purchase viagra onlinebuy CIALIS 20mgbuy cialis online
Home
Where is the Kenyan Left? PDF Print E-mail
Written by Tim Norwood   
Thursday, 16 August 2007

I have been reading a plethora of comments on Kenyan fora about a mysterious group called the Kenyan left. Invariably it is composed of individuals allied to ODM-Raila.

I am writing here in the vain hope that I can rouse them from their slumber with regard to their duties as members of the political left, or provoke them into coming out in the open, because I cannot see them. It would be a good thing if they came out, maybe they can even start to shed their disguises and show themselves unashamedly, for it seems to me that Kenya has not needed a left as badly as it does now for a long, long time.

Kenya is badly crying out for leftist thought and for leftist ideas, even if this was merely outside parliament. Injustice, inequality and an increasingly illiberal streak in the state leave the masses as citizens of a dystopic nation with little for its weakest to hope for.

The people's minds however are totally caught up in the cultural hegemony of the religious priests and their tribal lords who are without exception corrupt billionaires. Many of them, shamelessly clothed themselves in Marxist garb, mouth platitudes about the need for reform, all the time directing our gaze away from the fact that they are complicit in the rape of our nation. Few of them were there to put up the scaffolding of the corrupt and stifling state, but they are very busy today supplying the steel and concrete for the Black Iron Prison, standing idly by but just as often abetting and participating in the disenfranchisement and empoverishment of the working masses.

 It is interesting to hear these people call Presidents Kibaki and Moi fascists, very interesting to hear them talk about the need to give power to the people. It is interesting to hear men in Maoist suits writing newspaper articles praising Bismarck, and to hear pseudo-leftists proudly quoting Winston Churchill and John F. Kennedy. They are something special, they even boast about their affiliation with the Democratic Party of America, and attendance of some of its meetings.

It is most impressive to hear these chameleons praising nationalism, talking about the Majestic People of Kenya, and patriotism. It is indeed most riveting to see that there are no ideas left in this left of ours, nothing remotely resembling an intellectual framework. Scour the pages of the newspapers, these socialists do not even write, and when they do they do not write anything remotely inspired by the ideas of socialism or justice. They have bequeathed to our political culture nothing but an endless stream of unoriginal ideas as we suffer from those who support the government and the status quo. As Gramsci wrote so long ago, we are dominated and our life choices managed by an overarching consensual hegemony, one in which our pseudo-leftists even here are an integral part of, married as they are to the system.

It is interesting to note that even in the regions of the country where the Moi and Kibaki governments have had close to zero representation in the years since 1992, there has been no movement towards anything remotely resembling socialism. There is nothing resembling socialism in Kisumu or in Bondo, even though the education system there is controlled by the pretend left. There have been no bills proposed in parliament by our socialists to put an end to the increasing gulf between the rich and the poor, far from it. In fact, that Bishop of the left in Anyang' Nyong'o was not too long ago insulting us with pronouncements about an invisible 500,000 jobs and an improvement in the quality of life enjoyed by the mwananchi. Listen in awe to their silence as the Kibaki government sprints towards an all out grab for the public purse.

All that's left

The red flag is waved merely to enrage the bull, make it charge mindlessly, battering down all the obstacles in its way. Maybe now would be a good time to remember that organization called the National Socialists. They also had big crowds, they heckled at their opponents, and they promised the freedom of the mwananchi from poverty, they were big on symbols of power and names, names that pledged doom to anyone who dared oppose them. They served one master; they chanted his name, wrote endlessly in his defense and ultimately showed that they were not interested in the welfare of the people, but in raw power and in smashing away all opposition.

You vote for them if you like, it will all go very Animal Farm then, and no one will be able to say they did not see it coming. Not even the foolish hordes that blemish the emperors golden chariot with their filthy fingers.

P.S. The writer is offering one million Kenyan dollars for every leftist parliamentarian or mainstream politician that can be revealed to him.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (14)add
0
...
written by Timothy Wainaina , August 16, 2007
ODM-Raila for your information is resisting the privatisations of both Safaricom and Telkom, and has made murmurs in the past about turning back the clock on the privatisations of the previous years.

It is difficult to have a true left in a non-civilised country. The politics of the left are almost completely based on higher values that are learned and cultivated, much unlike the atavistic nature of the selfish traits of global capitalism.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by l.a.papakemus , August 16, 2007
one million kenyan dollars? tsk tsk
non-civilised country? for shame!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
so much for economists
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 16, 2007
Well, if we must mourn the Kenyan left, why not just mourn Kenyan civil society. It seems to me that Moi was useful for one thing, he kept people thinking. Since the end of the KANU government Kenyans seem to have stopped completely with the ideas.

Jaindi Kisero recently ran an article on the way the Kibaki regime is misusing public funds, all with the silent approval of parliament, he has been alone in pointing out the excessive inflation that is crippling Kenyans and an unsustainable borrowing regime or the high crimes being committed on the unpoliced Nairobi Stock Exchange even as the President and his buddies slap each others backs and proclaim our African Tiger status.

