Leadership, what leadership? - cartoon PDF  | Print |  E-mail
Written by Patrick Gathara   
Saturday, 05 January 2008 13:04
T he crisis in the country is above all attributable to a failure in leadership. None of the protagonists (Mwai Kibaki and Raila Odinga) could bring themselves to rise above their individual interest in securing power.
odm_peace_call.jpg
 click to see larger clearer image

 

They have both deliberately trampled on the national interest in their vain-glorious search for personal fulfilment. Mwai Kibaki, seeking to extend his tenancy at State House undoubtedly stole the election, and thus brought us to the brink of this precipice. However, the ODM candidate Raila Odinga's reaction to this injustice is what is now threatening to push us over the very edge.

Over the past week, Kenyans have been disabused of the notion that we are somehow immune to the sorts of state collapse and genocidal tendencies that characterise much of the rest of Africa. Long touted as "an island of peace and stability" we have suddenly come face to face with the reality that underneath the seeming calm lies a smouldering volcano of disaffection, hate, desperation and fear. It is no coincidence that most of the carnage we are witnessing on our TV screens is visited upon the poor, by the poor.

I live in a middle class housing estate, only a few hundred metres from the Kibera slums. Yet, the place is no need of police protection. None ofthe rioting mobs has ventured close in spite of the lack of a police presence. While looting, chaos and death have reigned within the slum, we have been carying on as normal, only slightly inconvenienced by the fact that the supermarkets, restaurants and bars were closed.

What we are witnessing in Kenya is more than just a political crisis with tribal overtones. It is the result of decades of unequal development that has led to one of the most inequitable societies on earth. The richest 10% (who are drawn from almost every tribe) of our society control the vast majority of our GDP. The people rioting in the streets are part of the 46% of our population that lives on less than $1 a day. They have nothing to lose. 5 years of steady economic growth under Kibaki has clearly demonstrated to them that even in boomtime, they will gain nothing. The UN's Human Development Index indicates that they are worse off today than they were 5 years ago. Inflation is running at levels not seen since the economic collapse of 1990s.

So they jump onto the ODM bandwagon which promises more equitable distribution of resources. It is immaterail that the populist Odinga is one of the wealthiest people in the land. It is also immaterial that he once joined the kleptocratic Moi in government (ironically denouncing the sorts of unlicensed political rallies he is calling for today as "treasous"). All that matters is that he is offering an alternative (however illusory) to a deperate and marginalised people. It is the proverbial straw that the drowning man will clutch for.

Yet, as events in past few days have demonstrated, neither Odinga nor Kibaki have much regard for the suffering of their fellow Kenyans. They are content to issue alarmist and inciting statements from the comfort and safety of their fortified, luxurious homes. Each passing day they polarise the country further with their political brinkmanship.

However, the country is fighting back. Led by the media, artists, businesspeople and trade unionists, many are rejecting the slide towards anarchy. In this, I find a great deal of hope. For if we can develop alternative centres of power and influence, and rob the political class of the all-encompassing grip it has on our collective throat, then future political problems can be quarantined within the political sphere and not allowed to infect the rest of society.


Written on Saturday, 05 January 2008 13:04 by Patrick Gathara

Viewed 1480 times so far. Like this? Tweet it to your followers!

Latest articles from Patrick Gathara

Latest 'tweets' from the imagine company

  • Nancy Jebet takes the gold in the 1500m women's finals. #AfricanAthleticsChampionshipsLinkFriday, 30 July 2010 14:41
wide ad

Trackback(0)
Comments (7)add
0
leaders
written by talktome , January 05, 2008
most resources to especially the rural areas and the poor areas like the slums depend on the area politicians.

estates are built with all the facilities hence who needs a politician?? say in buru buru

But when it comes to election the best and quick vote fix is leaders who play the tribal game, this is now very clear for all even in the west that raaila was a leader of a slum.
This begs the question what has he done for the slum dwellers?
You are luck that the police contained the violence back to railas area others were not luck.
The police force will have to be improved in rural areas of ethnic mix if lives are to be saved.
politicans will have to be charged with inciting violence against humaity and closely monitored.
All funds will have to be channelled independ of any goverment of political affiliations.
Violence over any disputes to deregister all organisation, memeber or party.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by jaya wardene , January 05, 2008
You have touched on a serious problem that faces us the electorate. If someone was to ask me, for instance why I supported the ODM rather than Nazlin Umar or Pius Muiru, candidates who were probably more in tune with the problems facing we the small people, it is quite obvious that only the Money Bags outfits were in a position to pull it off.

