400 dead and not a tear from the ODM PDF  | Print |  E-mail
Written by Brian Muthiora   
Monday, 21 January 2008 09:23
R Rasna Warah's article published in the Daily Nation on 21 January 2008 betrays a sense of reckless indifference to the plight of the victims of the violence meted out on certain communities in the Rift Valley suspected to have voted "against the grain."
This indifference runs through the ODM leadership and is not unique to Ms. Warah. 

The article idolizes the death of a male protestor in Kisumu as a source of "our" inspiration adding that "tears are being shed for him by people that never met or knew him". Ms. Warah remains silent on the misery in the Rift Valley following massacres that left hundreds dead in Eldoret, Cherengany, Londiani, Kipkelion, Msambweni and elsewhere. These dead were targeted merely because of their mother-tongue and supposed political affiliation. 

Is the death of one protestor any more significant than the deaths of 400 Kenyans "cleansed" in the Rift Valley? Are we not to draw any inspiration from the deaths of these hundreds of innocents? 

Whilst I do not intend at all to excuse the actions of the policeman that allegedly shot dead the young man in Kisumu, it saddens me that the ODM and ODM leaning commentators (and here I make no judgment as to Ms. Warah's political affiliation) find it unworthy of their effort to comment on the tragedy unfolding in the Rift Valley. 

On the contrary, the ODM, with their mastery of propaganda, appear to have succeeded in turning the media cameras, local and international attention away from the plight of the many faceless and nameless victims in the Rift Valley (mostly Kikuyu and Kisii) that went through the most horrifying deaths at the hands of ODM supporters. They would want the world to believe that the killings and evictions in the Rift Valley were a spontaneous reaction to the announcement of Kibaki's re-election. All evidence, however, urges us to a conclusion that the murderous mobs acted on the instruction (or incitement) of their leaders in a well-choreographed campaign that bears all the evidence of discipline and organisation. 

The Rift Valley case is a monumental humanitarian catastrophe compared with the accidental deaths of far fewer youth in Kisumu who, and this must be pointed out, made the conscious decision to exit their homes and engage in riots, rape, looting, vandalism and arson; or to stand in the company of individuals engaged in such crimes. The mobs in Kisumu and elsewhere put their lives on the line knowing fully well that their violent protests (for they did not appear to be peaceful) would be met with equal or greater force. The destruction of Kisumu and the large turnout of these groups continued even after news of the deaths of rioters had filtered out across the country. There was little if any innocence in those who came out onto the streets.

The young man in Kisumu had a few choices: he could have vented his anger at the election results in a more civil and peaceful manner; he could have opted to stay away from the mayhem; or he could have chosen to participate in the mayhem with the attendant risks. We all know he chose the latter and would not have died had he applied prudent judgment not to attend the protests called by Raila Odinga or if he had kept the peace. By taunting and exposing himself to armed policemen, policemen who were on duty to quell riots and the destruction of Kenya's third largest city, the probability of injury or even death was high.

The death of any Kenyan, it must be said is truly tragic, but those in he ODM crying over this particular death are only trying to score political points.  The party's top leadership conveniently shows no remorse for the Rift Valley victims, and even goes as far as to excuse the actions of their assailants. Whereas anger is a legitimate emotion, the manner in which these murderers vented that anger cannot be excused or swept under the carpet.

In contrast to the Kisumu incidents, it is well documented that many of the victims in Eldoret and other parts of Rift Valley died at the hands of armed gangs who either hacked them to death or burned them alive. These crimes were committed against people sleeping in their homes, fleeing the North Rift or most memorably seeking refuge in a church. These quite clearly are not the same as the deaths in Kisumu. The Rift Valley murderers walked out of their houses with murderous intent. The Rift Valley victims did not taunt their assailants, they did not transgress against them or do anything that would warrant the brutal violence that ushered them to their deaths. 

The people in Eldoret didn't have the same luxury of wealth choice that those in Kisumu had. They were condemned not for any action, but for simply being. Even as they fled, even under military escort, they were still hunted for their difference.