Three years ago, the investment group, Trans-century Ltd purchased 75 per cent of East Africa Cables from Mr Naushad Merali at a time when the price of the stock was Sh27 per share.
Yesterday, the share closed trading at Sh607. No single company on the Nairobi Stock Exchange (NSE) has experienced such a rapid upsurge in its stock in the last three years.
In the past three weeks, the price of the share has risen by more than 75 per cent.These people are laughing all the way to the bank. They can sell at Sh607 a unit what they bought at a mere Sh27, only three years ago.


Kenyans are then caught up between the NARC-K thieves, and ODM or -K who have in their constituencies both through CDF and their control of local government shown just how incompetent they are likely to be even in office. Lest we forget, most of the ODM-K chiefs have been in government in the past, and just as Kibaki's Moi era behaviour was a harbinger of the manner of his Presidency, so should the careers of Raila and his cohort remind us just how capable/ incapable they truly are.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
proto-socialists
written by Amir Ibrahim , August 16, 2007
There is nothing that is more dangerous to Kenya than this pseudo-left taking over. While only the irresponsible would cheer on the nefarious Kibaki government, one has to be especially irresponsible to sing the praises of Raila Odinga and his band of merrymen.

I can usually tell an ODM-R supporter apart from the crowd simply by looking at his unwavering desire to discuss nothing but the latest antics of the man, everyone who does not bow down is an enemy of change, everyone who does not sing his praise an agent for the dark forces of Moi and Kibaki, a fascist.

The left is about education and altruism. It is about giving and caring, about being so civilised society takes on a higher importance than the selfish whims of the individual; exactly the things no Kenyan politician can say for himself.
---
Are the Kenyan Unions in politics?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Ignorance Really Is Bliss
written by Onyango Oloo , August 16, 2007
Perhaps the first place to start is examine Kenya's history- stretch that from the 1930s to the year 2007.

You see, some of us will not take any responsibility for such crass displays of deliberate ignorance.

When you are ready to engage some of us in a serious discussion devoid of tribal and personal innuendoes, please get in touch.

Onyango Oloo
Nairobi, Kenya
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kenyan Left is DEAD
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 16, 2007
Perhaps the first place to start is examine Kenya's history- stretch that from the 1930s to the year 2007.
Onyango Oloo
Nairobi, Kenya


Aha, a gate-keeper approaches. Onyango Oloo wears his heart on his sleeve, and is no doubt a cut above the rest of the ODM crowd, but even a glance at his personal fiefdom at Jukwaa will reveal just how apt Tim's characterisation of the pretend left is. There they celebrate the decimation of Gikuyu youth, and are obsessed with tribal, Us vs. Them politics.

Maybe Oloo can explain for us why any leftist of repute would back a status quo party like Raila Odinga's. Who is the tribalist here?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
left?
written by Mr.Kay , August 16, 2007
You can keep your communist crap to yourself. Kenya has moved on.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Upuzi!!
written by Mr. E , August 16, 2007
This - about left or right needs to stop!!!Being either of the above does not in anyway bring food to the tables of Kenyans. We need to rid ourselves of these ideological nonsense and get our hands dirty and get some work done. The pillars of a progressive society cares less on whether one is a leftist or a rightist as they are clear cut. Everytime we digress from what need to do to develop ourselves as a nation, opportunities will just pass us by. We need a paradigm shift in Kenya; one that orientates everyone towards a common goal of coming together and building ourselves...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
not dead.
written by jaya wardene , August 16, 2007
To imagine that the left is dead or finished is to make a big mistake. Please do not be fooled that a majority of Kenyans do not see what is going on.

That is why the civil society is in the forefront of opposing some of the excesses of this GK.

That is why we do not have to wait for Amnesty International to call for an immediate inquiry into the actions of our police force in its declared "war on mungiki" and that is why we will stand together to see the dreaded media bill struck off.

Some writers like to say that the era of neo-liberalism ushered the demise of the left..wishful thinking...a few clouds do not mean rain is assured.. you cannot kill ideas with smartly dressed finance spokesmen brilliant smiles and a new privatisation.

The sweat and toil of the small farmer or that of the city hawker and the construction and factory worker are as real today as at any time in our history. The struggle for justice will not and cannot end until it is achieved
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Nark-Kenya is More Socialist t
written by Kimani S. Njoroge , August 16, 2007
You killing me, Tim. You've presented your case so well that I cannot tell uko pande gani. I however guess left.

One thing that Kenyatta did so well, albeit ruthlessly, was to destroy roots of socialism in our sweet sweet land Kenya. Those who went against his ways were branded socialist or communist sympathizers. This resulted to their slow political deaths, and so went their leftist beliefs. It happened to Jaramogi, Kaggia, and JM; it's still haunting wa Thiong'o, Nyong’o, and Raila.

But that was in 60's and 70s. Today’s Kenya lacks the distinction between ‘right’ and ‘left’. Our political class is actually on the left. Just look at our Legislature's Bills and Local Governments by-laws: they are all rooting for wealth redistribution instead of creation; media gagging instead of freedom; state monopolies instead of privatization; political centralization instead of decentralization; and nonsensical antismoking and plastic bags by-laws instead of business-friendly ones.

