purchase viagra onlinebuy CIALIS 20mg
Why I will not vote for Kibaki PDF Print E-mail
Written by Stephen Wanyama   
Wednesday, 25 April 2007

Later this year, the President will for one of the few times in his tenure as head of state consider the instruction of our constitution. He will dissolve parliament and call an election. In response Kenyans will go into a frenzied dance and infused with a sense of mission, political debate in the country will take on an even higher pitch as rival camps debate how best to steer this 'great' nation into the First World. The ritual and the circus surrounding it will be brought to an end, under the fierce December sun, in the marking of small pieces of paper in an arcane ritual that lends us an illusory sense of empowerment. A few days later, we will be treated to a flourish of a finish with the announcement of a winner, who if opinion polls are anything to go by, should be Emilio Mwai Kibaki.

 This endorsement of the incumbent is not a far-fetched outcome. It is the result of a number of factors, each weighty in its own right. The president retains membership of two clubs, each mighty and determined. The first is the Gikuyu tribe, or for these purposes the GEMA peoples. In Kenya's political culture, riven as it is with tribal rivalries, the Gikuyu and their cousins in the GEMA grouping make for an immensely powerful bloc. Numbering close to 40% of the population, they give any candidate from their midst an incredible advantage at election time, some many even say insurmountable advantage.

The former Vice President Kibaki is also one of the oldest members of Kenya's political and business elite. No, not the neophytes like Raila Odinga, Kalonzo Musyoka or Mukhisa Kituyi who have only recently cut their political teeth but truly old players some of them dating to beyond political independence from the UK. Unlike the battling boys in the ODM-K camp, these men are united beyond mere political affiliation. Their land and business empires overlap, as do often their family ties. But the most powerful ingredient in the glue that binds them is the fact that they are revelers in the status quo. Sure it may get a little uncomfortable if someone from without their control ascends to the Presidency, but if the changes made are not too radical, things are just peachy for them, just peachy. This cabal needs to retain control of Kenyan politics, to bequeath it to their sons and to expand their reaches as far as they can.

The second factor propping up the expectation of a Kibaki victory is the proximity of his fingers, even his indolent fingers to the buttons and levers of state. The incumbent's inertia aside, the Kenyan President, if so inclined can tilt an electoral landscape his way in innumerable ways. The President's unilateral composition of the Electoral Commission set the tone, even as recent murmurs about a plan for the mobilisation of the Provincial Administration and the police service, prove that this administration will not be coy about strong-arming those opposed to them if the need arises.

odm.jpgPresident Kibaki also enjoys the advantage of incumbency during a period of economic growth and political stability. If the current headlines, rumours of assassination plots, harassment of journalists, land clashes, crime waves and widespread poverty are brushed under the carpet; and the resultant sunny day compared to the early 1990s one can see the picture that inspires the writing of Kibaki's campaign prospectus. Consider also the generally bullish performance of the Nairobi Stock Exchange, the reality of a Revenue Authority whose coffers are sagging under the weight of an unprecedented tax loot, an improved agricultural economy and a gleeful business community; and you could be beguiled into thinking Kenyans have had a good old time these last five years.

To give an incumbent credit for reforms and improvements he was only completing or for the outcomes of policies that precede him is perhaps the practice throughout the world of voting nations. In our particular case, it is also incredibly irresponsible, for it forgives and blesses the lackadaisical manner in which the country has been run since 2002. This laidback style, would be permissible if our President were merely Head of State or if we were a state coasting along nicely to utopia. Neither of these is true with regard to Kenya, we are instead a nation struggling to get up on knees raw with the wounding of 40 years of economic and political catastrophe.

While our situation demands visionary and determined leadership to marshal the collective will in a progressive direction, we have had in the last four years, a first hand case study of how a chief executive thrust effortlessly into power against the whims of common sense can sit on his hands. Historical nicknames aside, the President has abdicated his duties as Kenya has craved leadership on a new all-encompassing constitution, East African Federation, the conflict in Somalia, the land time-bomb and related clashes in Mt. Elgon, Turkana, West Pokot, Mau and Tana River among innumerable other situations.

