purchase viagra onlinebuy CIALIS 20mgbuy cialis online
Home
The Case for a Military Draft in Kenya PDF Print E-mail
Written by Dave Nyambati   
Wednesday, 20 June 2007

With the proposed free high school education program, we are going to have more high-school educated people who cannot get a higher education nor find a good job.

These people will need to be occupied if Kenya is to avert its worsening security crisis.

In 2006, about a quarter of a million students sat for KCSE, and slightly less than 700,000 sat for KCPE. Assuming that the same number sit for KCPE in 2007, and with free secondary education 85% of them sit for KSCE, we are looking at 595,000 high school graduates in 2012 that will need to be accommodated. With an already saturated college scenario, we are potentially looking at several hundred thousand young people with a KCSE certificate and nowhere to go.

The current work force can only absorb so many high school graduates and the jua kali opportunities are limited. This could spiral into a situation where we have whole generations who feel disenfranchised and indifferent towards the idea of a common Kenyan brotherhood. The government has to find a way to turn these unaccommodated youth into responsible adults and upstanding citizens or risk loosing control of an already fragile situation with subversive ideologies like the Mungiki's taking hold.

This is why I think our politicians should consider implementing a national conscription program. This will instill a sense of national pride and responsibility towards our country and will help foster the kind of discipline and culture in our youth that will be antithetical to corruption and tribalism.

The mandatory draft should include high school graduates over the age of 18 with a cut off age of 21, for both males and females. Exceptions could be made for those who register in a college or institution of further learning within a year after high school completion and those who are incapable of serving for medical, physical or religious reasons or other substantial reasons. Conscription for this national service could be for a compulsory 2 years with an option for reenlistment at the time of completion for a total of 4 years. It could be converted to college credit or other useful commendations with enlistment being a prerequisite for getting a national ID before the age of 21.

Many countries today require mandatory service from their citizens at a specified age including Austria, Denmark, Egypt, Finland and Israel. There are many areas that a national guard service can be useful to the country. For example they could help build infrastructure like roads and bridges, help fight pollution and urban waste with reforestation and reclamation activities, assist in humanitarian aid in impoverished or natural disaster stricken areas, get involved in social outreach projects, the list is endless.

The draftees would be given military training but would not be required to get directly involved in combat or policing duties unless in an extreme situation like an attack from another country or a state of emergency. Most countries reserve the right to call up citizens to involuntary military labor in times of crises like the defense of sovereign soil. It is not far fetched to look at some of the ills currently affecting Kenya as direct attacks on Kenya's sovereignty, and a force such as this would be a great asset in 'defending' Kenya.

This group would strictly be a supplemental force that would compliment the security forces of Kenya but conduct some of the more socio-economical activities that government is responsible for. We would still retain professional armed forces with Army, Navy and Air Force divisions.

This is the duty of our generation in the twenty-first century, we have to find ways to resolve our complex issues and create the opportunity for a better life for our children. If we express the desire to collectively rise above our constraints then we could succeed in creating a society where members will define themselves not by their own identity but by that of others. It is our moral obligation to our young people that we give them a means of livelihood, and while a draft is not a permanent solution, it is a start.





Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (26)add
0
...
written by Kamale , June 20, 2007
One of the reasons most of the countries you mention have a compulsory draft is that they do not get enough people for recruitment. You do recall the US draft for the Vietnam war which was a response to people refusing to join the military. I had an interesting chat with some army recruiters in a street fair in Birmingham, UK some time back when I told them that in Kenya they keep away people that want to join the military unlike them who had to look for draftees in a market place!!

What we should be thinking about is whether we actually have sufficient enemies to warrant a huge force and if so, whether the men we have in arms today can defent this country. Alternatively, consideration should be given to the Spade Army (the NYS) to undergo the military training as a reserve force.

However if the issue is to inculcate patriotism and responsibility, then this should be included as part of teh education curriculum.

The danger with training every 18 year old in the country on how to use a firearm and at the same time on completion of the training fail to provide a job is that we shall have started a breeding ground of criminals who actually know how to use a gun!! The Finns and the Israelis ensure that the guys get jobs which something the Kenya government cannot!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
0
Yes! Good Idea!
written by Jayawardene , June 20, 2007
A very good read Dave. You have a brilliant idea. It is something many have proposed in the past. It seems that we have the means and the imagination, but the will is always lacking. I wonder whether politicians oppose it because it would open all our eyes?