Who’s more leftist: ODM or NARK Kenya
We see ODM as leftist because of her socialist rhetoric, and Nark-Kenya capitalistic due to her Transcentury connections. Nark's actions actually more socialistic than ODM’s. For who gave us CDF; who's killing our local governments using LATF; and who's muzzling our media; who’s killing our young democracy? Is it the parrots in ODM or the ‘bloodsuckers’ in Nark?

Enter Bismarck and Kibaki
A greater leftist behavior is coming from the president himself. He is learning from non other than Otto von Bismarck, the father of German socialism and ODM's guiding angel. Exactly 100 years ago, Bismarck's government had the same problem as Kibaki's: socialists were winning electorates through leftist promises. Bismarck crushed them by providing the very paternalistic goodies they preached, those goodies included: health, accident, unemployment, and disability insurance. Notable economic historians credit Hitler's political rise to Bismarck's programs.

Like von Bismarck, Kibaki is (through ‘free secondary education’ and other free goodies) beating Kenya’s left at their own game.

Who is more leftist now?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
in response
written by emmo opoti , August 17, 2007
Mr E, any progressive movement is leftist by any other name. That is the whole point to the name.

Mr K, the communist crap gave us many of the rights and privileges we take for granted. Read a little.

When Tim and I first discussed this article, we were merely responding to a discussion on another forum ( where the use of such terms as MPK- Majestic People of Kenya are found ) which desribes itself as left leaning.

Kimani
Wealth distribution and wealth creation need not necessarily be inimical to each other. In Northern Europe for example, Scania, Volvo, IKEA, Saab and so on exist right inside states that are greatly inspired by the ideas of the traditional left. Wealth distribution is about justice and fairness, in the end as the examples of Mungiki, the endless tribal clashes and insecurity in Nairobi aver; it is also a matter of national security.
On state monopolies and privatisation. Well, if the idea is to smash monopolies then I think it would be much more prudent to lower barriers to entry than to go about stealing from wananchi. We can couch it in euphemistic argot but when the ownership of KenGen for example is transferred from 35 million Kenyans to 280,000 (if so many) then what we have cannot be called justice, especially when the bulk of the 35 million are both unable to participate in the free-for-all and desperately poor. Even those of us who are businessmen can see the injustice in that.
Now KenGen, like KPLC is still a monoploy and there are really few benefits to be got from privatising them. Like I always say, it is not the privatising that makes a firm more efficient, it is its management culture. Temasek ( owner of Singapore Airlines), DWP, Emirates and even Western firms like the BBC, DHL, Deutsche Post, Deutsche Bahn are all either wholly or partly owned by their governments. All our privatisation efforts are succeeding in doing is transfering wealth to the rich, it is not creating wealth at all and neither is it creating jobs or improving delivery.

Centralisation again is not characteristic of the left. In fact, true socialism is stateless, with no serikali to boss people about. The left is about granting power to the people, it is about liberalism and freedom, which virtues as you have pointed out, our parliament takes a decidedly dim view of.

On Bismarck and the left. Bismarck can in no way be construed to be the father of German or any socialism, he was a tribalistic, and conservative monarchist and an enemy of the left, which is why it is odd that our proto-socialists (^) are so eager to take him up as a champion.

I am inspired more by te left leaning parties of Europe than any old Frankenstein the American media machine has conjured up. In that tradition, rather than seeking to overthrow the hold of capitalism over society, we seek to reform it. In my opinion this tension is necessary because it is through it that a nation is able both to create wealth and to distribute it fairly.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , August 17, 2007
Anti-smoking and anti-paper bag laws may seem draconian to you, until you realise that the costs of the free-for-all are actually much higher than those of restriction. I gather from your comments that you are something of a libertarian, even then you must admit that such civil liberties as infringe on the rights of others are best curtailed by a responsible government. Otherwise, we are shredding the social contract and let the powerful do as they please.

Jaya,
For me, as for some other respondents above, the tragedy is the vaccum that exists on the left, as the two camps beat their war-drums it is the poor and weak in the middle who get trampled upon.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by H , August 18, 2007
The Left can only create another Tanzania under Ujamaa, where laziness becomes large scale. See how long it takes to come to a decision on anything!

I am a strong individual responsibility.
Every man and woman has the ability to chart a destiny for themselves. That is the reason why I go Republican each time Welfare if mentioned in America.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 26, 2007
Don't be silly H.
You obviously know nothing baout what you talk about. There is no lack of individual responsibility in social politics. There is a wide gulf between being responsible to your society and the man eat man policies of your masters.

Your Republican friends. I see they have no problem taking subsidies, grants and massive government projects then, but begrudge the little people these same treats, eh? I cannot think of any US President who was more big government than George W. All they are doing is robbing the Middle Class, you cheer on you, but its your pocket they are biting. Look at the state of American agriculture, look at your Airlines, look at Boeing, Lockheed Martin, the Big Car companies. You do not see Welfare there?

The shootings outside your window, the crack dealers, the poor medical care, the everything you have that makes America a Third World country is down to this selfish, immoral attitude of yours.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 16 August 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company