Political expression for us the small people has been reduced to a simple strategy summarised thus:

Who has the deepest pockets

Who can pull the biggest and rowdiest crowds

Who can brazenly and shamelessly rig an election the fastest

As long as we live in a split society living parallel lives rent by gaping inequalities we will continue to look to the Money Bags for salvation despite all our collective disappointments in the past.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by knjenga , January 05, 2008
I have a nagging sense that this issue is bigger than both Raila and Kibaki. We cannot get away from the role of our personal and individual responsibility of how we have conducted ourselves in the aftermath of the elections. No amount of blame trading or rationalizing will ever account for the fact that we killed our own brothers and sisters and or, that we burned, stole and destroyed their property or that we shot them in the back.
Our collective and colossal failure to do the right thing slaps and lays bare and naked our espoused peace loving and religious nature of the Kenya people. Our leaders have always been selfish and narcissistic, we should not be surprised by their supposed inaction. What is really shocking is that we have shown that they are actually a mirror reflection of our values and aspirations. We are all to blame and the solutions lie in our individual actions.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by jmaruru , January 05, 2008
It hurts me so bad to admit that Yes, I am part of the problem. When I stand in line to vote for no other reason than 'so and so politicain' comes from my tribe, when I let myself believe that even in peace my tribe is 'better' than the 'other'. We have let ourselves be molded into a selfish society that does not think beyond our individual tribes. And that is why politician can singlehandedly turn us into tribalistic genocidal hooligans who have no care for Kenya or my brothers and sisters, Kenyans.
I am so proud of all those who have decided to alternatively go out and help someone who needs Kenya, no matter the tribe.
I am so proud of the media houses and other voices who have devoted themselves to spread the idea of peace and hope.
And even as I watch events unfold with a little fear, I am hopeful that Kenyans are coming out of this smarter and better.
I am praying so hard that on Monday we will go back to work, start rebuilding our lives and move on.
Should the political bigshots decide to fight it out, I am hoping that you and I will not believe that we can help them by going out to the streets to kill each other.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Bwana KO
written by Kamau Ochieng , January 05, 2008
I cannot see what else that left out there in regards to the Elections and the Violence that has not already been touched on this website.

We need a way in which we can start a sequence of events that fully state our disgust at what our leaders are doing. We can discuss till we blue but thats just it A discussion. Now that we have identified the problem areas. WHAT ELSE CAN WE DO,
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
D.O. Misiani
written by Beta , January 05, 2008
As I write this, I'm listening to Bwana D.O. Misiani (RIP). I'm Kikuyu and I love this guy's music. I don't understand a word he's saying but, love the beat. I will buy his music spontaneously because he's got the beat that I really like.
I attend athletic meets and watch marathons excitedly. I'm just awed by how talented our largely kalenjin athletes are. Jepkosgei (800M World Champion) will give you a rush after you've watched her perform and dominate. Lel, Tergat, R. Rop, R. Cheruiyot, et al are all a joy to watch and the best ambassadors Kenya has outside of our borders. I love them, support them and wish they were given greater roles to play in our society once they retire. Because, let's face it: they've earned it.
Now, I may not be able to love all Luos and all Kalenjins alike but I will cherish some for what they say/do. I believe I speak for most everyone in the world when I say I'm not immune to tribal prejudices. People tend to gravitate towards their own before they reach our to those outside their groups. Look around and tell me what you see.
As a nation, we've survived by coercive bonding and tolerance. The colonialists drew our borders and forced the Kenyan identity on us. Given a choice right now, I doubt many of the ethnic groups would want to be included in the union known as "Kenya". But, it is what it is. We must all suck it up and make it work. There really is no other choice.
Kenyatta and Moi used force to keep the nation together. Kibaki experimented with increase in democratic space and tolerance. Look where we now find ourselves: divided, bitter and with increased unbridled sense of entitlement (those in power feel entitled to keep it, while the opposition feel entitled to take over through an election that can hardly be deemed free and fair).
Now what? We'll first retreat to our tribal safeties, angry that the others are screwing us hard (as evident from the ground, this forum and others across the web). We'll accuse and counter-accuse, exhibit belligerent chest-thumping, make a failed attempt at political horse trading, and poor people will die. Then this phase of life will pass.
I love the lessons history teaches. Kenya 1992 is a case in point. Being young and naive, I kept telling myself the world would end if Moi "didn't go".People were hungry for change; they fought, they died, then Moi stayed put for another 5 years.
Kenya will survive the current wave of political uncertainty. The question that will linger is: when will be the next show?
Meanwhile, I will still blare my Misiani tracks and idolize my Kalenjin athletes. I'll continue to work my butt off, hustle and hope, so my children can eat and go to school.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
What are our leaders doing?
written by Kay , January 05, 2008
Do they think they are helping the refugees in their own country by JUST visiting them in the slums? While they are at it why don't they carry some relief food, clothes, etc for them...the media houses, some individuals, red cross amoung other organisations are doing a better job compared to those who caused this problem.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
Last Updated on Saturday, 05 January 2008 17:11