Home
Corruption and journalism PDF Print E-mail
Written by Rebecca Wanjiku   
Thursday, 09 August 2007

Recently, I received an SMS with advice for a fellow journalist. In it was the simple advice,“ go to hell”. Many Kenyans it seems bear similar sentiments towards journalists.

Thursday, 09 August 2007 Recently, I received an SMS with advice for a fellow journalist. In it was the simple advice, "go to hell". Many Kenyans it seems bear similar sentiments towards journalists.
I was offended because I expected more from my SMSing friend, a lawyer I had grown to respect. I had thought he had better sense than to throw mud on everyone he happened to disagree with. He in turn complained of bad faith and malice, as demonstrated by a cartoon in the newspaper he was angry about. But the core of his complaint was what he described as chronic corruption within journalism. He said that the very journalists, who write or publish the most strident criticisms with the one hand, are very busy reaching out with the other, for handouts.

There's an old saying, one that has been told over and over for generations. Even the meanest of characters, he who cannot afford to buy anybody a drink, will find a cause to shout himself hoarse when speaking about corrupt journalists. I am not overly impartial in this being a practising journalist myself, but my opinion has always been- it takes two to be corrupt. Can anyone who gives money or other favors to journalists claim to be righteous?

The main question: do the journalists hold a gun to anyone demanding money? This question was underscored by the Members of Parliament who claimed the only reason for passing the Media Bill is because the journalists are corrupt and subsist on hand outs.

They argue that it is fair to pass the controversial media bill that will force journalists to reveal sources," because journalists are corrupt". It was even said that journalists are always seen walking to Parliament. How right! The question of corruption is controversial, as the press is often the last frontier between the public and their increasingly wayward leaders. It is the Fourth Estate that unleashes the news on scandals that brings down reputations and ends the careers of irresponsible leaders.

One does understand that there are often grounds for disagreeing with journalists, or the portrayal of oneself in the media. It is for that reason that our already extant laws are in place, and politicians, much like anyone else will appreciate that they can get redress from the courts, or even by complaining directly to the media houses, demanding their right of reply, corrections or even retractions and apologies. We needn't make enemies of the press; they are often our greatest guardians.

 


Rebecca Wanjiku
About the author:
Rebecca Wanjiku is a Kenyan journalist and entrpreneur. She writes on technology and media issues and publishes the BeckyIT blog.




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (21)add
0
lawyers....well well
written by Nowa Indania , August 09, 2007
I understand what you mean Rebecca. You have defended your corner very well. I think all this is just a smoke screen as they seek to see this contoversial media bill enacted.

I hope that you are not too surprised by the venom displayed by this "lawyer" There are very many good and honest lawyers in Kenya but sadly there are even more corrupt and evil ones who rob wananchi of monies entrusted to their care, who collude with criminals and corrupt cops to frustrate justice..who have assisted murderers and rapists to evade justice..so many evils that lawyers practice.....A free media, unshackled from the proposed bill would make life pretty difficult for these crooks too.

Lawyers, estate agents and politicians: apparently there is no room for them in heaven
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Amir Ibrahim , August 09, 2007
I would still say that I'd much rather have the powerful and wealthy suffer the inconvenience of being accused of drinking chai with Kibaki when they did not, or soliciting on K street when they did not, than have any attempts at muzzling the Press.

And why are Kenyan journalists so poorly educated, so poorly read? What do they do at journalism school? They have near zero knowledge of history, culture, philosophy or the art of government. What on earth do they do in those schools of theirs? There's much more intelligence on your average three-bit forum than there is in the good newspapers of the Jamhuri. They do not even have the sense to attend demos in their own favour!