Predictably, the ODM does not want Kenyans to interrogate these different scenarios. It is not politically expedient for them as it would show the unrighteousness of their crusade. They demand an equivalence between these two different tragedies, and refuse to contemplate the differences.

So whilst I empathise with the family of Kisumu man for their loss, my heart goes out to the injured, dead and displaced in the Rift Valley. Most of all, I am touched by those that have decided, in spite of the imminent danger, to count their losses and move back to their farms and start rebuilding. These resilient folk are my inspiration, they are the true heroes.


Written on Monday, 21 January 2008 09:23 by Brian Muthiora

Viewed 1786 times so far. Like this? Tweet it to your followers!

Latest articles from Brian Muthiora

Latest 'tweets' from the imagine company

  • Nancy Jebet takes the gold in the 1500m women's finals. #AfricanAthleticsChampionshipsLinkFriday, 30 July 2010 14:41

Trackback(0)
Comments (35)add
 1 2 > 
0
...
written by Nori , January 21, 2008
Flaws were noted in the manner that votes were tallied at KICC. The ODM leadership pleaded with ECK commissioner to look into the issue before announcing the results to dispell those "rumours" that rigging had taken place. The Human Rights Society leadership and international observers shared the same thoughts as did ODM. Mutahi Ngunyi a GEMA who is a well know political analyst expressed views that announcing those results without correcting the anomalies will lead to big problem in Kenya. But Kivuitu through Kibaki and Kalonzo gave them a deaf ear. According the police spokesman, they expected violence for two to three days before everything else returned to "normalcy".

The problem is not therefore the actual murderers or looters and rapists. The problem is the person who created room for all this hooliganism to take place. If Kibaki trully believed and still believes that he won the elections, why did he object for a re-run or re-tallying of votes? Had accepted this then those looters/rapists and murderers would not have gone on rampage. Or at least he should have allowed the ODM leadership to address their people peacefully and provide security as is stipulated in the Kenyan constitution that he is supposedly defending. Instead he decided to repulsed them through the GSU with very brutal force.The same force that should have been applied in Kuresoi or Mt. Elgon where Kenyans were being terrorised on a daily basis.

It is true and sad that Kenyans of all origins have suffered and yet they did not deserve to suffer. Please let us all look at the root cause and address it accordingly other than blame each other. The root cause must be addressed now exaustively lest we experience a repeat or even worse of what has happened to our beloved country.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Excellent Writing
written by Advocatus Diaboli , January 21, 2008
This is an absolutely superb piece of work, Muthiora. You put across your case eloquently and have something for the heart as well as for the mind without unduly valourising your cause or gratuitously vilifying your opponents.

Kudos for doing "as adversaries do in law, strive mightily, but eat and drink as friends.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Nori
written by Timothy Wainaina , January 21, 2008
Please peruse the collection of photographs at the end of this link, the violence started way before Kivuitu's announcement.

Link here

The ODM had already ordained that any result beside an ODM victory would have been the result of rigging, nothing else would satisfy them.


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Bad journalism at its worst
written by aeichener , January 21, 2008
Indeed! Among the many many bad and clueless articles by Rasna Warah over the times, this was certainly one of her worst. It is a shame that the Nation will publish just about anything from their steady columnists without any kind of proper editorial review.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Hope for Kenya?
written by Wuod Aketch , January 21, 2008
Some stories bring back hope and hints that, all is not lost :


Joseph Kariuki, 35, a Kikuyu born and raised in Kisumu, says he will not leave the city where his father settled in 1934.

Unlike many others, Kariuki did not lose anything during the riots. He speaks Luo, the language of opposition leader Raila Odinga's ethnic group, and his linguistic skills saved him.

"I speak better Luo than Kikuyu. I've never left Kisumu and I don't even know where my father hails from in central Kenya. Kisumu is my home and I have nowhere to run to," he said.

http://www.alertnet.org/thenew...166551.htm
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nori , January 21, 2008
The manner in which the results were announced to Kenyans caused anxiety and raised many questions. Why were media houses asked to stop announcing those results? Why were parliamentary votes announced before presidential votes in some constituencies and yet they are supposed to be released at the same time. Why did Kivuitu announce to Kenyans and the world that some of his returning officers after announcing paliarmentary results switched off their phones and went underground? Why were some presidential votes in some constituencies more than the registered number of voters. These were some of the actions that led to most Kenyans percieve presidential results having been riged hence the anger.