Many countries have their own National Service schemes through which they address their own particular National objectives. It is fruitless therefore to compare Kenya's unique situation to that of Israel, Finland or any other country.

Dave shows how an organisation like this can be a useful framework in building a national identity amongst the youth as well as giving them an idea of the bigger picture, to counter the negative laager mentality of 'our people are being finished or it's our turn to eat' nonsense so cleverly propagated by tribal chief politicians.

The development potential that such a large organisation could give to the country is immense and Dave mentions the struggle against poverty and disease as two important wars that we can fight using such a force. He also sees the force as an agent to watch against environmental degradation, pollution and desertification.

Bw Kamale, Kenya's enemies may not be massed outside our borders planning to attack and occupy us. They are already amongst us and are highly operational. Today they come in many guises; tribalism, corruption, nepotism, HIV/Aids, malaria, malnutrition and other preventable childhood diseases and the ever-present severe food shortages.

It would be ideal if the education system was geared to work in the way that you say but reality is quite different. I went to a school where we did not have a single pupil who did not speak "my language". The morning assembly was coducted in a style that assumed we were all christians and we thought that Jomo was the king of Africa. I had never seen a malnourished child or known anyone with malaria. Dave's proposal is the only way that diverse young kenyans of all creeds from right across the country can have an opportunity to learn from one another.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
0
good argument
written by John Ongeri , June 20, 2007
Plaudits to the writer. I must ask him though: If this is such a good idea, how come we did not do it before?

Jayawardene seems to have grown up in the countryside. Most of your folk out there are ignorant of other parts of kenya. Travel will broaden your mind.

Kamale remember Wan Yu? was it not him who said a man with no enemies is only half a man? I read your final paragraph with something approaching horror....let me explain...Responsible use and proper care of firearms is something all kenyans should be taught. It is only through education and disciplined training that we can come to appreciate and respect firearms. Many people do not actually know what firearms are capable of. I would go so far as to say that given a choice It would be far better to be confronted by armed gangsters who actually knew how to handle guns......it is the panicky opportunistic thugs who usually shoot their victims.......
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Kamale , June 20, 2007
Unfortunately, there is evidence that quite a number of the gun totting gangsters in our midst are former security agents dismissed or even retired!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
myth buster
written by kamau , June 20, 2007
Where a government that can’t feed, cloth and educate its citizens get the money to fund such a lofty escapade?

Three words, National Youth service, what a fiasco!!

If unemployment rate reduction is the core of the issue that you are trying to address with this adventure; how about a much simpler plan? Instead of trying to use the government to create jobs, how about getting them out of the way of those that actually know how to create jobs and have a record of creating jobs; The private sector.

When has a third world government ever created meaning full and sustainable employment that did not revolve around a white elephant such as this?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Good Idea
written by Githush , June 20, 2007
A mandatory National Serives program would be a very good move. Service that includes military training (i do think we need to expand out armed forces, especially with the belligerents we've for neighbours and the increasing difficulty - as the FT pointed out - we find in staying above the regional fray). National Service would also include the "shovel brigades" mentioned by Kamale and possibly a lager "peace corp for Kenya" program that would focus on extending services - medical, educational etc - to the rural areas.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nekessa , June 20, 2007
Hmm, I actually thought this would garner more controversial discussion. Let us look at the current Kenyan army. What really does it do? Are not its roles some of what Dave proposes? Question is why are they not enforced?

If such an investment was to be made, then it would have to, as others have suggested, ensure jobs otherwise we will have to deal with the weapon that it has created.

However, like Kamale I am skeptical about training a whole generation of kids to "fight".
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Marangu , June 20, 2007
Dave:
Your approach is that of a pragmatist, someone emphathetic with the people on the ground who have no hope, for no foult of their own. While I would find it hard to justify the need of having larger, fuller barracks engaged in unproductive excercises, I fully uunderstand your point.
My take on this is a full review of how our armed forces operate, an acknowledgement of the fact that we have less enemies today and hence the need to scale down on war preparedness including expenditure on military hardware and training.
A reorientation of the current armed forces to Nation Building activities including road construction, agriculture, law enforcement and emergency response. Imagine what this could do to our flagging Police force, sharing the not so vast military resources would be the cure we need to rid ourselves of the rampant crime. If this happens, I would support a complete rollout of the recruitment excercise of our youngsters as Bw Nyambati suggests. It's a great idea.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
I talked about this before
written by al , June 20, 2007
I have actually mentioned this idea to my buddies manytimes.

