The Miseducation PDF Print E-mail
Written by Stephen Wanyama   
Wednesday, 14 February 2007

This year thousands of Kenyan students, having completed their secondary education, and desiring to further it by joining a university will have their hopes dashed as the pass mark shifts ever higher with fewer university places to go around.

There are two causes for this predicament. The first is the fact that population growth has far outstripped the growth in University places. The mushrooming of private universities and the provision of parallel courses is a much needed salve but still the gates of the universities are straining at the hinges as more and more clamour for a place in their halls.

The second and perhaps more powerful reason behind this continuous despair is the high social demand among Kenyans for a university degree. It is the cap every educated person must wear, the badge that sets societies' worthies apart from the crowd. So it is that every year, the average Kenyan family pushes itself to the brink of financial disaster, disposing of precious family assets and lifetime savings in an all-out-effort to send their children to university. This all, in the vain attempt to buy their children a way out of the grinding nothingness of the village and urban estate, and thrust them onto the stage of opportunity, wealth and prestige.

Last week, Maseno University Chancellor Prof Bethwel Ogot warned of a further swelling of the disappointed train. The future he says will see only those earning an A- or above in their national exams qualify for entrance into university under the Joint Admissions Board's programme. The rest will have to find some other way, and if the thought of private university, the parallel programmes or study abroad is financially daunting they may settle for a place at one of the nation's polytechnics or even a teacher training college.

Four years later and after a great deal of compromising, if all has gone according to plan, the great halls of knowledge will spit out another great mass of experts in Food Nutrition, Fisheries, Veterinary Medicine, Law, etc who have neither the inclination nor the qualification to take up jobs in these fields. Even sadder, another great number, eager to pursue their career of choice will find that neither the government nor private industry can absorb them. So it is that years after embarking on the trip up the pyramid of knowledge, clawing their way to its very apex, these all will find themselves thrown off just as the notion to raise their hands in victory suggests itself to their minds.

Every year, thousands of Kenyans are taken into jobs that they would have had every competence to take up fresh out of high school, with the same on the job training that they still require after wasting away family resources and personal time in a fruitless pursuit of paper qualifications. So it is that every year, our education throws up thousands more of these servants, totally lacking in independence or creative zeal, all of them seeking the assurance of a secure teat, and with not enough teats to go around, the losers clinging on for sustenance any which way.

And there ends the six-lane highway out of the slums and the villages, bumping unexpectedly into the rude awakening that the immolation of communal wealth in the name of the illusion of material return was unjustified. The great sacrifice and the glaring opportunity cost as we realise that our economic advancement as a nation does not depend on the numbers of graduates, but on their potential for contribution to the national development call out for our attention. The bright lights of the city are not a dream we should discourage, but there are better ways to get there than to preach education as an intrinsic good. More Kenyans need training in technology and advanced service industries, fewer Kenyans need to be trained as hospitality workers or lawyers. The misplaced sacrifice we are making is turning our tertiary institutions, far from engines of growth, into engines of despair and cause of national enervation.

Survival for the fittest is a permissible compromise, but what is not is that the system's rejects leave with little useful knowledge and even worse that they are neutered of their entrepreneurial zeal.


Stephen Wanyama
About the author:




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (17)add
0
Great Insight
written by Amina , February 14, 2007
I could not agree more! While education is key to economic success... Kenya needs to reevaluate its curriculum. As I had said in , a previous thread and as has been reiterated by Chancellor Ogot, we need to invest in polytechnics, and 2yr-colleges. The Kenyan Education curricular has to be designed to reflect the market, which is very different from that of the West.

