purchase viagra onlinebuy CIALIS 20mg
Home
The Mo Ibrahim Index-Kenya's Story PDF Print E-mail
Written by InSidious   
Friday, 28 September 2007

Last week, the Mohammed Ibrahim Index of African Governance as constituted through Havard's Kennedy School of Business released its 2007 rankings placing Kenya at 15th out of 48.

As usual and especially with the election fever competing for the front pages, the media gave the report only cursory run-throughs in their print issues. At the same time, the Government's Spokesman had no official statement on the report, disposing of the zealous enthusiasm he employs in calling attention to the most mundane issues. Nothing at all surprising so far, then.

This index was created in recognition of the need for a more objective and quantifiable method of measuring governance in the 48 countries of sub-Saharan Africa. The Mo Ibrahim Index provides both a new definition of governance, as well as a comprehensive set of governance measures. States are ranked and rated on the basis of five categories detailing essential values. These categories in turn comprise 58 individual measures, capturing clear, objective outcomes. These categories are:

  • Safety and Security
  • Rule of Law, Transparency and Corruption
  • Participation and Human Rights
  • Sustainable Economic Development
  • Human Development

Here is how these impact our daily lives

Safety & Security.
Going by last weeks events in Kisii, it pretty apparent Simeon Nyachae and his ilk will go to extreme lengths to ensure the status quo prevails. We have seen this menace before especially during the 1990s when Molo's residents lived in perpetual fear. Nairobi's satellite towns are not immune either suffering as they are from Mungiki and an army of organized criminals, all without the explicit condemnation of the crimes by area politician of stature.

 question_mark.jpg
 

But these facts should not come as a surprise. Kenyan politicians and insecurity seem to go hand in hand. The culture of political violence has been advanced and honed over the years, coming in especially handy in our tribalised politics when it is deemed necessary to intimidate potential opponents into compliance or silence. It is not only Nyachae whose got a violent streak though, President Moi has in similar fashion hinted this week at what may be the result of looking into the crimes of the past with a view to restitution. His son, Gideon, minced no words in implying that he would use violence if necessary to ensure that his family does not lose its wealth even speaking about spilling of blood. Such is the talent that Kenyans must choose from at the coming general elections. The prospect that things will change cannot be tolerated by this ilk and your safety and security will be held as ransom by the same old dinosaurs.
Consequence: the UNEP will move out of
Kenya, for good, and our position as a destination for foreign tourism will be unable to improve substantially.

Rule of Law, Transparency and Corruption.
Vigilante justice has long been a way of life in Kenya. It has mutated over the years into several forms with the constant remaining that civilians are subjected to the whims of lawless politically supported gangs. It is odd that these groups have neither been infiltrated by NSIS nor had their political patronage prevailed upon to ensure they comly with the law. Depending on what part of the country you call home, we all bear with us the horrific accounts of people who have been put through hell by these groups. Across the country, tribal tensions have been whipped up to fever-pitch, with noxious sound bites bearing little evidence of responsible foresight. And it could well be worse, for many politicians and public figures, the tribe is a place of last refuge especially when charges of corruption are raised.

You will recall that High Commissioner Edward Clay's "vomiting on donor' shoes comment" elicited wild and medieval rejoinders from every corner of Kenya's political establishment. It is now apparent that the 110 page report by international risk consultants Kroll details assets allegedly owned by the Moi family and associates in 28 countries. The Githongo Report is another indictment of what even the blindest Kenyan knows is the bane of our national existence. We must not deceive ourselves; the reciprocating cost of corruption is the reason why we are where we are as a country.
Consequence: Rapidly evaporating middle class and with it, consumer purchasing muscle. Even then, this says nothing of the great disincentive to new businesses, or the cost of conducting trade in a country where a large part of business income is lost in unpredictable corruption costs.

Participation and Human Rights.
It is irrational to argue as some have, that free speech alone is an indication of progress in human rights. Even as the expansion in some freedoms is acclaimed, Kenyans must be aware of the enormity of human rights abuses elsewhere. Extraordinary renditions- extrajudicial transfers of a Kenyan citizens to other states especially Ethiopian jails, torture by the police service, police brutality, illegal arrests and even the barbaric practice of clobbering suspects with batons while boarding Police vehicles. What happened to thorough investigative work, hand-cuffing suspects and the presumption of innocence?

98 Kenyan civilians were killed by marauding foreigners this year and the Sabaot especially have been victims of the Uganda's UPF forces whose obvious disregard for Kenyan's sovereignty is clear for all to see. That this persists while we spend disproportionate sums on defence is truly tragic, and displays the injustice of our resourse allocation. Simplistic rhetoric from the Head of State and State officials do not address these issues, leaving the wider public's rights open to gross violation.

In addition, the media editors show a lack of judgement and yet perpetuate a sense of melancholy and defeat in doing their jobs. There is little attempt at follow through on these stories and issues of relevant debate are subject to the editors' political slant. Free press, yes: but of little value in bringing about change and advancing our knowledge or promoting accountability.
Consequence: a perception in the national culture that human rights are expendable as the media merely tracks national prejudices instead of providing leadership. In the meantime, large parts of Kenya's population feel increasingly unprotected and exploited.