For your information, I personally received sms warning of certain things that will hapen which eventually turned out to be true on 29th December, 2007, which left me perplexed. My rental house was burned down on 30th December, 2007 at 7.00 PM because one of the tenants belonged to a certain tribe. Although I am lucky not to have lost a family member or close relative or friend, my only source of income is gone and I have no capital to rebuild the house. I will never blame the people who burned my house down. I blame our leadership more so the Government for failing to provide security to Kenyans who are law abiding and tax payers. The systems we have in place should be changed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nyabs , January 21, 2008
I mourn the death of the young man and note that investigations are underway. If the police officer exceeded his mandate and killed unecessarily, then the full force of the law should apply to him.

That said, I am saddened by the shallowness and insensitivity of Rasnah's article. As Muthiora has pointed out, the young man had a range of options and if he had chosen the more sensible options, he would be alive and well. The children, women and men who have lost their lives at the hands of hate filled gangs did not have these options and have died cruel and unecessary deaths.Many continue to live in fear and desperation in displaced people's camps.

The heroes I am looking for are those members of the Kalenjin and Luo communities who have chosen not to tread the path of hatred and have instead chosen to hide and protect their neighbours and friends from harm. My heroes are also members of the central Kenyan, Kisii and Kamba who, inspite of the justification and ample opportunities provided, have chosen not to revenge and continue living peacefully together with people who would be considered their adversaries. It is such that give me hope for the Kenyan nation in these dark days.

Glorifying a demonstrator who went out of his own volition to taunt the police is not what I expected from Rasnah.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re:
written by aeichener , January 21, 2008
I will never blame the people who burned my house down.


As you wish. However, then you deserve to have it burned down. Be glad you are alive. Deservedly?

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nori , January 21, 2008
@Alexander. Unless the underlying factors, the root cause of the violence is exaustivley addressed and not swept under the carpet, calm will return but the bitterness and anger will never go away.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re:
written by aeichener , January 21, 2008
@Alexander. Unless the underlying factors, the root cause of the violence is exaustivley addressed and not swept under the carpet, calm will return but the bitterness and anger will never go away.


I fully agree that calm is not equivalent with peace. The now very necessary quick restoration of order - if necessary, with fire and sword, since conditions like the road blocks in RV cannot be tolerated even for one day - can only be a very first and preliminary step on the long way to a true and lasting peace.

And indeed, if one subscribes to such a more spiritual understanding of the loaded notion of "peace", then one can contend inhowfar Kenyans really ever had such "peace" since colonization. There has been an undeclared war of the possessing against the depossessed for a long, long time, as well as a gender war, and not-yet-uhuru did not change a iota; rather it fortified and cemented some existing structures, and worsened others.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Who is being sacrificed?
written by Wuod Aketch , January 21, 2008
Kibaki is sacrificing people from his tribe on the altar of greediness. His actions here show where his priority lies - making money while Kenyans are suffering. He is now asking for advice for survival from some businessmen. Are these the business friends that ODM is talking about?

Kibaki meets business owners : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...ature=user

Kibaki does not care about the raia that you see in the vdo below who are relying on charity for food and clothing:

More people run away from violence Jan20, 08 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...ature=user
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by j.shery , January 21, 2008
well, yes.. the government should have done more, should be doing more... but it never has and i think we all know it never will... what i find absolutely repugnant, to say the least, is kenyans going on the rampage, killing each other and afterwards crying foul... while you riot and get yourself shot at... the cause of the whole mayhem are sitting in their palaces, their income and families secure... why not attack the perpetrators... who is it who rigged the polls... the wananchi or the presidential candidates? what happened to logical thinking??? If Odinga were to lose a loved one, get his house burnt down and his only source of income taken away brutaly... if his daughter, wife or mother were to be brutaly raped and left for dead, would he call for another rally... if he were to face death in the hands of a neighbour trying to hack him to pieces.. would he call for another rally... Odinga on Hardtalk/ BBC was asked if he supported the idea of sanctions to the Kibaki government and he said yes without batting an eyelid... who suffers most from sanctions, i ask??? He said there was nothing he could have done about the killings and that what we saw was a reaction to police brutality... i wonder how raping a child fits that picture... how does beating/hacking a fellow human being to death fit that picture? If you ask me... we have all failed: the gorvernment for not providing enough security... but why should it... the more deaths and rampage, the worse ODM and its people look... ODM for being so selfish and reckless ... and we as kenyans for being so stupid as to actually go to the streets... forgive my unpatriotic thoughts... but there is no such thing as a peaceful demonstration in a third world country... it's the perfect opportunity for hooligans to go on the rampage... we are acting like animals with no ability to think rationally, if at all... and while we point a finger, we forget that at least three of the fingers on that hand are pointing right back at us....

PS: Rasnah Warah's article may be shallow but she certianly didn't forget the deaths elsewhere... read the last 3 paragraphs... her sin is concentrating on one unfortunate (suicidal???)demonstrator foolish enough to think taunting a policeman in kenya is good entertainment... or whatever it is that may have been going through his mind at the time... there are no heroes in this saga
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Let us face it
written by daja , January 21, 2008
Whereas I understand your frustration and anger, it is wrong for you to imply that the young man, who as any Kenyan has a right to demonstrate, somehow deserved to die. Mrs Rasna did not in any way say that the victims of violence in the RV were less deserving of any sympathy. She chose her point of view which in my opinion is equally important as the position most commentators in the Nationmedia take. The truth is this monster was going to explode one day. I am sad to say that it is Kibaki unlocked this thing by stealing the election. Have a nice day
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
re: Let us face reality
written by aeichener , January 21, 2008
Whereas I understand your frustration and anger, it is wrong for you to imply that the young man, who as any Kenyan has a right to demonstrate, somehow deserved to die.


No, he did hardly "deserve" to die, certainly less than such ODM politicians as Ruto, Kosgei, Kosgey, Ntimama... and we could add an equal number of criminal PNU crooks for good balance.

However, he chose to participate in an armed attack against equally armed (and rather exasperated) AP riot police, and was in the middle of the attackers.

This was not a peaceful demonstrant in a peaceful manifestation of civil resistance, let that be very clear. While I cannot say that he himself threw a stone, the guy immediately to his right with the orange shirt (left from our side) did so - he violently hurled a stone against police. That is an assault with a deadly weapon and *can* (need not) justify the counter-use of deadly force. Of course, the law of proportionality must be observed, and milder measures of force have precedence, when viable.

The guy in the black t-shirt did (in the filmed excerpt of the clip) only taunt, mock and insult the police, first by doing a cartwheel or half somersault showing his behind, then by doing a monkey dance and grimaces. Neither justifies being shot, there you are certainly correct.

And it indeed appears that the killer was NOT the policeman who was running with his AK rifle at the right side, partially covered by the sheds, but one or some of his collegues, maybe while the youths were still hurling stones. When the police officer finally met them around the corner, they were already lying on the soil.

Had he wanted to kill them, it would have been the easiest thing in the world, to finish them off with shots at close distance - but he DIDN'T do that. He DID not, though he had every chance.

Instead, there was apparently an exchange of words with the young man who rose and walked towards the policeman, then slumped back again. The officer kicked him several times in the ribs, but that was all. All the shots he fired there when standing before the two men were in the air, respectively at further away targets.

Alexander
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Savages
written by cicero , January 21, 2008
If there is any symbol worth sentimentalizing over is that of a crippled woman whom The Nation had run a feature before she met her cruel death...all that was left of her's were the charred remains of her wheelchair.

Has Brian emailed that UN woman this article?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Vikii , January 21, 2008
This is a wonderful post Brian muthiora. As much as nobody deserves to die, I find the shallowness that ODM supporters want to engage in ridiculous. Raila justifying the burning of women in an Eldoret churh (Hardtalk) then heading to the City mortuary and shedding some crocodile tears(after making sure the cameras are flashing)and accusing the government of targeting "ODM supporters" just shows you the levels we have sank to.