The great sacrifice and the glaring opportunity cost as we realise that our economic advancement as a nation does not depend on the numbers of graduates, but on their potential contribution to the nation calls out.
This is profound Wanyama, and you should consider sending this piece to the Ministry of Education.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Dancing around a Golden Calf
written by aeichener , February 14, 2007
True. Not only Kenyans, but also other East Africans (Ugandans, Malawians) share an exaggerated cult of formalized education for mere degrees' sake. *Sigh*

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Great great Insights
written by pndiangui , February 14, 2007
Well a great piece and well thought-out.
I however partly agree with you and to some extent disagree.
First is I think seeing an education a means to a job or its application being only a certain job is itself 'demeaning' the noble cause that the philosophers of education set up. Many times the improvement of general knowledge , psychology of living and the ability to complete simple to complex tasks is the essense of education. Rememebr we are talking about 'edu-cation' which is totally differrent from 'training'. The former's meaning would go like trying 'to draw art of' whereby a student is allowed to realize and practice ideas wholly in harmony with their human development. Training on the other hand is totally technical and 'to the point'. I for example have heard many people criticize the shunning out of many liberal arts students in Kenyan universitites but I think they represent a great deal of our Nation's so powerful civil society and downstream their impact is continuing to be felt.
On the other hand as Amina puts it , yes we do need badly those directly trained tchnologists and it has been a failure of both the societal perception of these middle level colleges and village polytechnics as well as the past regime.
The issue here is the striking of a balance between the universities (wich I think we need about 15 more at the moment),the middle level colleges and the Rural polytechnecs.
True we need more R & D in these universities , so a need to balance bettween the lecturer's load in commercialised parallel programs and his time to do research, but again the whole aspect of performance reviews in our universities is fundamentally flawed as is the management of public universities.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
the system
written by anonymous , February 15, 2007
our system takes the best brains and provides them with the worst education.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by emmo opoti , February 15, 2007
It needn't be all bad if the government can channel this excess some other way. For example, advances in IT training and an internet backbone can set up all the accountants churned out by the countless colleges in every little town into a pool of skilled labour for outsourced accounting tasks.

The key is to manage the manpower requirements of industry and government and promote these particular needs at tertiary education levels. For example we still need many many more doctors, I am not sure government spending reflects this, but we must try to push harder for a lower patient:doctor ratio. On the other hand as has been said to often, we suffer a surfeit of lawyers, whose entrepreneurial zeal ( see article) is channelled towards fleecing the public as they await their ascension to the cushy life of the bench.

Ndiangui,
I would suggest we spend the money for the 15 more universities on developing R&D capability at the universities. Perhaps even allow the private sector to sponsor this in lieu of taxes.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Student
written by Peter , February 15, 2007
I am a third year student at Moi University, School of Information Sciences. I have one thing to say: University education is highly overrated.

My school happens to have the best facilities (built by donors from UK) but the stuff we read...people, if it is quality education you are looking for, take your kid to Strathmore of another institution where they take learning seriously.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
the over hyped graduates.
written by kendirangu , February 15, 2007
Got to agree Education is highly overatted in the country. The relevance of some subjects is also disputable especially since the 'western system' of education which we have adopted tends to concentrate on things that are not fully relevant to most Kenyans --> Science. We have a very small R&D and manufacturing industry in the country but looking at the number of engineers being churned out of this institutions I have to wonder where they all end up to.

While we are busy glorifying science and maths we stigmatise people with any other talent and in the process kill creative talents we could harness in sports, media, entertainment and until recently in business. We have also lost focus on things like Agrculture with academic institutions not paying enough attention to our farmers and their growing concerns.

I cant help thinking our own Pele is probably a double maths graduate working as a project manager in mabati rolling mills and feeling very jisty and proud of himself. Not considering the opportunities he missed due to our own dogmas and lack of opportunity and mentoring.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Nope! Engineering & Science sh
written by Honey , February 15, 2007
I beg to strongly differ with kendirangu who stated that math & science need not be so emphasized.

For Kenya to ever get a far, this two areas will have to be worked on, seriously. You cannot harnes sports, media and entertainment without getting the basics right...those basics need science & math! Where will you be sporting, in the bushes.

Africa needs to look at sciences agressively, it matters in such a big way. Ever wonder why the West scrambles hard to 'invent' and 'discover' 'innovate'...it has led to where they are!. A student thinks of a better way to shovel snow, his idea is worked on, and bam, they have it together.

As it is in Africa, there are too many entertainers and talkers.
If I had it my way, some arts/entertainment classes would be abolished altogether.

Africa does not need that now..who to be entertained, the starving?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Amir Ibrahim , February 15, 2007
For once I agree with Honey. While it is important not to stifle young people's dreams, I also believe guidance is of utmost importance.

