
our politicians to get into all manner of sickness as long as they entertain us
on TV. And it has spread. We expect Asian tycoons to
treat workers poorly, to flout safety regulations, to steal public money and to
treat other Kenyans as part of the wildlife.
And we expect to die in road accidents, to be mutilated and
murdered by surgeons while helplessly under anaesthesia, we expect matatu
drivers to become lawless tyrants on our roads. We expect our managers, MDs,
PSs to appoint and favour their tribesmen and girlfriends.
We actually expect Kenya to become a failed state.
In that regard, we have devised two pernicious and
fallacious reasons not to do anything.
The first is that we are to poor to afford decency. Good
manners are simply beyond our means. We are a third world country. We do not have
mineral wealth. We are too prone to the vagaries of global economic upheavals.
Thus, we cannot pay teachers well, we can neither build new, nor equip existing
schools, dispensaries and even government departments. We cannot computerise
the Companies , Lands and Court registries. We cannot fund research and our
scholars must beg for scholarships from western vested interests. We cannot fix
our roads, provide farmers with extension services, employ new teachers,
nurses, clerks, drivers, build and equip our referrral hospitals, cannot
assist fishermen, hawkers, orphans, pastoralists, every other wretched person
to see a half-decent way of life.
The second reason is the constitution. It concentrates too
much power on the presidency. It does not provide for parliamentary autonomy.
It does not give 'teeth' to the Electoral Commission, though it certainly
gives it a vast gut. It renders the provincial administration and civil service
prone to political interference. It hampers the independence of the judiciary.
It puts the fate of Kenyans in the hands of one person. It facilitates abuse of
office, land grabbing, Anglo-Leasing type transactions, siphoning of public
funds. It requires Kenyans at all levels of government to be ill-mannered. It
is harmful to the unborn child.
On account of these reasons, we need to build a mansion for
the vice president, speaker, prime minister, clerk to parliament, although we
are too poor to give teachers a measly increment. We need to rationalise civil
servants' emoluments to become competitive and protect them from being lured to
the private sector. We need to pay for politicians' junkets to gallivant all
over Europe and America,
while poor people are imprisoned in hospitals because they cannot afford
treatment. We need to enhance every bigshot's bodyguard whilst robbers are
killing children in our slums. And so and so on. The government's train
of non-sequiturs huffs and puffs along the downhill track to oblivion.
But not to lose hope, for a new constitution is coming. It
will be pure magic. It will prevent politicians' minds from conceiving corrupt
and treacherous thoughts, it will prevent thieves from stealing, landgrabbers
from landgrabbing, brokers from broking, ghost workers from ghost working,
women from conceiving misbegotten reprobates and men from siring them. It will guarantee enhanced rights for every citizen. It
will make those rights affordable. It will enable the children of watchmen to
go to Saint Mary's and Lenana. It will bring a Prado to every household. It
will raise the dead.
We will be raised, incorruptible. We shall be transformed.
For those two reasons, understand if your government wholly
devotes itself to doing nothing. Appreciate that meanwhile, swindlers and
other sad types must steal in the absence of a good constitution. Kibaki may
reappoint Kimunya because the present constitution required the opaque sale of
prime taxpayers' property and makes it hard to fire incompetent and corrupt
officials. The warrants against Devani had to be lifted; without a new
constitution, KCB, KPC and other initials must lose their money.
So we are recruited into a new conspiracy of inaction. Of
lack of curiosity. Of want of vigilance. Of the extermination of 'why?'.
And mutual lament.
____________________________
Eric Ng'eno
About the author:
Eric Ng'eno is a Nairobi-based advocate who writes passionately about Kenya.
odd that you believed written by trrr , February 02, 2009
It is strange that you choose to totally ignore Raila's career of corruption, repression and poor leadership prior to the 2007 election and choose to gently focus on his post-2008 failings.
The man has built a fortune, both politically and financially off of deceiving people.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
... written by mkosakabila , February 03, 2009
Might this work well as two separate articles? The first part of which I would care very little, the second, a rather apt synopsis of our twisted psyche.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
On Raila in Davos written by Ndiang'ui , February 03, 2009
I really never wanted to put it like this. But watching Raila at Davos confirmed to me what a grave mistake befell us....oh but it did not just happen...we worshipped the man , the messiar , the saviour ....all what made us 'fight' to have him in some form of Power.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
... written by ... , February 04, 2009
I am not entirely sure about the justification of the comprehensive "we" that Ndiang'ui uses. KenyaImagine authors have quite early warned about Raila; not out of any vile tribal feelings (several of the critics came from Lakeside even), but out of precise observation, insight and political memory. Sadly, they have been proven more than right.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
I am one of those written by Ndiang'ui , February 04, 2009
If there is anyyone who has warned about Odinga on this very platform it has been myself. The use of 'we' is abound to elicit the many in the community I belong..
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Raila not the problem written by Curious , February 04, 2009
It is not Raila but Kenyans who have abandoned all common sense in the name of _____ (fill in whatever you like).
Is there real hope for Kenyans?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
RAILA IS ENJOYING THE TRAPPINGS OF POWER written by Captain , February 06, 2009
Let the man enjoy what he has now......for the wait has been long. When I joined the military I learnt quickly that power does not reside in a vacuum or in the multitudes of supporters but in the wielders of the articles of war....those who enjoy the monopoly of violence to defend the "leader", otherwise known as the "prince" or "saviour". And the formatted police or military bands play sweet melodious tunes in the lawns of the State lodges or the officers’ mess as the "leader" and his "O" group enjoy sumptuous meals, downed with caviar and yes, long..... belches.
Watching the Rt. Hon PM Eng. Raila Amolo Odinga moving around town guarded by mean looking members of the VIP protection wing of the "J" company, I notice that he has learnt quickly, to take the salute with the stride of a "leader" and to eat, drink and belch as sweet melodious music of (un)harmonic (irritating though) of restless masses waltzes in the background. For how would he know that he has "real power" without eating while an army of wananchi is making “musical” noises in the background?
Stop Complaining. Let the man have his piece in peace, the journey has been long and odious! Hail the Chief!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Diffrent goals written by Mlevi , February 06, 2009
We seem to be incapable of being of rational and pragmatic in Kenya. I am not sure if it’s a cultural issues or one of education. Maybe its not that folks are rational and pragmatic but the fact that we are very purposeful however, we are using the same language to achieve very different goals.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
it was just more of the same written by jaya wardene , February 08, 2009
It is not difficult to see why all the comments here are of a cynical nature. Eric Ng'enos's well-crafted article brings it all out. He takes me back to the heady euphoria of the days when our Orange team won the referendum on the constitution. The days when the future looked bright because it was going to be Orange. Would there a few in this room today whose rebuke perhaps is akin to that of disciple Peter, when he denied that he knew Jesus?
Kenyans wanted change, a new direction and a break with the past. We find ourselves today abandoned in the middle of nowhere, sitting by the side of the railway. Who knows when the next train will be coming along.
Political reforms, New constitutions and other catchy promises have failed us. We put too much faith and power in our politicians. More of the same.
If you ask me why, I will say that it is because the majority of us are very very poor and as Ng'eno says we have been mentally conditioned to not only accept, but to expect the grabbing, pushing, bullying, looting, Kifua type Matatu mentality as our way of life. Our leaders have shown us the way.
From the comments above, you all know that. Why then do you blame me when I send out my 8 year-old child with a jerry-can?
The man has built a fortune, both politically and financially off of deceiving people.