Sustainable Economic Development
The latest multinational to leave Kenya is Colgate Palmolive. Since 2003, the list has grown and includes, Johnson & Johnson, Agip, Unilever, Procter & Gamble and most recently, ExxonMobil. This must be our greatest concern, especially as we strive for the economic growth that will create jobs and improve lives across the country.

An Eritrean friend who for many years lived and raised his family in Kenya but now lives in the US, decided to invest in EastAfrica. After carrying out country comparisons, he opted for Uganda. Next week, he travels there with several American friends to open 2 gas Stations and a Small Business consultancy firm. So as our government officials sign off on 6% economic growth, the re-adjusted GDP index (2003) betrays below average and shows off our structural problems. At the same time the multi-nationals I have spoken about relocate, shut down or downsize their operations, actions that are unlikely in an expanding economy.

Further re-inforcing the fact that there has been little progress, Kenya persists as a poor investment destination, particularly when compared against regional alternatives. The notoriously high cost of power in Kenya, difficulties in obtaining licenses and visas, inefficiencies at the Port of Mombasa, rising insecurity and deteriorating infrastructure add to the tariff barriers discouraging investment in this market. A lot more needs to be done if the country is to compete with other money destinations worldwide.
Consequence: The endurance of an immotile Jua Kali economy, massive unemployment and great inequality.

Human Development
Add up the above 4 indexes and do the math. Consequence: a Squatter Nation, with citizens increasingly adrift from global progress.


InSidious
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (11)add
0
boom
written by Mr.Kay , September 29, 2007
For every multinational that leaves, three are entering...so I think you neglected that point. 6.5% GDP is not happening out of thin air. Economy is booming.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: boom
written by a guest , September 30, 2007
For every multinational that leaves, three are entering...so I think you neglected that point. 6.5% GDP is not happening out of thin air. Economy is booming.


Facts please. Names?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Timothy Wainaina , September 30, 2007
Great work. Are these indexes useful unless there are consequences for them?
The Kenyan media are truly irresponsible, not just in the areas you have highlighted, but much more widely in provinding leadership to Kenyans. Most of the time, as this website shows, ordinary Kenyans can do so much better journalism than any journalist in Nairobi. Their prejudices, the breadth of their knowledge and their analytical skills show no sign of having attended any schools at all.

As to the 6%, This is just a number, there have been many signs through the years that this growth has not been felt anywhere but at the very top levels of Kenyan society. Inflation really has made life much more expensive than it was before, and those jobs Anyang' Nyong'o and co were bragging about are non-existent.

P.S. Thank you for pointing out about the companies. I had not heard of it before.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: boom
written by Don , October 01, 2007
For every multinational that leaves, three are entering...so I think you neglected that point. 6.5% GDP is not happening out of thin air. Economy is booming.


Kay,
I'm not a fun of MNCs or the much hyped magic of FDIs, but I think you are being disingenuous claiming that Kenya has a net gain of two MNCs. Show us the evidence to corroborate your claims. Further, your assertion that the economy must be booming because of reported 6.5% misses the author's point. See that we're still at 6% growth rate even after adjusting (scaling-up) our GDP Index in 2003. If you scale the GDP growth rate numbers from 2003 back to the metrics used during Moi's time, you'd be surprise at how dismal the figures are.

Regarding the MoI Index. I think it's too dated to inform us adequately. 2005 is such a long time ago that the numbers are irrelevant. More so, I know how the index is constructed and the data used. Besides, I'd categorize some of the names behind it into the lot of "bigoted clueless Africa experts." Anyhow, I suppose the reason the Government blacked it out was its painting of a not so rosy picture. We deteriorated in safety and security, marginally improved on economic opportunity (still way below 50%), and stagnated in human development. Look at the countries performing better than us in sustainable economic opportunity: Swaziland, Tanzania, Uganda, Gabon, Cameroon, Cape Verde, etc. In a nutshell, the story arising from the index is that Kenya was no better in 2005 than 2002, in those scores that matter most to its citizens: security, economic opportunity, and human development.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Writers gloom and doom unjusti
written by Cogni , October 01, 2007
The Mo Ibrahim governance index report had lots of good news for Kenya. Kenya's performance overtime shows a sharp decline from 2000 to 2002 and a steady improvement from 2002 to Present.

The results and graph can be found here
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Great piece
written by Man R , October 01, 2007
Author? Could the T in your name by any chance stand for Terence?

Anyhow, Kenyans know what they must do but are hesitant. We should use elections to hold politicians, especially the president, accountable. It's insane to say Kenya's economy is booming. The only thing that's booming in Kenya is despair. When I was there in June, I saw a bitter nation without direction. The president was practically absent, (this is not to say Arap Moi's omnipresence was in any way sexy)But the president has to show his/her leadership every now and then. This Kibaki hand-off style of leadership is just a euphemism for laziness.