It is true that this determined strategy to do nothing has often been temporarily shelved, but even then merely to purvey the most obtrusive discrimination, of a kind unrivalled since the 1970s. Where the nation sought healing from political oppression of 40 years, it has received in its stead a perpetuation, even an extension of the nepotistic corruption that has created a greatly polarized Kenyan society.

Clement weather, investor goodwill, a surge in remittances, divestments of state stakes and a healing from the trauma inflicted by the Economic Structural Adjustment Programmes flatter the present view of the economy, but as the effect of these boons wear away, it is vital that Kenya embark on a programme of radical reform in anticipation of the future.

An economy built on agriculture will not achieve the growth figures that will lift Kenyans out of poverty, and neither will temporary infusions of finances into the public coffers from taxes or the sale of public assets. Absent a total revolution of our economy, economic growth will slide up and down as the world economy favors, with an ever increasing class of poor Kenyans.

Understandably perhaps, the spectre of an ODM-K presidency sends many into a panic; but this must not preclude the appreciation of the fact that Mwai Kibaki's Presidency has been a sad failure. Promising much and delivering very little, it has not served in any way to sort out our deepest structural problems, nor provided the guidance and impetus to guide our economy and national outlook in any way fundamentally different from what prevailed since the late 1990s. I will not waste my vote, I will make sense of my ritual, I will not vote Kibaki.


Stephen Wanyama
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (16)add
0
Applause
written by aeichener , April 25, 2007
An excellently written, powerful piece. Polished English, astute perception and analysis. And a good sense of colour distribution, my compliments.

Usualy I do not like the empty politicking that Kenyans so delight and excel in, in lieu of treating real issues. But your article is an exception. You should at all means submit it to the Guardian or the Financial Times for re-publication; it would be excellent for foreign readers.

So what will you do when election time comes? Abstain, likely?

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
I won\'t either, but...
written by pndiangui , April 25, 2007
I might not vote for Kibaki either, but I don't see what different you propose that could have been done. Yapping around without providing different and solid proposals which can be realistically executed, is itself a lazy behaviour.

Much as Kibaki has had his grave failures, I have seen some shifting of policy towards making Kenya competitive. When some of his strong policy points start being felt, if implemented sustainably, they will have significant positive effects. Some of those include areas that few have really bothered to analyse critically before giving credit or demonising them. Examples would be found in Energy, Banking, Education and Telcommunications.

It's naive to think that we can shift the Kenyan agro-based-economy in a 5 year period. What will those farmers do? Where would the money to invest in other production be coming from? It's not only sensible but imperative to create cash-flows with the asset at hand while using that cash-flow to diversify the economy. A farmer may have been delivering milk or coffee or sugarcane for the last 30 years; to make him shift his centre of activity to become a service worker would cost more than optimizing the farmer's output and strengthening his markets by forming avenues in the value-chain that enable value-addition to put more cash in his/her pocket. And that's exactly what I have witnessed with the cooperatives' revival. Do I credit Kibaki for this ? Yes because the previous regime had actually killed those value addition service providers.

And in fact New Zealand is still partly an agro-economy but it has one of the best per-capita GDP globally. It has been using its agro-economy cash-flows to diversify its economy without disrupting the quality of life of its farming population. There are a myriad opportunities that the agro-industries in Kenya can exploit even in the COMESA region alone, first through an optimized cooperative movement. The climatic conditions in most parts of Kenya are a core competitive advantage; so it would be foolish not to exploit the already existing systems to turn the economy around and give it a life, before investing the collected tax and income in newer means of production such as a fibre optics network, rehabiliation of dilapidated infrastructure, diversifying tourism etc. etc.