I totally support such a move. First guys would get some professional training. They could include things like tuition reimbursement like here in US.
Not only military training why not expand the military but emphasize sciences like Engineering plus research and education in general. Let kids earn a salary when they enroll. After the mandatory reenlistment give them an option of extending their duty.

Let the Govt set up a fund lets say poverty reduction fund or industrialization fund and fund it for a trillion shillings over 30 yrs.

Let the govt fund research in all areas of science and even have our own secret projects. Fund research in telecomunications, Mechanical engineering, Aeronautics,Naval engineering.

I'm kinda for reinventing the wheel to some extent with some little copying and refining ideas that are already there because when you do things hands on you tend to learn better.Japan did this and look where they are now.
Our kids would then gain all sorts of expertise be engineers, Pilots, build their own tanks,weapons, build bridges, become doctors and lots more.

My thinking is this look at our folks man there's like 50% poverty man this is a huge crisis. It needs great thinking and a plan on a grand level like the (europe marshall plan) because only we ourselves will solve our problems.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
So dangerous as well as flatte
written by echwaluedward , June 20, 2007
The idea is very bright.I couldn`t agree less.However a lot of questions comes behind that plan..

Africans are very different from their western counterparts.While someone from Britain for example will see the need to have a gun to rob or do any ijustice to some else, a Kenyan will happliy do that.

In the West, every citizen atleast has government beneficiary when unemployed.I mean they can even survive for the coming decade without a job.Something which is not possible in Kenya and in Africa in General.

But i think its a very brilliant idea of keeping our jobless just over 18ns.Its a good thought all the same.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by aeichener , June 20, 2007
A very good discussion topic, and certainly apt to elicit an animated and reasoned debate.

One will readily recognize that the tendency of the answers will (and must) be heavily coloured by the collective historical experiences of one's present region of residence; contributors residing, working or studying in Germany and Russia probably will have a very different take on the value and (de)merit of an obligatory labour service (such as Reichsarbeitsdienst and Trud-Armee) from those whose countries never knew such an institution. Kenyans knew dire obligatory labour, but those under 90 years of age seem to have forgotten it :-(.

And those readers who have actually served in an armed force (like yours truly, who has worn the black beret and the pink pipings) will likely have a view different from the armchair generals ;-).

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by a guest , June 20, 2007
Yeah, then hay can go build for Budalang'i some real levees!
The mofoz be getting swept away each year!

Or they can surely construct Nairobi highways and by-ways...LOL..or even loan them out for a price!

Too many things to do with this bags of youth with military training and no one to kill!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
good idea
written by joe , June 20, 2007
i think what is needed is a set of voluntary national services that provide some kind of stipend. for exampel we can have national guard, police, reserves (recontsituted).for some thing similar to job corp,conservation corp and also perhaps an art corp, medical corp that allow any adult who is willing to work and is unemployed to serve the country and earn some wages. - i think at the same time this service should be limited to public works and perhaps agriculture so as not to affect the economy in negative ways.

i think when people talk of welfare in the US they think about foodstamps - but foodstamps is the lowest level of welfare - the syetm of welare includes things such as student loans, the national guard,publci housing that prrovide various opprtunities to give people a hand up
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Myth buster
written by kamau , June 20, 2007
A case for a Military Draft in Kenya It’s not only a very silly idea but emblematic of the tendency African intellectuals to prescribe western social constructs and institutions to African problems.

Quite simply, where will the money to fund such a colossal white elephant come from?

This might make sense in the west where there are resources to fund such lofty ideas. What of Kenya where the resources have to be created first before we can come up with “ingenious” methods to distribute them?

Large militaries and pseudo tools of colonization like the “peace” corps are for countries with imperialistic desires and ideas. Are we suggesting that Kenya embarks on such endeavors? Should we not spend the money of things that will result in creating real jobs like education and health programs and reduce corruption which is the biggest impediment to job creation in Kenya?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
0
...
written by a guest , June 21, 2007
I partly agree with Kamau, the idea is too ambitious even for one who abores idleness like myself

Although Mr. Kamau, when u talk of resources have to be created, I smell a strong trait of Africa and its people: They are waiting for someone to create resources...fat chance, we will wait for eons to come. Ask not how much the govt will contribute, but what u will contribute!
Half the progress out here does not start with money, someone just decides that I will sit here and make cool-aid for passers by, small scale, once people realize a good cause, they will join hands.