Nowa,
I went to heaven, and met many journalists there. Apparently all the good ones are dead.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: lawyers....well well
written by aeichener , August 09, 2007
Lawyers, estate agents and politicians: apparently there is no room for them in heaven


No room in hell either. All filled up with Kenyan judges.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Marangu , August 09, 2007
I would hesitate to make sweeping statements about the quality of Kenyan Journals, I don't suffer short term memory, and a good number I have read are better than any, anywhere. There are a few among them who have fallen to the usual social ills of corruption, lack of indipendence in their reporting and commentry. These are not vices peculiar to journalists, you will find them in any professional body, everywhere in the world. But to paint Kenyan journals with the same brush, especially with little factual, supporting evidence is to say the very least, irresponsible.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Marangu , August 09, 2007
Now, are there bad Kenyan Judges? Many probably, and if Alex bothers to walk accross to heaven, he might find a good number there, unless they have not made the trip yet.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Amir Ibrahim , August 09, 2007
Marangu,
On the contrary there is a lot of evidence. Pick up any Kenyan paper today. While it is true that generalisations are often wrong, there are few Kenyan journalists worth their weight in salt.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by aeichener , August 09, 2007
AI:

1. Marangu spoke about Kenyan journals, you about Kenyan newspapers. That explains the difference in your assessments (at least in my English dictionary).

2. I am more charitable with Kenyan journalists than you. I do however loathe Kenyan editors. As soon as they turn editors, they turn bad and throw quality out of the window. KenyaImagine itself is only one more example in an endless list.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by vivid , August 09, 2007
Democracy can't work well unless people are educated about the important issues. You journalists just need to keep doing your jobs, educate the rest of us, and all will be well.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Clarification
written by Miss H. , August 09, 2007
What are we talking about? Journals or journalists! Rebecca, have you graduated from the school of journalism yet? Journalism needs passion, and a gift of gab, it is not just for anyone who can scribble or has a keyboard.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Sorry Bex
written by Miss H. , August 09, 2007
I have visited her blog and noticed that it has very well written pieces. Brings me to the editors at KI. I am not going to sugarcoat it for you, because I beleive you can do better. It is terrible when you take someones piece, cheapen it, and put it out here.
Bad grammar and all, generally poor editing! Becky's article is fabulously put on her blog, you mess it and drop it here!

You need better editors! Or better training for the ones you have! Or offload the article as is. After all, it is still reamins Becky's.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by editor , August 09, 2007
Well, Honey, so be it. We will continue to improve all the work that comes our way, including yours for clarity, grammar, punctuation and so on. When we receive responsible complaints, we will deal with those. Notorious vandals will be treated likewise.

Having looked over the article in this particular case, and comparing it to the source, and speaking with the author, I am sure it has been improved.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
No Offense Mr. Opoti
written by Miss H. , August 10, 2007
I apologize for loosing the address to your offices, for I intended to complain 'professionally'.

I simply found the original piece to be better 'cuisine' than this edited one.
What I did not understand was the need to edit it, when the same author is recognized.

While I appreciate your hard work, I demand quality all the time. No slacking.
And you know it is not out of malice that I raise my objection to the quality of editing. I have no problem having m work edited, factually put, I wish I could put in mnemonics so you and your team work on it.

Let history show that a good job is appreciated, a bad one must be pointed out!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re:
written by aeichener , August 10, 2007
When we receive responsible complaints, we will deal with those.


Untrue, Emmo.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
in reply
written by emmo opoti , August 10, 2007
Alexander, you have never put in a reasonable complaint, not once. Instead you saw fit to very publicly insult and humiliate three of our writers. Your campaign of irresponsible vigilantism, crude language and racism is what got you out of KenyaImagine, and for that we can be justly proud.

See Leso Munala, David Maathai, Dan Teng'o and others like Kamale who have severally pointed out just how irresponsibly you carried out your duties.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Sheesh
written by CHUTI , August 10, 2007
Here are the facts:

1. Editing/writing for KI is not exactly equivalent to hitting a jackpot. It is at will, and peeps are free to leave anytime.