The man was not supposed to be shot, but if we can engage in some comparison, he probably deserved it more than those children and women burned in Eldoret. He was in the company of stonethrowers and arsonists (Notice how reluctant I am to call him these) and so he was guilty by association. What did those victims of arson do to deserve that craze?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by manta ray , January 21, 2008
Now Raila is claiming he will take the Kenya Police to the Hague. I wish he does so as soon as possible, because he will find himself in that dock together with Ruto and Kosgei faster than he can fly Ali's file to that city.
The charges against him and his cohorts will stick, once the evil barbarism and mindless savagery of what they executed is brought to the world, especially when the very sad story of that disabled woman burnt alive in that church because she could not move is narrated.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
WAKE UP -- You\'re being playe
written by interested spectator , January 21, 2008
Incoherent worldwide conspirationalism (from Kenya to New Hampshire) deleted. Ed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Muthiora
written by Michael , January 21, 2008
The gross ignorance of people is used by politicians in a most calculated manner. This ignorance is the fuel of the ethno-fascism erupting today in Kenya. Shameless politicians are fanning the flames of ethno-fascism, knowing full well the consequences. This is a great evil.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Nori , January 22, 2008
@J.Shery. THERE ARE PEACEFULL DEMONSTRATIONS IN KENYA AND THIRD WORLD COUNTRIES. There was one witnessed in Kapsabet. Police were no where to be seen and the people of Kabsabet in thousands held PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATIONS FOR MORE THAN THREE HOURS. They later converged at a market and their leaders addressed them and went home without destroying anyone's property last week. DEMONSTRATORS ONLY RETALIATE AT THE BRUTALITY OF THE POLICE MET AT THEM. In some parts of Kenya, I witnessed police telling protesters to destroy and steal property. Some of the property was sold to the same police at the same venue. I witnessed police buying mobile phones stolen in their presence at Kshs. 300/-!!!!!!!!!

For your information, I do not believe that all those hooligans are ODM supportes. The hooligans are taking advantage of the situation. A situation created after elections were percieved rigged. The looser crying foul play and the winner claiming free and fair elections. The looser comes up with evidence but the winner turns a blind eye to the looser. The looser calls for a rally to vent his anger and probably explain to the world what he thinks happened. But the winner bars the looser from meeting his supoters, reasons for doing so are best known to him.

I am even sure that those rapists do not have a voters card and they care less whether Kibaki, Raila or Kalonzo won or whether elections were rigged.

I do not understand why everyone is always asking Raila what he will gain through mass action. Why cant you ask Kibaki what he will loose if he accepted a re-tallying of votes or even a presidential re-run, after all he won fairly and he will still win fairly. We all know where the problem lies but unfortunately, we are all shying away from addressing the problem due to reason best known to us. While we are all guilty in this play, I believe that the one man who is more guilty is Kibaki in liaison with Kivuitu and his croonies "those people who GOd should never have brought to this world" as Kivuitu put it.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Called Em all out
written by Obamab , January 22, 2008
An after thought.... Brian Muthiora you should be ashamed of using this forum to highlight your own prejudices. Your comments I have found particularly disturbing and will take time to go through point for point to illuminate what Im saying

indifference runs through the ODM leadership and is not unique to Ms. Warah

This a trivial attack of Ms. Warah, and should be called as such. She was decide to comment on something that we all watched and were astounded by. Just that she had the platform to voice her interpretation.

The article idolizes the death of a male protestor in Kisumu as a source of our inspiration adding that tears are being shed for him by people that never met or knew him

And Why not he did what you and me did not have the balls to do.

Is the death of one protestor any more significant than the deaths of 400 Kenyans cleansed in the Rift Valley? Are we not to draw any inspiration from the deaths of these hundreds of innocents?

On the contrary, the ODM, with their mastery of propaganda, appear to have succeeded in turning the media cameras, local and international attention away from the plight of the many faceless and nameless victims in the Rift Valley (mostly Kikuyu and Kisii) that went through the most horrifying deaths at the hands of ODM supporters

this is the most untrue statement of all, and it is a repulsive thought to think that you truly believe that the statement is true. The reality of the plight of the people in the rift are being highlighted and condemned in equal measure. The Propaganda that you speak about might be the one that you are bringing to the table with the article and such statements.

