The strawman in Nairobi PDF Print E-mail
Written by Rodgers Akombe   
Wednesday, 10 January 2007

It is often gratifying to blame the monster called Central Government for every little misfortune that befalls our locality.

It is common to hear people say, "Nairobi is stifling development of our area because we are not from the president's tribe." Some of those making such claims are MPs who sit in Nairobi and are part of the central government.

A close look at the allocation of funds will show that Local Government and constituencies get a piece of the pie. This piece often ends up being privatized. Our local leaders will then point fingers to Nairobi when asked why services are not being rendered.

Districts, Local Authorities (LA), and constituencies receive money directly from the central government. The LAs receive budgetary support from the central government in form of Local Authorities Transfer Funds (LATF). 5% of the total income tax collected by the central government is allocated in this fund. 7% of this is shared equally among 175 Local Authorities while the remainder is distributed in consideration of population and other economic indicators. The central government and the Kenya Local Government Reform Program's secretariat - where Local Authorities have representatives - come up with the formula of distribution. More often than not, LAs do not account for these funds.

In addition, Local Authorities collect local taxes, duties for trading permits, parking fees, and collect levies for delivery of services. It is shocking to note that most LAs owe their employees several months of worth of salaries in arrears.

Citizens - through a mandate given by the Local Service Delivery Action Plan (LASDAP) - are supposed to question how their moneys are being spent. They are supposed to participate in planning for development projects and evaluating if they met their expectations. We are also given a constitutional mandate to elect and fire councillors should we feel that we are being taxed without fair representation. It is a shame that we keep on electing empty heads as our councillors. Most of these councillors - if not all - don't know what their duty is. That tells you a lot about the electorate.

There also exists a Road Maintenance Levy Fund (RMLF). 16% of this fund goes to districts to maintain rural roads. MPs, Councillors and other opinion leaders sit in committees that share these funds among all constituencies in respective districts. So in any given year, every constituency gets a part of the RMLF. The monies end up in people's pockets.

Constituencies receive money from the Constituency Development Fund (CDF). The fund shares 2.5% of our ordinary national revenue among 210 constituencies. This financial year, sh 5 billion was allocated to the fund. The CDF is intended to go into the development of major projects in respective constituencies. More often than not, MPs' cronies and their spouses manage the fund. A majority of MPs cannot account for this fund.

Tea farmers are surcharged a 1% Tea Cess. According to the Kenya Tea Board statistics, Kenya exported tea worth US $567.42 million in 2005. 1% of that amount went into the Tea Cess. 80% of the tea cess goes into road building and maintenance. The fund is distributed to every tea factory. It is a shame that most of the money if not all ends up in people's pockets.

In my home (Mokomoni in N. Mogirango/Borabu Constituency) we have a number of tea factories; we receive the CDF, LATF, and RMLF. One would expect to the constituency to have average roads but this is not the case. The Nyaramba-Mokomoni road - which borders the Sang'anyi Tea Factory and is a stone throw away from the area MP's shop and residence - is a total mess. Right outside Sang'anyi factory there are deep gullies in the road from years of soil erosion. Even the huge trucks - popularly known as Toriti - that ferry tea find it rough navigating through these canyons. So what went wrong?

We pride ourselves as democratic citizens in a democratic country. What we have is a "once-in-five-years-democracy" where we trade our votes for money or we vote along tribal lines. Our local leaders have successfully created a straw man called central government to whom they attribute all our tribulations. This way they have succeeded in looting with impunity.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (12)add
0
...
written by emmo opoti , January 10, 2007
Great article. You know your numbers!

It has always been hoped that reducing the power of Nairobi over the provinces would lead to greater accountability in the management of public resources. Sadly experience has taught us that the opposite is true.

My family owns a farm in a similarly productive part of the country, up in Kenya's granary around Kitale. Just like in your part of the country, there's little sign anywhere of the fruit of that revenue.

It is good to see these figures, they show just how much MPs in the provinces would have made a difference if they had a mind to.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
A job well done!
written by aeichener , January 11, 2007
A thorough and very informative article - my compliments! Please continue this.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Facts
written by Amir Ibrahim , January 11, 2007
This is great. I am not sure I cano do much about it, but this is investigative reporting like you don't see in the newspapers.

The MPs have lobbied long and hard to win these monies from the Treasury. Now that we've got love what are we going to do with it? We ought to check and see what MPs are really worthy of the privilege to serve Kenyans.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
cool
written by Dan Kihote , January 11, 2007
A great article that is bound to set the pulses going. The forensic journalist is definitely in the house.

Aside from development and issues of accountability your article touches on administration.....a monster topic in itself....

On the matter of transparency It is surely now incumbent upon all MPs to quickly set up their websites where they can publish for all to see a breakdown of how these monies are disbursed in the local area. Aspiring candidates must demand to see what the sitting MPs have been doing.