Many have cited India as an example of a service economy in the making; but may I remind those, that India's IT workers dont even make 3% of the Indian labour market?

Stephen, I wish you would be more specific as to your desired 'fundamental shift' of policies.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
rabble rouser
written by Kamau , April 25, 2007
It is our civic duty to register our opinion with our vote. What are our alternatives? why are alternatives better than the Kibaki regime?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Timothy Wainaina , April 25, 2007
Everyone and their uncle knows that Kibaki is not a good President, not even by half; but he is the best alternative that we have. So I will on my part, vote KIBAKI!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kibaki should just call it a d
written by Job , April 25, 2007
There isn't much more the 76 year old Kibaki has to offer than he has already done. He has done his best (he will be remembered for some good efforts in FPE and tax collection) but unfortunately Kenyans had much higher expectations of him.

It's simply time for the septuagenarians and octagenarians to call it quits and enjoy the rest of their sunset years in retirement.

Fundamental changes are needed with respect to security, devolution, corruption, tribalism, equitable distribution of resources and power, rural development, landlessness, and respect for the law.

Let's just face it, these are all areas Kibaki has failed in. The current waves of civilian massacres in Mt. Elgon, Saboti, Banana by armed outfits including Mungiki exposes the state of denial this government suffers from. Not even recognizing the magnitude of insecurity and terror.

Kibaki showed where his heart rests regarding devolution and equitable sharing of national resources during the referendum and Katiba fiasco. He need not speaketh more on it.

Truth be said, the ultra-skewed display of ethnic favouritism and nepotism in effecting public appointments has left a sour taste within souls of most Kenyans outside the Mt. Kenya enclave while Kibaki and many of his supporters have maintained an insensitive and arrogant "Mtafanya- nini-attitude".

The failure to prosecute Goldenberg masterminds and the emergence of sh 50 billion-plus Anglo-Leasing and other procurement scandals, sh18 billion Nakumatt-Charterhouse tax evasion and money laundering that led Uchumi to shut it's doors, has defined a new level of grand and rapid corruption which according to John Githongo, has cost our exchequer close to sh 200 billion.

On failure to respect the law, the Artur mercenary saga offered us a glimpse of the dirty side of Kibaki's regime. His very own Internal Security Minister John Michuki acknowledged breaking the law while raiding (in snake-bite fashion) The Standard and KTN premises. The regalia found in the Artur Runda residence including Asst. Police Commissioner badges, stolen vehicles, under-cover CID vehicle plates, masks, AK-47's and other arms was indeed revealing.

The attempted breach of EALA rules while appointing EAC legislators just shows the impunity with which Kibaki is willing to risk exporting bad politics outside Kenya.

The premise that Kibaki is the best alternative is indeed only laughable. Millions of able Kenyans are definitely better than Kibaki any day. The ballot box will surely sort this out in a few months. Like Wanyama, I can't throw away my vote to Kibaki. That will be lending victory to tribalism, corruption, insecurity and lawlessness.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kibaki Has My Vote
written by J Otero , April 25, 2007
I will definitely vote for Kibaki. I think he has done a good job under the circumstances.

Kibaki inherited a country with grave problems a free falling economy, runaway insecurity, simmering ethnic feuds a bloated corrupt and demoralized civil service an underpaid ill-equipped and thoroughly corrupt police force, an embargo on lending and aid by development partners, stalled projects tattered roads collapsed agriculture and a dying tourism industry.

In evaluating Kibaki we must look at what he has done with respect to each of these challenges has he made progress .

The deterioration of the economy has been reversed and we are seeing positive growth this is no mean feat.

Insecurity remains a challenge especially in certain pockets but there has been tremendous progress on that front too as compared to when Kibaki came into power.

The police are much better equipped, better paid, better housed, less corrupt and have better morale.