As for Joe and welfare: Wrong, the only welfare that does not come with a tag is the food stamps.

Student loans, huh! Six months after school, one must pay. D'u wonder why some kids refuse to graduate? Because they borrowed so much, the interest is so high, with a job that begins paying $12/hr, they have long to pay off the loans.

I just relized`there are seldom free items in this country. The rich give to get a break from taxes and a good name.

Talk of giving people credit, and priority in job places....maybe that might fly!

Too many trained bags of youth, no oe to kill!

Good chance of increasing Mungiki members!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
0
response
written by Dave Nyambati , June 21, 2007
The primary function of this national service would not be civil defense but national development so it is not about how many enemies we have. It is about giving people a chance to do something meaningful with their lives while earning a little money.

Several people have argued that teaching these youth how to operate arms is tantamount to creating a breeding ground for criminals. The logic to this is that they still will not have jobs upon completion of duty and their knowledge of guns would be incentive for them to turn into violent thugs. Using a gun is nothing complicated, it is a simple matter of point and pull the trigger that is why you hear reports such as a 7yr old shooting his friend. Anyone with a desire to would learn how to operate a gun could do so with minimum effort.

The military teaches several things; discipline, honor and patriotism as well as the proper use of a fire arm. It teaches you to be ready to sacrifice your life to save the life of a stranger who just happens to have been born in the same country as you. Once these tenets are instilled in a person’s character, I doubt they would easily be compromised. It is not about training a ‘whole generation to fight’ – leave them out of the system and they will learn to fight their way in to the systems peril.

As far as funding goes, The Nation just reported that the government lost Shs. 660,000,000 because it did not tax MPs. Then there is the Shs. 1 billion Kibaki Youth Enterprise Development Fund. There is a lot of mismanaged revenue that the government could put toward worthy projects. Some of this revenue could be used to fund the national service program which would in turn work on projects that cycle revenue back to the government, either directly or indirectly. To do things like improve the infrastructure is to directly positively impact the economy. Also the security climate has a very large tangible financial value. If the government would truly commit, it would find the money the project needs. Just because its never been done is no reason to not do it, do we have to follow always?

Kamau termed this a ‘western idea’ and chastised ‘the tendency African intellectuals to prescribe western constructs to African problems’ – I do not get it. You mean western like a navy or an air force? Or is it more like a modern medicine western – you know laser surgeries and the like? Or maybe it is simply western like English? Problem like poverty, diseases, nepotism and corruption do not only afflict Africans, they are universal.

Remember, this is not intended to be a final solution to unemployment, but a band-aid while we seek to open up the private sector and improve economy in order to create jobs.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
0
response to Bw Nyambati
written by Nekessa , June 21, 2007
Anyone with a desire to would learn how to operate a gun could do so with minimum effort.
You must admit that a military trained frustrated individual is very different from a 7yr old shooting his friend by accident.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by cindy , June 21, 2007
in Fiji they let the UK military recruit jobless Fijians.

maybe a similar thing could work in Kenya
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
draftresistance.org
written by Scott Kohlhaas , June 21, 2007
Hello.

This proposal is insane. It is the worst piece of social engineering I can imagine. Slavery for the surplus students??--hogwash!

Would you be willing to spread the word about www.draftresistance.org? It's a site dedicated to shattering the myths surrounding the selective slavery system and building mass civil disobedience to stop the draft before it starts.

Our banner on a website, printing and posting the anti-draft flyer or just telling friends would help.

Thanks!

Scott Kohlhaas

PS. If the USA wandered into a draft like this it would be used for the most violent ends imaginable.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
0
Myth buster
written by Kamau , June 21, 2007
Nyambati,

This is a case where the cure is worse than the disease.

First off we should dispel of the notion that employment is more important than productivity. Think of our bloated civil service and its poor delivery record, yet you are basically proposing at multiplying it to deliver what? Roads, hospitals or busy work for the youth? Is the government in the business of keeping idle youth busy or delivering roads, schools and hospitals?

A dual carriage way linking Mombasa to Nairobi will do more for the economy that than giving several thousands youths drill instructions. Even if the youth we asked to build the road, from a cost, quality and delivery perspective who would give the government a bigger bang for its back a specialized mechanized construction company or untrained youth with shovels? If we are really interested in keeping the youth busy they should use spoons not shovels that way we would need use of them.