How can one lay their hands on the minutes of these MP/Coucillor committees?

Kumbe the much maligned "straw man" is just a clever diversion.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Kamale , January 11, 2007
Absolutely great article!!!!

I had the occassion sometime back to speak to the chairman of Karuri town council about the woes facing local authorities. His view was that politics and the scramble for allowances is what leads to non delivery of services and even failure to meet revenue targets. However, in his town council, and perhaps it is the only one in the country, they run a comfortable surplus of revenue over expenditure.

In order to ensure that the councillors also provide a service to their wards, the town council has started a "mini-CDF" where wards are awarded money from this surplus so that they can create development plans at that level. A great effort has been made to improve the infrastructure of the town. I do not come from the town but my visit there was a real eye-opener.

On the LASDAP, local authorities are required to publish in the media their budgets as well as their actual expenditure for the previous period. Councillors are required to discuss these budget plans at ward level before approval of the budgets. What has lacked is the education to wananchi that this is the avenue to vet what their local authorities are doing and approve/reject some of the council plans. But will wananchi have the time to go for these barazas?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
good article
written by Dave Nyambati , January 11, 2007
The CDF will be Kibakis legacy - although corruption still threatens it. I long for the day when all government expenditure will be in the public domain and easily accesible.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
More research on a local level
written by aeichener , January 11, 2007
Kamale:
About the interaction between local authorities and civil service organizations (or, following the penchant for abbreviations: CSOs), an interesting case study has just been published in 2006, about the city of Nakuru. Since I have been there myself (and on the ground, not just domiciled in a Milimani manor), I think I am in a position to evaluate the validity of the study at least at bit. The main author is a specialist with very good knowledge who had done his PhD at Amsterdam, but now is back in Egerton as a professor or lecturer in the Dept. of Sociology, S(amson) Wokabi Mwangi (mwokabi at yahoo.com).

"Community Action and Partnering in Nakuru, a Critical Appraisal of the Process of Services Upgrading in Low-income Neighbourhoods"
January 2006, 33 pp.
(PDF file)

His previous study (16 p.) from the year 2000, also as PDF file,
is found here:

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Interesting read
written by kendirangu , January 11, 2007
This is a great article. It's worth noting that most of our leaders (Even those with good intentions) are busy pointing fingers in the wrong direction.
Accountability is a massive issue and will definitely be a bone of contention in the coming elections I hope it won't only be at the parliamentary and presidential level.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Very good Article and touches
written by pndiangui , January 11, 2007
Good figures.
The misappropriation of funds however seems to be only targeted to the central government.
I remember when DP was the alternative government (official opposition) with the current president as their leader , Prof. Wangari Maathai and Wanyiri Kihoro complained alot about the rotting Nairobi City Council which was full of DP councillors,while DP itself would stand in public galleries accusing the KANU government of corruption and misappropriation of funds. Kibaki would be on record asking how the Roads levy had been spent.
Did we expect anything better from him , with such hypocriyy and trying to talk DP as a party out of a behaviour that they themselves are a part of?
A resounding NO!

The highest rot in Nairobi city council happened under the majority of DP with the mayor, deputy mayor and other elected officials being from the same party. Yet the public expected better when DP took over the central government.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Other examples
written by emmo opoti , January 11, 2007
Kamale
Do you know any constituency that has a record as good as Karuri? There is a lot of very good work going on insome constituencies of Central Province and as Alex has said before also in Joe Khamisi's Bahari Constituency.

P.S Dave, CDF is not an invention of Kibaki's. We ought to give credit where it is due,just as Kibaki is not responsible for all that goes wrong during his time as President, neither is he to be credited with all that is good about it. I think it is the work of Muriuki wa Ol Kalou, no?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Good research
written by Obamab , January 12, 2007
It is interesting to note that the monies that are collected do finally trickle down to the Local authorities. Interestingly very few people are able to name or identify their local councillors. This pretty much lets this guys be able to do anything they want to do with the taxpayer’s monies. My take would be to concentrate on the education of the electorate to identify the impact of the local authorities in their every day lives.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Time to take action on City Ha
written by Dancan Muhindi , March 23, 2007
Just to quote Rodgers Akombe:

"It is a shame that we keep on electing empty heads as our councillors. Most of these councillors - if not all - don't know what their duty is. That tells you a lot about the electorate."

A truly insightful analysis of our councillors.

Well, I've always beleived that any serious reforms in our country must logically begin at the grassroots. Its time the voters focused more keenly on the calibre of leaders at council level.

Am a Kenyan professional who strongly advocates other like-minded reformers, to focus their energies and resources at penetrating and reforming our local authorities in critical numbers.
Let us move away from talking about it, to actually DOING SOMETHING!

Please see my CIVIC EMAIL ANNOUNCEMENT here:
http://smartkenyan.com/index1....newsId=257
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 11 January 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company