The young man in Kisumu had a few choices: he could have vented his anger at the election results in a more civil and peaceful manner; he could have opted to stay away from the mayhem; or he could have chosen to participate in the mayhem with the attendant risks. We all know he chose the latter and would not have died had he applied prudent judgment not to attend the protests called by Raila Odinga or if he had kept the peace. By taunting and exposing himself to armed policemen, policemen who were on duty to quell riots and the destruction of Kenya's third largest city, the probability of injury or even death was high.

Though the action by the young man might be thought as irrational by clear headed individuals like you and me, the reality is that we are cowards who will not show the same courage that the young man did, by picking the option to go out there to show the disdain we feel about the government and the stealing of the elections, and the continual impunity that is displayed by the government on the will of the people. He is a HERO, he will be the forgotten heroes of this struggle and just like the many before will be villainsed by people like you and other commenters who think that what he was doing was stupid.

The death of any Kenyan, it must be said is truly tragic, but those in he ODM crying over this particular death are only trying to score political points

The killing of the young man by police is not about scoring points. It is a natural indignation that comes from watching someone loose his life in cold blood. Just to have the Police Spoke person gives a bunch of baloney about what we watched with our eyes. The death was not highlighted by ODM, rather by the media, who were doing their best to keep us informed of what was going on.

In contrast to the Kisumu incidents, it is well documented that many of the victims in Eldoret and other parts of Rift Valley died at the hands of armed gangs who either hacked them to death or burned them alive. These crimes were committed against people sleeping in their homes, fleeing the North Rift or most memorably seeking refuge in a church. These quite clearly are not the same as the deaths in Kisumu. The Rift Valley murderers walked out of their houses with murderous intent. The Rift Valley victims did not taunt their assailants, they did not transgress against them or do anything that would warrant the brutal violence that ushered them to their deaths.

And here you go again justifying the death of the young man. Why are you equating this to the rift valley deaths. These guys chose to go out there to demonstrate and where met with deadly force. I will not touch the Rift Valley deaths because because Im calling you out on the shallowness of painting the young man as a villain instead of exalting his cause, his democratic right to demonstrate albeit any police presence. You have decided to view the story of the young man in the prism of a middle class apologist who has something to lose, who believes that life should continue as is.

Predictably, the ODM does not want Kenyans to interrogate these different scenarios.

ODM has no control over what is aired in the media, nor do they have a mysterious way of controlling what is going to be discussed by the nation. Such senseless base stirring comments are example of what has lead to the polarization of the country. Please desist from making such false comments.

I will also sympathize with the people who have been displaced due to the ethnic cleansing that has occurred. Unfortunately, the people who have chosen to take the street with the eminent threat of bullets being put through there youthfully bodies are my Heroes.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Blinders.... Seriously
written by Obamab , January 22, 2008
Are we missing the point here... the story by Rasna Warahs is to highlight the plight of the demonstrators. The Killing of innocent demonstrators (we shall not pass judgment) are we justifying the killings by POLICE... of the youth in Kisumu and by extension in Kibera, Huruma and Mathare etc. We should be joining in protesting, but here we are congratulating a government apologist for government ineptitude in dealing with the looters and the rift valley cleansing. What does the shooting of demonstrators in Kisumu have with the killings in the Rift Valley, are the police killings tribal as well or are they politically incited are they organized as being purported by various a commenter.

Bottom line the deaths should be condemned, by all, but the government should be held at a higher standard for not following the rule of law. The killing of the young people who are demanding their rights notwithstanding the looting that seems to be going on, should not be encouraged by writings.
Review the footage being referenced and tell me that the killing of these young men is the same as the brutal deaths in the Rift Valley

(Disingenuous link to a manipulated and shortened version of the KTN video clip erased. Here is the link to the full version instead, which gives a very different picture of the events. Eds.)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcJqA2bdIyc
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Neither is crying
written by Amina , January 22, 2008
The Daily Nation's Macharia Gaitho:
Nothing could be more hypocritical than a bunch of politicians pretending to grieve over the dead, when they are salivating over the opportunity presented for propaganda points.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
THE DAY OF THE AFRICAN CHILD
written by truth be told , January 22, 2008
The Day of African Child marks a 1976 march in Soweto South Africa, when thousands of black school children took to the streets to protest the inferior quality of their education and to demand their right to be taught in their own language. Hundreds of young boys and girls were shot down; and in the two weeks of protest that followed, more than a hundred people were killed and more than a thousand were injured.