Cycles of violence started in the Moi era are continuing in certain parts but such conflicts are notoriously hard to stop in Ireland they went on for decades. In the US the battle against the Mafia took two decades and they still exist. So progress on this fronts must be put in perspective. We cannot simply fault Kibaki for not eliminating conflicts and armed gangs in 4 years.

The civil service has been trimmed and the terms of service improved. The results can be seen in the much improved service delivery by all government departments especially the KRA which now collects enough revenue to fund 95% of government expenditure up from about 50% in 2002.

Education has seen a huge government push , free primary education promises a brighter future for millions of Kenyan kids. Secondary and tertiary learning institutions have all received attention and funding and the education system in Kenya is back on track.

In agriculture immense strides have been made. Agricultural extension services are back. KCC,KMC and other organizations vital to the farmers have been resurrected. Agriculture is on the mend a great job by the government.

Road repair and construction is proceeding at a tremendous pace. Stalled projects have been revived and completed. Nairobi is clean and safe to walk again the airport is undergoing a major expansion and overhaul.

In tourism hotels which had closed and let workers go have reopened and are hiring. The tourism industry is booming. The NSE is booming Kenyans are now investing in securities. Kibaki has done a tremendous job.

The tribalism charge against Kibaki is I think bogus. Kibaki cannot be held responsible for the tribalism in peoples hearts. The bogus charges on skewed appointments have been addressed the government recently tabled in parliament a full list of government employees their positions and ethnicity. This is the truth that will lance the boil of tribalism inspired opposition campaigns. Next time we are lied to that 70% of DC's are Kikuyus one can simply refer to that list and easily disprove the lies.

The Aturs are a sideshow best left to tabloids like the standard and other "enquiring minds"

Instead we should focus on debating and implementing development plans like those in Kibaki's vision 2030. While this is not a radical vision it is the best plan I've seen so far.

I have read a lot about the necessity for radical change but no actual suggestions of what the radical change should be. I suspect it is just hot air from people who have no serious policy proposals. Let us see some of this radical proposals that will save us and transform our country.

For example we hear a lot about equitable distribution of resources what exactly does this mean and what resources are we talking about. There is the suggestion that government jobs should be distributed according to regional equity. My problem with this is that we should employ people on merit and their ability to do the job not according to some ethnic balancing formula. We would never dream of using equity to balance say our Olympic athletics teams because there are too many Kalenjins.

Also are the resources to be balanced taxes in which case will the be distributed equally across the board by constituency or per capita or per square foot? Also will we have equity in contribution or only in distribution?


We have many basically ridiculous and tribalistic ideas being propagated and passed off as wisdom. Kibaki avoids all such unproductive gossip and focuses on development. That is why he has my vote and support.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
rabble rouser
written by kamau , April 25, 2007
I don’t think you will not get an honest argument about the failures of the Kibaki administration with its old school way of thinking and doing things. We all agree for the need to usher in a new form of government etc.

We can not however, call for a change and not supply alternatives. The current viable alternative the ODM with six months to the election has failed to provide a cohesive alternative that addresses what really ails the country. They have however given us their power sharing plan that is both unconstitutional and undemocratic.

Kenya will have to face the fact that we have failed to give “fringe” candidates a chance and continue to support the same old recycled KANU thugs. We must therefore have to choose the lesser of two evils, depending on ones viewpoint that lesser evil could be the ODM or 5 more years of Kibaki.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Great Work!!
written by Samuel Mbwana , April 25, 2007
While our situation demands visionary and determined leadership to marshal the collective will in a progressive direction, we have had in the last four years, a first hand case study of how a chief executive thrust effortlessly into power against the whims of common sense can sit on his hands.


This is exactly why Kibaki is such a failure. He did not really want to be President, he was thrust on to the national stage by Tosha and the fact that there was no other Gikuyu to take his place. That we must be led by an old man suffering a stroke, who even if he willed it is rendered incapable of focus and sustained effort by age and poor health is a big lie. We can do much better!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Specific alternatives
written by pndiangui , April 25, 2007
Job
How far do you want develution and why do you think it will make a differrence?