Insecurity is a major problem that's driving investors away. There is a joke in Nairobi now that if you are looking for an apartment in the city, you want torent the topmost floor because Mungiki are not likely to attack you there... But we all know Mungiki aren't cowed by heights nor depths; the government's dragging of its feet and the deafening silence from Central Province MPs that greeted the group's orgy of violence was a loud acknowledgment of the group's grip in the area, and a testament to just how weak our security forces have been rendered by the well-connected group.

The Armenian circus, the never-ending ethnic tensions and the regular city crime, pile up in a compost heap of serious government failures in serving the citizens.

Kenya has to shake itself away from the grip of old-school elitist politicians like Pres. Kibaki. We must look for radical new ideas of governing our nation for us to stay relevant in world's politics and ensuring prosperity.

It's not OK that five years after we enthusiastically sung yote yawezekana bila Moi, he's now moonwalked his way back in the fold with a big endorsement for the guy who kicked him to the curb. What's wrong with Kenya? Is Moi's endorsement for Kibaki a good thing?

This is just pathetic. In fact, Moi's endorsement is a clear indication of Pres. Kibaki's failure in tackling corruption. Baseless sycophantic retorts like this one from Mr. Kay just makes you wonder why our nation has keyed in to such low standards.
For every multinational that leaves, three are entering...so I think you neglected that point. 6.5% GDP is not happening out of thin air. Economy is booming.

The reasons outlined in the indices and many others makes Pres. Kibaki the least favorable leader Kenya needs right now. The sins of Kibaki and crew make Raila and Mudavadi's ODM the most credible team that should be allowed to lead Kenya.

A vote for Kibaki will be a loud endorsement for the status quo of failure and mediocrity that has plagued us for more than four decades.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Objectivity
written by pndiangui , October 01, 2007
I really dont see why when Raila seeks Moi support , Raila supporters see it necessary but when he's doing the opposite Kibaki is bashed. Well none of these two men represents Wanjiku at heart but I beg some objectivity.
By the way for those who claim manu MNC have left Nairobi , GE has transferred its corporate headquaters for Africa from Johannesberg to Nairobi, Coke has done them same, HP has chosen Nairobi as the platform of expansion into Central and East Africa. Even Mo Ibrahim's Celtel corporate HQ have been partly been moved from Dutch to Nairobi , and this Office is supposed to serve as the point of expansion in Celtel's Africa growth strategy. More? I can site more and more firms that are positioning themselves in Nairobi. Not because of Kibaki or Raila's well crafted policies but mainly because of the human capital in the country.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Country of Administrators?
written by Don , October 01, 2007
Bwana Ndiangui,

Thanks for the information about MNCs, now we can debate based on facts not fiction. Now tell me. What do we need MNC corporate headquarters for? Does Kenya need more administrators and expats or entrepreneurs and skilled workers? So they locate their productive (value-adding) activities elsewhere but use Kenya for marketing and distribution? Granted, they'll create jobs for a few individual administrators and other watu wa mikono but, is that something a country should be celebrating or aspiring for? Label me old-fashioned yes but I see little logic in such a trend.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Take a cue from KAM
written by InSidious , October 03, 2007
For every multinational that leaves, three are entering...so I think you neglected that point. 6.5% GDP is not happening out of thin air. Economy is booming.


http://www.nationmedia.com/eas...110075.htm

Allegiances aside, does anyone really believe Kenya is on an economic boom?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Facts/analysis first
written by Nyawira , October 03, 2007
great article, my only concern is that you are assuming we read the report, we didnt, maybe you would have started by telling us briefly what how Kenya was rated on the indices below, before giving your opinion/analysis??

Safety and Security
Rule of Law, Transparency and Corruption
Participation and Human Rights
Sustainable Economic Development
Human Development

thanks
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
FDI and Technology
written by pndiangui , October 04, 2007
Don

I actually dont favour the past Era of MCN's much as a sustainable way of achieving National objectives but you need to see what globolisation is doing to many MCN's as well as MCN's being catalysts of technology transfer and methods that can be applied to meet locals needs by sprouting Local firms from former employees or even customers of the same. Thats how Equity Bank came to being , and others . On the changing global front of the way MCN's recruit talent and invest ,they have become more independent from their Corporate HQ. Leaders in these decoupling strategies are IBM and GE . If you for example look at the innovations they are launching in Asia away from their percieved American HQ's. They are moving away from what used to be termed as low outsourcing centres which represented 'labour arbtirage' to relying on local Talent to serve their Global strategies , in essence 'Knowledge arbitrage'. What such strategies do is to fuel R & D and the creation of knowledge workers locally that have potential of bringing forth start-ups in those very industries to disrupt the MCN's. A case in our country is Equity Bank and Bidco.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 02 October 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company

Buy Cheap Software Corel Home Office 5.0 Multilingual Corel WordPerfect Office 2002 Professional Edition