This is the kind of mindless western social engineering that African intellectuals learn in western universities and then try to pug in places like Kenya
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
0
re:
written by Kamale , June 22, 2007
in Fiji they let the UK military recruit jobless Fijians.

maybe a similar thing could work in Kenya


You will be happy to also know that there are Kenyans that enlist with the British Army. A silly arrangement where you are on your own for a 6 month period as they evaluate you before finally taking you into the military......and perhaps straight out to Iraq!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by kendirangu , June 22, 2007
I watched one documentary on the French foreign legion.
The main agenda is to go to war with all the risks knowing that if any men are lost, they wont be frenchmen.
Sounded to me like sending slaves to fight your wars for you.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
0
draft will be good
written by mogiyusuf , June 22, 2007
I think the idea is a noble idea that should be considered along with changes into the army's constitutional responsibility within the boundaries of kenya .Specialised training can help kenya as we move towards development .examples of the army core of engineers in the states is a good example of what military training can help in achieving drafted cadets can learn civil engineering skills that can be implemented to build dams,roads and other facilities i think its a brilliant idea that should be examined and modalities worked out. besides with neighbours such as sudan and ethiopia with large armies we must think long term .the us army and the isreali defence forces have shown that armies can do alot and not just in defence and fighting but in recontruction and development
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Good Thinking
written by Mark Nyoike , July 05, 2007
I think the reader has a very valid arguement. As mentioned above there is opposition to the idea by example of Finland and Israel not having enough troops, and the US during the Vietnam war instituting a draft to increase military strength. There is also a positive case in point that we can consider. During the great depression in the United States, Franklin D Roosevelt deemed it necessary to create an institution known as the Job Corps. This institution was charged with the responsiblity of creating work for millions of disenchanted youth during a time of great economic adversity. There duties were and not included to tree planting, road construction, and the construction of other public amenities necessary for economic recovery. The same could be said of Kenya, we are at a critical stage of economic developement and the fact that not all of our youth can find jobs should be of major concern to planners. The outcome of the Job Corps in the U.S. was highly successful and contributed enormously to U.S. economic recovery. From a socio-economic perspective we cannot have millions of youth left to wonder the barren lands of Kenya's current economic situation. The impact of which would be detrimental to our nations security and inevitably our prospects for economic progress.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
draftresistance.org
written by Scott Kohlhaas , July 14, 2007
Hi Mark!

Actually, I think what you are talking about is CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps).

I will tell you now that CCC was administered by the US Army. It was invaluable training for them because they brought in millions of men a few short years later in the first peacetime draft in US history in 1940.

I know your heart is in the right place, Mark, but using force will never to achieve your political goals simply will not work--it will only end in more violence.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
too late
written by Jayawardene , July 14, 2007
From the outset it was clear that many thought Dave Nyambati's idea wonderful.

Mister Ongeri posed a useful question when he said: .."If this is such a good idea, how come we didna do it before?"

I think the answer is to be found right here in the comments from honourable readers.

Those with negative sentiments fit neatly into 2 groups saying ati:

(i) Do not train 18 year olds to handle weapons as they will turn on us after their National service is over. Are we to be killed in our beds...Mr Bennett?......A similar circular argument rears it's head whenever social workers propose giving condoms to sexually active teenagers....oh no! we are encouraging promiscuity....hand wringing, etc etc so nothing gets done and the answer increased HIV infections and unwanted pregnancies....

(ii)We cannot afford the scheme. Where will money come from. We are taxed enough as it is. This comes as we watch our Mps taking home six-figure sums to sleep in Kaparo's chamber...hahah

Is there perhaps an argument that many well-educated, better off middle-class urban types cannot really envision and appreciate the benefits that Dave's scheme would offer to unemployed youth the length and breadth of our country?

It is unfortunate indeed that these people are the opinion formers, the so called movers and shakers, the people in the know and they form the constituency that the GOK Listens to. They can stand in the way of any radical reforms that would benefit the whole of Kenya .

I have heard that they stand in the way whenever reformers call for "opportunity for the many, not just the few".......

Now ....even as we write....There is a small body that recruits unemployed(and employed) youth into it's ranks. It promises them a sense of self-worth and dignity. It promises security from lawlessness and a society that is built on traditional and Christian beliefs. It has entered the security and protection business in a big way and has a foothold in the transport industry. It should be noted that it is only a regional body with members mainly in Nairobi, Central and Rift-Valley provinces..

Here kwa kweli Nyambati's Idea is too late
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Friday, 29 June 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company