Tell us how long you would think it might take to restore lawsness if you were to be the president.

And tell us how long you think it would take you to eliminate or reduce corruption if you were Kenya's CEO, and how you would do it .

Go for it in full.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
What do you mean, aeichener?
written by Juma , April 25, 2007
Polished English, astute perception and analysis.

Are you saying it's unusual for the Kenyans to write in "Polished English?" If you are, were in trouble.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: What do you mean, aeichene
written by aeichener , April 25, 2007

Are you saying it's unusual for the Kenyans to write in "Polished English?"

Yes.
If you are, we're in trouble.

Yes you are.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
one term president.
written by xo , April 27, 2007
Throughout the ordeal that kibaki has put us through! wait a minute, I have to throw up. I am back nauseated, Kibaki must have under-estimated the intelligence of kenyans. The plain un-intelligent strategies used by this government are at par with those of a monkey with police protection. I don't need to talk anymore about this thief and his coper [edited by MOD] , he has to go.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kibaki\'s stealth
written by yoyo , May 02, 2007
Kibaki called Kenyans Pumbafu and we called him pumbafu over and over again. Kibaki totally under-estimates this electorate who have been taught well by kenyans in the diaspora, through their families who have neighbors and friends that also have other neighbors and many more friends. Kibaki is killing innocent citizens in mt Elgon in the name of an ancient strategy that goes like this, "Beat the grass to startle the snakes or stir the water to catch the fish". This is a very effective strategy that pulls all Kenyans into the mt Elgon myhem and chaos, leaving the entire country and it's people wondering where or who will be the next victim. To tell you the truth, the entire kenyan community is fully intimidated, including the know it all diaspora with their so called deep pockets.Here is the trick, As you ponder where or who will be next, The mount Kenya mafia will give you a little token (Free secondary education), which will be more appreciated and exaggerated than without chaos.Kenyans will just say, Kumbe the jambazi has some heart! he must not be the one doing it, then the illiterate voters will sing his song and vote him back. Raila, you are acting a fool, back Kalonzo or you will be left with your empty shell (ODM).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nekessa , May 09, 2007
A few months ago, another Kenya Imagine writer told us why she would vote for Kibaki. Click here to read Doris Sadera's Kibaki: Still the Man.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , May 25, 2007
just a thought, in the last 30 years no african country has made any impact in reducing poverty, even the ones that are well governed e.g senegal, ghana. this is opposed to countries in far east. is there something intrinsic in africa that make us poor?
back to the point of discussion, kibaki was a mistake from day one, majority of people in 2002 were not voting for him but against moi (who was not in the ballot paper). it now take many years of the kind of antagonism that has taken root during the kibaki time. Come next year when raila is the president, and the same political shenenagan will be directed to him. i dont see him making any significance difference in the way kenya is managed. to make things worse, people will demand more of him than they are demanding kibaki, and offcourse he will not deliver, not becuase he is not able but simply its africa and we are condemned to poverty eternity.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
LET DEVOLUTION EMPOWER OUR DEV
written by millicent liani , November 28, 2007
so many kenyans especially the GEMA group are against majimbo. do they know its definition and could they please define development at their personal level? Look at the mps in the cabinet and how many of them have valid job descriptions for an mp.others are even IT illiterate yet they are claimimg to be on the ladder towards development.for good governance, let us vote the best mps we think are developmental and let each of them write his/her job description for us as kenyan citizens to evaluate their competence.i know only the learned youths and few others understand what majimbo means. please empower our old illiterates like kalembe ndile, john michuki e.t.c coz they are growing dumb and blind: very soon they will be going naked."please lets save them n kenya as country of our own".
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 25 April 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company

Buy Cheap Software Corel Home Office 5.0 Multilingual Corel WordPerfect Office 2002 Professional Edition