In today's world, many talented children are taken with the world of materialism and get-rich-quick schemes offered by the media. Sports, dancing, singing- the whole PopIdol world is dangerous for a poor country like ours. Every single member of society must ask himself how he can improve the well-being of the nation, and unless we are seeking Raila's Gross National Happiness, we must do the hard work of science and mathematics.

Wanyama in his article above seems to suggest that more people should be encouraged to go into business, in the manner promoted by Peter N. in the Youth Fund discussion here.

Like we are discussing with regard to black entertainment, sorry black history month on another thread, the reason why the Chinese, the Indians, the Malaysians, etc are doing so much better than us is the fact that they are not afraid to be boring. While we walk about bragging about how well we can dance, or how all the other races envy our sexual prowess, etc the rest of the world is in the labs, or making money off of us.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Tim Norwood , February 15, 2007
In speaking with some Zimbabwean friends, I asked them why they were not giddy with excitement at all the free land they were being given by their government.

I told them how in our country, people in Kisii plant on mabati roofs or large rocks layered with soil. I told them how families are broken and parents murdered for land, but they could not understand. It was Mugabe's fault they said, for over-educating them in the 1980s and 1990s.

While things may be bad in Kenya, I am sure we have it better than many other places. Sure there are many Kenyans who are wary of dirtying their hands with any form of non-white collar work, or of risking life away from the 'security of the teat' but still we have it better than most.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
The \'whole\'
written by pndiangui , February 15, 2007
Emmo, Kendirangu & Honey
I think I might taken a skewed approach in my first comment trying to rail at the weak-points of Kenya's education policy. I apologize.
Lets immerse ourselves in this area and take a holistic approach both from our own insights through observations and experience.
I might be alone on this one , but hell I think the 8.4.4 system was perfectly superior in its design. It only failed in its implementation especially at the detail level of funding, insitutionalizing it and a continous improvement altitude.
At the lower levels of schooling and high school too, as Kendirangu mentioned we did art and design, wood-work, Agriculture and Home-science but we were not nartured into them as possible career routes even those who extremely good at them. Neither the society nor the government or the parents that can escape a blame on this.
For example many Kenyan ladies that I know still point at their high school home science studies as their leverage in them attaining the kind of roving cooking skills in their kitchen that they have today, mine being one!
Many are the times I hear , "I wish I pursued this as a career instead of what I currently do, I love doing it!"
The Motor Mechanics , I have met in Kenya who have superb skills have mentioned to me that they gained an intrest at it from a High school where they worked with power tools or during art and craft work in primary schools. However these people have been seen as the tyical 'failures' in the society. These are small business owners who with good nurturing at the village polytechnics or Middle level colleges followed by free business clinics funded by the state would be owning numerous franchises around East Africa or even Comesa region servicing motorists much better than the your usual con-mechanics in Kirinyaga Road or Eastlands. Much better because more than their superior technical skills they have a passion for the job, they have a vision for their enterprise and integrity has been instilled in them. This just provides a win-win situation for the motorists, the investors, the banks , the community and the government in form of taxes.
The way I see it ,attaining a balance in the education system that we have in terms of implementation and a change of the societies altitude is a must.
Here in Australia the government and the private sector after sufferring high skills shortages in the skilled workers who are more into hands-on tasks like plumbing, bucthering, brick-layering and pipe-laying, has instituted a mass change in mindset about what career skills mean to change both the public and graduates perceptions on those hands-on careers. It has gained grounds; But critics say if taken too far, it might again do more harm than good downstream if falling levels of univerity enrollments are not checked. With mass exodus of High school graduates turning into middle-level colleges, downstream the supply/demand corrects itself in a ruthless manner both for the society at large and the graduates of the same.
The current shortage in Australia has been attributed to the 1990's educatio policy that paid more attention to university level education at a tertiary level rather than balancing the both. The OECD task force on education reforms has castigated the Ausies of the same issue we are complaining about here; A lack of proper training framework for non-university skilling.
This may be where we are at the moment with the university educated graduates. A mis-alignment of supply with the demand and the society needs.
The other day , sveral contractors were complaining of the escalating labour costs in kenya for Real-estate development citing shortage of skilled construction workers like foremen and brick-layers who can use complex machinery, some who who have been snapped up into southern sudan ,and others being paid upward rates and leaving projects incomplete. Other contractors have also cited escalating costs due to shoddy work being done by '4 weeks trained' brick-layers or non-experienced foremen. This is just a bomb-ticking to explode revealing the kind of neglect that has occured for our village polytechnics and middle-level colleges.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
What ails Kenya\'s education.
written by Honey , February 16, 2007
1. With the birth of 8.4.4 came a new defination for excelling in life-a university degree (hata kaa ni matope), and the tertiary institutions were neglected.