2. Opoti needs to rise above petty squabbling, and even so publicly. Leave that to readers and writers.

3.There is something wrong with grown folks getting offended by people they have no relations with nor met.
Worse, to expect that their sentiments will be accepted by all. Good Lord, never allow that to happen to me, for it is that day that I will commit myself in an institute.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kenyan Media a disappointment
written by Man R , August 10, 2007
Hire me and I'll edit stuff for you here ASAP. There are typos all over these pieces and even in comments from people complaining how KI sucks. I mean, the title of this thread has a typo; it's corruption with two ‘r’ not three ‘r.’
About corruption among Kenyan journalists--it's bad. I'm a journalist based in the U.S. and I have to say I’m embarrassed to admit I share a profession with some of those people... They're in politicians' pockets; I have witnessed journalists asking politicians to give them kitu kidogo and others, especially from the smaller papers, following politicians like a bunch of hungry hyenas. A lot of them are compromised and cannot be trusted to write an objective story on any subject.
The Kenyan journalism market doesn’t seem to have a system of checks and balances. Journalists in Kenya have distorted the line between their role as objective peoples’ watchdog and that of activists. A lot of journalist don't get facts right-- an example is when the Kenyan media reported that Raila's Hummer is worth Kshs 40 million (Approx. $450,000), and nobody seems to really care. I read a commentary in The EA Standard where the writer confused the Hummer (vehicle) and hammer (Tool) throughout the article. The saddest part is I never saw a correction in the subsequent issues of the paper. It boggles my mind how such a factual errors and mistakes get past editors.
Another thing that ticks me off about the Kenyan media is when they hide facts from readers. Two examples-- "The Bull of Auckland" story and K-street scandal involving MPs -- why did the media have to withhold the names of the people involved when it was obvious they had the information? Who is the media protecting in such cases and why?
I haven't had the time to read up on what the government is up to with the media bill, but the Kenyan media has brought this unto itself because of its unethical behavior on the job. Journalism is a profession of passion; you don’t become a journalist just because your ambition to become a priest got frustrated. You become a journalist because you believe in the need for a society to be empowered and informed. Kenyan journalists have to start behaving themselves.
Kenya has one of the liveliest media environments in the world, it's a shame that some journalists don't seem to know what that means.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
getting facts right
written by bex , August 10, 2007
i am so saddened that you complain about journalists not getting their facts right yet you demonstrate the same in your comment,
first it is ignorant of you to think the K street story was all about covering up, there are legal implications, read section 36 of the judicature act very well.
it also seems you have not been following up about subsequent libel suits filed by Kiunjuri and Makwere,
in as ,much as you never got the hint of who it was, it seems everyone else did.

i am not going to go on the defensive about kenyan journalism only ask why you have chosen to go practice in the US and not show the way in kenya.

we need people like you who have the passion and can show the crappy lot the way to do it.

while your opinion is appreciated, please read and understand joirnalism in kenya,
i can do a piece and give the grim realities, there are so many fallacies!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Quis ipsos custodiet custodes?
written by aeichener , August 10, 2007
In numerous countries, journalists see themselves as (and indeed are) the watchdog of the people.

In Kenya however, the People must be the watchdog of journalists.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , August 10, 2007
Kamale made this point too (about the unnamed parties in a Bill) in the other thread about the Media Bill. I do not see that the harm caused by a media piece that merely implies something or the other about a Prominent Minister's son is cause to change our laws.
Public life demands a thick skin( you have to deal with accusations and attempts to bring you into disrepute), and as Becky says it is very clear that the newspaper houses will pay dearly- have paid dearly- for coming out and actually naming people. An editor does not make a story less clear than he could for nothing. These decisions are usually made by the higher-ups and the legal departments, because they know what the cost of putting in the names would be.

There's another unmentioned factor here. There are far too few papers of national importance in Kenya. When the media is controlled by two or three people it is almost impossible to have it functioning as a check on the powers that be. There are stories which you will only ever be able to read in the yellow press
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Bex
written by Man R , August 10, 2007
I was just trying to illustrate the situation. Obviously I'm not 100 percent in touch with every little thing that happens in Kenya, but my point is the Kenyan media is corrupt and it needs to check itself.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
E.g.s of good journalists toda
written by Magothe , August 14, 2007
East Africa is full of good stories especially on Kenya and I think Jaindi Kisero has done an excellent job with it so far. Macharia Gaitho (Sunday Nation); Kiptanui (Standard) all do good pieces.
This clause in the bill is about GoK trying to control information flow.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Friday, 10 August 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company