In a major way it was the beinning of the end of the apartheid system..The demostrators could have chosen a better way or a sensible way and apartheid will still be here with us.

The mau mau could have chosen a more sensible way and we still could be under the colonialists

Is Matiba had chosen a more sensible way he could be in good health and enjoying his health unfortunately he chose to sacrifice please Muthiora be seious
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by truth be told , January 22, 2008
The Day of African Child marks a 1976 march in Soweto South Africa, when thousands of black school children took to the streets to protest the inferior quality of their education and to demand their right to be taught in their own language. Hundreds of young boys and girls were shot down; and in the two weeks of protest that followed, more than a hundred people were killed and more than a thousand were injured.

They were SUICIDAL against the overwhelming force of the police and we salute them
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by truth be told , January 22, 2008
[b]This is article is a good example of what i could call ethnic intelectualism .It is being exhibited by both sides of the political divide
Kindly look and read the statement by the Kikuyu lawyers

Or listen to Cardinal Njue


Insults unbacked by argument are unwelcome here. If you have a point to make, make it civilly and briefly. Thanks, Ed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
Kenya Burning
written by truth be told , January 22, 2008
Drums, dancing greet Kenya opposition leader
Mon 21 Jan 2008, 13:53 GMT

By Guled Mohamed
KISUMU, Kenya (Reuters) - Fanatical supporters of Kenya's opposition leader Raila Odinga banged drums, danced and blew whistles on Monday as the former political prisoner returned to his western stronghold of Kisumu.
The veteran politician is fighting the toughest battle of his turbulent career to try to win back what he considers his stolen victory in December 27 polls, a disputed vote which saw President Mwai Kibaki re-elected.

Nowhere is his backing more fierce than in Kisumu, an industrial town perched on the edge of Lake Victoria in Nyanza province near where he was born.
So rapturous was his welcome back after three weeks of violence across the nation that the ceremony he attended for those killed in the unrest turned into a political rally.
Police have crushed previous efforts to hold rallies in the flashpoint town with an iron fist, shooting dead scores of demonstrators -- many of them as they tried to flee.
"This was supposed to be a mourning ceremony but it seems Raila's homecoming has overshadowed the funeral service here," said Terry Sylvenas, a 40-year-old mother-of-two.
"People are dancing their hearts out and praising Raila."
More than 650 people have died across Kenya and a quarter of a million have been displaced since the vote in some of the worst unrest in living memory. Kisumu -- Kenya's third largest city -- has been among the hardest hit.
"We will not be cowed by guns, handcuffs and prison," Odinga told frenzied crowds in the town's stadium.
His supporters called for arms and waved banners reading "We want guns, we want guns!" and "Give us guns and they will see!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Brian Muthiora , January 22, 2008
@smilies/grin.gifaja, I have not suggested that the young man deserved to die. As Alexander has said, he was, sadly, the author of his misfortune by tempting death.

@Cicero, yes, I sent Rasna Warah an abridged version of this article, also more personalised.

(Please let our readers know if, when and how she responds. Thanks. Eds.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
we need to struggle for democr
written by Matiba na Rubia Tuna Wakumbuka , January 22, 2008
Hey Muthiora Which law is the police using to stop the demostrations
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Brian Muthiora , January 22, 2008
@Obamab, I am not an apologist for anyone and I do not use this forum for propaganda. The post above simply highlights the fallacy of glorifying a young man in Kisumu who died in a most unfortunate way, when the nation faces a far larger catastrophe in the North Rift where hundreds have died horrifically and thousands more have been displaced.

The young man
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
 1 2 > 
You can add your comment here

busy
Last Updated on Thursday, 03 April 2008 01:27