2. I am among the kids who worked so hard, for failing to get a spot was largely seen as failing. Looking back, I can only say 8.4.4 was a big joke.
All the music, h/science, woodwork...yet all I wanted to study was math and science.
3. The old guard dont help much. The stance taken by the likes of Prof. Gichaga is only crippling: He maintains a university graduate is a manager!. Ok. but there are too may chiefs and few Indians!. Who will manage who?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
it\'s hypped as hell !!
written by kendirangu , February 16, 2007
Ndiangui, thanks for putting down stuff in plain English.
I didnt say sciences are bad and should be scraped but I still think they are overhypped and given too much attention. Unfortunately at the expense of creative talent.
How many years have those institutions been churning out graduates in sciences and where are the results for this ... how many patents, research papers or innovations do we have to show ?

Why do we have a bsc in automotive engineering doing maintenance work in GM ? a job that is done by a mechanic in Kirinyaga road with a 6 month course and on a quarter of the budget. Or pick a graduate in comp science in Kenya and compare him to one in India, China or Europe and America are they on the same level of productivity ? why spend 4yrs pretending to be busy studying when your resultant output is nothing to be proud of. Apart from pirating software, What the hell are this guys doing in the country anyway ?

We tend to blame govt for all our problems but the productivity of Kenyans (especially the 'educated' ones) is terribly low.

A question we fearlessly need to answer is: What is the return on an investment in education specifically in a Kenyan public institution ? - Apart from the pride of being a graduate and respect undeserved from the rest of society what else is there? In terms of contribution to society and in the solution of our current problems what can we point to?

For those who ask where we will be sporting... you got your head too deep in the science to see. Why not take a look at Nigerian and Senegalese Soccer schools or better still the Ethiopian athelete training camps. This are not milion dollar research centers. they are simple govt supported knowledge transfer institutions no science just plain mentoring. I dont need to state the returns.
Last I recall our atheletes do us proud with gold medals and records broken without stepping foot on those damned shitholes. Their remittances home are much more than they would ever have made in a career in sciences.

If we stop ostracizing non-scientists and farmers, maybe we will realise that they have alot to offer too. For all who think that we should be pouring calculus down the throats of our kids, please show me where the returns are so far.
We need social scientists, good entrepreneurs, bankers, and yes entertainers just as much as we need scientists. However as I noted earlier in my post, we churn this guys out in an economy that is a net importer of finished goods and all they do is maintain finished products imported from other parts of the world.

There is very little innovation in Kenya, too little to warrant the current hype this 'scientists' get.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Puhhleaaase kendirangu
written by Honey , February 17, 2007
I beg to draw from your second last paragraph mister: support, support and lack of it is what has killed science in Kenya. Addd on simplistic imbecillic reasoning from your likes, especially in positions of leadership. Moi did the nation a diservice when he locked out intellectualism in all faces of leadership...we had illiterate buffoons for CBK governor, illiterate army men for the health portfolio petty makangas for decision making, see where it got us!

1. Kemri has suffered a setback in funds, under govts that are willing to import what their own scientists can come up with, under the guise of development & partnership also known as anglofleecing.

2. Korea & its toy Hyundai, they perfected it (of course it was not entertainment) and today, almost all motorvehicles running in Korea are that make. How far was the Nyayo car supported.

3.Proff. Obel has to be in hiding for his work?
4. ICIPE has all kinds of research lying in the shelves, but no, because Luos head it, the govts will not support it.
Not even if it will save them millions in importing DDT.

5.The innovator of Arial (the OMO competitor of the 80's) why was he stopped.

Simple homeborne practical solutions, but no, how will the fat cats of anglofleecing eat if such innovations are encouraged.
Now am sitting here, watching an 18 year old from a neighboring school, who has just won a grant from the UN to come from the US to Kenya and purify water for people in villages. It is the second grant he has won, the first he won at 15 from the govt.

I just finished a research on fresh water lakes and pharmaceuticals, thanks to a govt grant of $10,000 that I got just to do that. I'd never get that support from those dark pot-belly men who head the govt of Kenya-no apologies

This initiatives and incentives dont exist in Kenya, and you wonder why people die of petty things (car accidents, poor roads, disease, hunger) and are so ignorant....because of too many entertainers and talkers!

Flash news- Farming is quite a science in its own right. A Kenyan proffesor here serves locals quite qell, he has been researching on cantaloupes for five years, thanks to the US govt.
Yeah right, as if that wud happen in Kenya.

Man, am so passionate about science...and the lack of support it gets in Africa will drag the continent back foerever.

At the end of the day, the world is a play field for scientistS and mathematicians...the rest are just pawns in the checker game.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Too skewed
written by pndiangui , February 18, 2007
Honey and Ndirangu
We cannot do without R and D. And R and D is not limited to science and mathematics.Neither is entertainment independent of mathematics and science, we cant compartmentalise them like we are doing here. For all to be benefecial they must be acted on with synergestic applications in mind.
Honey your last statement is even more skewed that'...the world is a play field for scientistS and mathematicians...the rest are just pawns in the checker game.'
This sort of a statement seems not to take a synergestic approach to how maths and science can be applied to sort out African mess. Inventions alone dont create jobs, the art of designing and uderstanding social dynamics in order to see the value those inventions can deliver in an economy is inherently important. It guides the commercialization process of those inventions. We also cant rule out the capital markets that provide the necessary funds to commercialize those inventions. What Ken is concerned about is I think R & D without an objective , without looking back to account for the time and money spent on it, hence his capitalistic view of the ROI of science graduates or even R and D for the sake of it. True I can also fault the skewed view that any R and D has to have a 'known' commercial application but there is a need to have a balanced portfolio of such R and D initiatives.
For example the internet and worlwide web emerged from exploratory R and D which wasnt targeted to the discovery of them. Many pharmaceuticals however have emerged from targeted R and D as has the continous improvement of many manufacturing proceses, telcommunications technologies etc.
For that lets stop compartmentalizing subjects , lets take a synergestic and balanced approach to education.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Multiple intelligence
written by kendirangu , February 19, 2007
There are far more levels of intelligence than Logical/mathematical intelligence and to assume that innovation only comes from building on this alone seems a little naive to me.
To further blame the govt for all our woes is also becoming abit too tiring.
There are very few if any developing countries that have anything left in their budgets to allocate for research grants, however innovation has been seen in sciences in even those countries where the govt doesn't directly fund research.
But I digress. My point was and still remains sciences in Kenya are overhypped, way below their productivity. If this wasn't so the results of the emphasis put in this subjects over the years should have begun to show themselves as in the case in countries like China, India and even Egypt.
But we can always blame the govt for everything......
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Govt is the mess!
written by Honey , February 22, 2007
I can name for you 20 innovations that have gone unacknowledged by anyone.
Largely due to illiterate and obtuse leaders, an epidemic that has been Kenya's for a long time.

They'd love to innovate, but how so when kes toothpaste is all over Mombasa?.

Of WWW, I was unfortunate to sit thru alecture on how chemists get it to work...now dont ask me how? but they do some useless number crunching and reasoning that is beyond my very noram abilities.

I also think that we are approaching this from the notion that science and math lovers are nerds who know very little about other fields. Not necessarily true. A good number are very artistic too.

I hype science because it is not about crunching numbers or watching boring happenings, but because it helps one know that at times they must look beyond the problem.

The human brain only gets better wheb used more. The IQ too rises with age, assuming a normal person.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated ( Friday, 02 March 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Login/Register

Login/ Register

click to subscribe
feed image

Contact

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for content related questions and suggestions

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it for republication enquiries

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it to report faults or offensive comment.


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2009 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  The Imagine Company